All posts by webadmin

Rajesh Sharma chose Army, set family tradition

Was awarded Shaurya Chakra for bravely fighting terrorists at Akshardham Temple

Col Dilbag Dabas (Retd)

Rajesh had always abided by the advice of his parents in letter and in spirit except once when he was in his late teens. For once he defied his parents and even had his way but only after he had convinced them. Since he was good in academics right from the beginning, his father Dr Puran Chand Sharma wanted him to become a doctor or an engineer or pursue higher education and take up a good white collar job. Rajesh, however, had already chosen the career for himself and spoke his heart: “Papa, naukri hi karni hai to fauj ki karunga aur aise karunga ki aapko apne bête par garv hoga”.

Even his mother Reshma Sharma was not comfortable sending her only son to the Army but the reason she gave, “Beta, hamare khandan mein to fauj mein jaane ka rivaz hi nahi hai” did not convince Rajesh. He spoke most cordially yet confidently, “Mummy, main ye riwaz shuru karna chahta hun”. Realising the patriotic fervour of young Rajesh, the Sharmas happily allowed their only son have his way.

Rajesh was born in Kirori village of Hisar district on February 15, 1975. After senior secondary from Vaish School and graduation from Maharishi Dayanand University, both in Rohtak, he joined the prestigious Indian Military Academy, Dehradun, and was commissioned into 6th Battalion of Rajputana Rifles Infantry Regiment on December 6, 1997. After two years, Rajesh Sharma, as a young Captain, moved to 2nd Rajputana Rifles and was part of this battalion during its outstanding performance in the Kargil War. 

Captain Rajesh Sharma, for his demonstrated courage during the Kargil War, was absorbed in a newly raised Parachute Battalion. After three months of probation and five mandatory parachute jumps, he was permanently seconded to Parachute Regiment as a promising paratrooper. The National Security Guard (NSG), always on the lookout for the daredevils, found one and got Capt Rajesh Sharma posted on its establishment. It is during his challenging deputation with the NSG that Captain Rajesh Sharma exhibited the stuff he was made of when he almost single-handedly flushed out and eliminated two terrorists from the Akshardham Temple complex in Gandhi Nagar (Gujarat). For his daredevil act, Captain Rajesh Sharma was deservedly awarded the Shaurya Chakra. His citation for the award is available with the NSG as well as 23rd Parachute Battalion.

Rajesh, now a Colonel, after successfully commanding a Parachute Battalion in an operational area, is at present serving as Colonel General Staff (Planning) in the headquarters of a field formation.

Colonel Rajesh Sharma, the Shaurya Veer, too, has a son. For the past 21 years, his mother has watched him serve the motherland with pride and honour and is proud of her son. In fact, she is eagerly awaiting for the big day when her grandson too dons the oval greens and carries forward the glorious ‘rivaz’ started by his father.

The account of his bravery in War Diary of 23rd Parachute Battalion reads…

On September 24, 2002, some armed terrorists entered the Akshardham Swamy Narayan Temple complex in Gandhi Nagar (Gujarat) and started firing indiscriminately. The terrorists killed 30 people and injured over 100 present in the temple complex. To take stock of the critical situation and eliminate the terrorists, a special action group of the National Security Guard was flown in. Captain Rajesh Sharma, the leader of the action group, was tasked with locating and neutralising the two terrorists reported in the open patch outside the main complex. Despite daunting fire from the terrorists and lack of cover, leading his team from the front, this young officer continued to move forward. With total disregard to personal safety, Captain Sharma maintained pressure on the terrorists and kept them pinned down. He finally pinpointed the terrorists and gave covering fire to Subedar Suresh Chand while he closed in and killed one of the terrorists. Another terrorist inflicted a bullet injury on Captain Sharma’s left shoulder. The injury, however, did not deter this officer from his mission and he continued to press forward. In the final action, Captain Rajesh managed to locate and eliminate the second terrorist also. For his exemplary presence of mind, mature decision making and for displaying gallantry of a high order, Captain Rajesh Sharma was awarded the Shaurya Chakra.

(The writer is a veteran Gunner, 6 Field Regiment)

 


‘Jailed for 9 yrs in false case, but I didn’t give up’

‘Jailed for 9 yrs in false case, but I didn’t give up’

ough journey: Anti-Sikh riot victims Jagdish Kaur (R) and Nirpreet Kaur react after Sajjan Kumar was convicted.

Aditi Tandon

Tribune News Service

New Delhi, December 17

Nirpreet Kaur was only 16 when she witnessed the horrific murder of her father in Delhi Cantonment’s Raj Nagar area on November 1, 1984.

“We were a very happy family. My father Nirmal Singh and mother Sampuran Kaur loved me a lot. Our house was located next to Raj Nagar Gurdwara that was defiled and torched by the communally charged mobs on November 1, 1984,” recalls Nirpreet Kaur, one of the three witnesses against Congress leader Sajjan Kumar.

Settled in Mohali now, Nirpreet says her mother had sent her to Punjab long ago fearing for her life.

“I remember every detail of that day. Then Congress MLA Mahendra Yadav and Congress councillor Balwan Khokhar, who were known to my father, came to our house pretending to offer us security. But after my father let them in, they dragged him out. Two persons accompanying them tied my father up and Khokhar and Yadav beat him with iron rods before torching him to death,” says Nirpreet Kaur. Happy that Sajjan Kumar and other Congress leaders had been convicted for the murder of five Sikhs, besides defiling the gurdwara in Delhi Cantonment, Nirpreet says her fight for the resettlement of anti-Sikh riot survivors will continue.

Asked which part of her journey to justice was the toughest, she says the toughest part was when those who perpetrated the crime against her family began to torture her near and dear ones to intimidate her.

“They wanted me to withdraw the case. My close friend was killed and his death was shown as an accident. Then my mother was picked up and jailed. A false case under TADA was slapped against me. I spent nine years in jail, but did not go back on my word,” she says, pledging to keep helping the victims of 1984 carnage.

The HC today placed on record its appreciation for the fearlessness of witnesses Nirpreet Kaur, Jagdish Kaur and Jagsher Singh, saying it was due to their testimonials that Sajjan Kumar had been brought to justice


They wanted me to withdraw the case. My close friend was killed and his death was shown as an accident. Then my mother was picked up and jailed. A false TADA case was slapped against me. I spent nine years in jail, but did not go back on my word. —  Nirpreet Kaur, Witness 


‘Police post in charge asked the mobsters: Kitne murge bhun diye’

According to HC judgment: “Around 9 am on November 2, 1984, when Jagdish Kaur went to lodge a report at the police post, she saw that a public meeting was taking place which was attended by local MP Sajjan Kumar. She heard him declare ‘Sikh sala ek nahin bachna chahiye, jo Hindu bhai unko sharan deta hai, uska ghar bhi jala do aur unko bhi maro’”. She claimed she heard officer-in-charge of the police post ask mobsters “kitne murge bhun diye”.

 


PVSM for Army Chief Rawat Two officers to be conferred with Kirti Chakra

PVSM for Army Chief Rawat

Army Chief Gen Bipin Rawat.

Tribune News Service
New Delhi, January 25

Army Chief Gen Bipin Rawat is among 19 senior Army officials who have been conferred the Param Vishisht Seva Medal (PVSM), the highest military medal awarded in recognition of peacetime services not relating to gallantry. Fifteen Lieutenant Generals and three Major Generals have been awarded the PVSM.

Two senior officers Lt Gen Surinder Singh, Western Army Commander, and Lt Gen MM Naravane, Eastern Army Commander, will be accorded the PVSM.

Besides, President Ram Nath Kovind approved one Ashoka Chakra, which is the highest gallantry award in peacetime, two Kirti Chakra, the second highest peacetime gallantry award, nine Shaurya Chakras and 109 Sena medals for the Army personnel.

The Navy personnel will be decorated with seven Nao Sena medals and the IAF with two Vayu Sena medals for gallantry.

Lance Naik Nazir Ahmad Wani will be posthumously conferred with the Ashok Chakra. The Kirti Chakra will be awarded for separate acts of bravery to Major Tushar Gauba from the Jat Regiment and Sowar Vijay Kumar, 22 Rashtriya Rifles, the latter posthumously.

On May 24 last year, Major Gauba had eliminated three terrorists. Sowar Vijay Kumar was part of the operation. He got injured, but refused evacuation and killed two terrorists.

The Shaurya Chakra awardees include Capt Abhay Sharma, 1st Battalion, Parachute Regiment. He was the party commander tasked to undertake patrolling against enemy Border Action Team along LoC in Jammu district in April last. Besides shooting down the enemy, the team also destroyed three bunkers, recovered enemy weapon and ensured safe extrication.

Lt Col Vikrant Prasher of 10 Parachute Regiment (Special Forces), Major Amit Kumar Dimri from 14 Rashtriya Rifles, Major Imliakum Keitzar from 4th Gorkha Rifles, Major Rohit Lingwal of 9th Battalion, Parachute Regiment, Capt Abhinav Kumar Choudhary from 21 Rashtriya Rifles, Lance Naik Ayyub Ali from 9th battalion of Rashtriya Rifles, Sepoy Ajay Kumar, 42nd battalion of Rashtriya Rifles, and Sapper Mahesh HN, 44th Battalion of the Rashtriya Rifles also won the Shaurya Chakra.

In the IAF, both Vayu Sena medals for gallantry are for rescue efforts during floods. Wing Commander Bhuvanendran Nair Prasanth rescued 13 college girls stranded on a rooftop. Sergeant Amit Kumar Jha has been awarded for rescuing people during cyclonic storm “Ockhi” in Kerala.

In the Navy, Commander Vijay Verma, a helicopter pilot, is on the list for Nao Sena medal for gallantry. He had rescued two pregnant women during the floods. Another naval copter pilot Commander T Anup Kumar has been awarded for another daring rescue. Another copter pilot Lt Commander Manu Mishra saved a merchant vessel from spilling its cargo of toxic chemicals into the Bay of Bengal.

Lt Gen Praveen Bakshi and Lt Gen PM Hariz, whom Gen Rawat supereseded, were conferred the PVSM in 2017

Army Chief Rawat among 19 awarded PVSM, 2 Army men conferred Kirti Chakra

New Delhi, January 25

Army Chief Gen. Bipin Rawat is among 19 senior Army officials who have been conferred the Param Vishisht Seva Medal, the highest military medal awarded in recognition of peace-time services not relating to gallantry.

Almost all commanders who became Army Chief in the past four decades had been decorated with the award before their appointment to the top post, according to defence experts.

Fifteen lieutenant generals and three major generals have also been awarded the Param Vishisht Seva Medal (PVSM).

The defence ministry also announced Kirti Chakra—India’s second highest peacetime gallantry award—for Major Tushar Gauba from the Jat Regiment and Sowar Vijay Kumar ((posthumously)) from 22 Rashtriya Rifles.

Nine Army men have been awarded Shaurya Chakra, the third highest peacetime gallantry award after the Ashoka Chakra and the Kirti Chakra.

Major Gauba has been given the award for displaying “unparallel bravery” while dealing with a group of terrorists along the Line of Control in Kupwara district of Jammu and Kashmir in May last year.

Army officials said he crawled up to 20 metres close to the terrorists under heavy firing and then lobbed a hand grenade. Showing utter disregard to his personal safety, he charged on the terrorists with his weapon.

“In close combat undeterred by the terrorists’ fire, he killed three militants. His act of unparallel bravery under heavy terrorist fire, tactical acumen and swift action resulted in elimination of three hardcore terrorists,” said an Army official.

About Vijay Kumar, Army officials said he was deployed in Baramulla district of Jammu and Kashmir as part of “Operation Vijay Darsu” on August 2-3 last year.

During the operation, Kumar came under heavy fire from a group of heavily armed terrorists. However, despite being injured after killing one terrorist, he refused evacuation and went ahead to eliminate another in hand to hand combat.

He has been posthumously awarded the Kirti Chakra for displaying “indomitable raw courage and exemplary bravery beyond the call of duty”.

The Shaurya Chakra awardees included Lieutenant Colonel Vikrant Prasher of 10 Parachute Regiment (Special Forces), Major Amit Kumar Dimri from 14 Rashtriya Rifles, Major Imliakum Keitzar from 4th Gorkha Rifles, Major Rohit Lingwal of 9th battalion, Parachute Regiment and Captain Abhay Sharma, first battalion, Parachute Regiment, according to the defence ministry.

Captain Abhinav Kumar Choudhary from 21 Rashtriya Rifles, Lance Naik Ayyub Ali from 9th battalion of Rashtriya Rifles, Sepoy Ajay Kumar, 42ndbattalion of Rashtriya Rifles and Sapper Mahesh HN, 44th battalion of the Rashtriya Rifles also won the Shaurya Chakra.

Three lieutenant generals were chosen for Uttam Yudh Seva Medal while 32 army personnel have been conferred with Ati Vishisht Seva medal and nine with Yudh Seva medal.

According to the defence ministry, 103 Army personnel were awarded the Sena Medal (gallantry), 74 were given Vishisht Seva medal and 35 Army personnel were selected for Sena Medal (distinguished). PTI


Opening Ceremony :: Military Fest ::06 Dec2018 At 10:00 a.m Also Armed Forces Flag Day

Military Literature Festival kicks off at Lake Club today

CHANDIGARH: Punjab governor VP Singh Badnore will inaugurate the three-day Military Literature Festival 2018 at the Lake Club in Sector 1, Chandigarh , on Friday. Open to all, the festival aims to offer an opportunity for the youth to get acquainted with India’s military heritage, while also bringing a host of cultural activities, cuisines and competitions to the public.

HT PHOTO■ A series of brainstorming sessions will be organised at five venues of the Lake Club in Chandigarh.It is a joint initiative of military historian and Punjab chief minister Captain Amarinder Singh and Badnore with support extended by the army’s Western Command.

A series of brainstorming sessions have been organised at five venues at the club during the festival that will continue till December 9.

Subedar Yogendra Singh Yadav, one of the three living recipients of Param Vir Chakra, the nation’s highest gallantry award, and decorated defence personnel will interact with visitors.

The opening ceremony will see a session on the role of cross-border operations and surgical strikes. It will be moderated by Lt Gen DS Hooda (retd).

Another session on Friday will feature discussions on Punjabi poetry, literature and folk forms fostered by World War I.

Hindi litterateur Mrinal Pande will moderate the session on the heroic tradition (Vir Ras) in Hindi poetry.

CAPT TO TALK ON ROLE OF INDIA IN WWI

On Saturday, Punjab chief minister Capt Amarinder Singh will share his thoughts on the contribution of India towards World War I.

Columnist Vir Sanghvi will have an interactive session with Amarinder on ‘Valour, history, politics and media’, which will have actors Sonu Sood and Gurmeet Chaudhary on board.

The afternoon session will see Badnore talk on ‘The guerrilla campaign of Maharana Pratap with Rima Hooja moderating the session, followed by deliberations on the topic ‘Wisdom of spies’ with IPS officer AS Dulat, along with Lt Gen Kamal Davar and Lt Gen Sanjeev Langar as participants. KC Verma will moderate the session. BATTLES FOR SURVIVAL The concluding day will see live discussions on two battles for survival – Ferozshah 1848 and Chilianwala 1849 and Indian cavalry charges of the First World War and the Gallipoli Campaign with Captain Amarinder, Lt Gen TS Shergill, Dr Indu Banga, Tony McClenaghan and Brig Sukhjit Singh as panellists.

There will be a session with journalist Shekhar Gupta on reporting from the war zone. Journalists Vishnu Som and Barkha Dutt will participate in the session.Forty short films on wars fought by the army since Independence will be screened during the festival.

Besides, martial dances, weapons display, medallion gallery, artists’ corner, cultural activities and exhibitions, food and cuisine, book fair and children’s Saragarhi Samvadh will be among activities for visitors.

 

 

clip

clip


Nirmala opens TN Defence Corridor

Nirmala opens TN Defence Corridor

Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, File photo.

Tiruchirappalli, January 20

To accelerate indigenous production of defence systems, Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman today inaugurated Tamil Nadu Defence Industrial Corridor that is expected to attract Rs 3,123.50 crore worth of investment.

Inaugurating the corridor, Sitharaman said the Centre had decided on two corridors — in Uttar Pradesh and Tamil Nadu — despite demands from states like Karnataka and Maharashtra.

She also spoke about the Defence Ministry’s initiatives to ensure that the Indian industry engages with the country’s armed forces to co-create best defence technologies. Sitharaman said the development of these specialised corridors will facilitate a well-planned and efficient industrial base.

Several public and private sector organisations announced investment projects worth about Rs 3,100 crore, said the Defence Ministry. Major players like Lockheed Martin, LMW and others announced their plans to set up units in the corridor.

The Ordinance Factory Board announced its plans to invest about Rs 2,305 crore. Among the investors are BEL (Rs 140.50 crore), BEML (Rs 40 crore), BDL (Rs 150 crore), MDL (Rs 15 crore), TVS (Rs 30 crore) and Data Patterns (Rs 75 crore). — IANS

Rs 3K-cr investment  

  • Nirmala Sitharaman said UP too would have a defence corridor
  • The aim, she said, was to facilitate well-planned and efficient industrial base
  • TN corridor has attracted an investment of Rs 3,123.50 cr

 


Pak continues to use Afghan Taliban as hedge against India: US

Pak continues to use Afghan Taliban as hedge against India: US

Marine Corps Lt General Kenneth McKenzie’s remarks came days after US President Donald Trump sought Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan’s help in the Afghan peace process.

Washington, December 5

Pakistan continues to use Afghan Taliban as a hedge against India, a top American commander has told lawmakers, as he expressed the US frustration over Islamabad’s failure to take concrete steps to deny safe havens to terrorist groups.

Marine Corps Lt General Kenneth McKenzie’s remarks came days after US President Donald Trump sought Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan’s help in the Afghan peace process.

The Trump administration, in the recent months, has intensified its efforts to seek a negotiated settlement of America’s longest war in Afghanistan where the US has lost over 2,400 soldiers since late 2001, when it invaded the country after the 9/11 terror attacks.

The Taliban are fighting to flush out US-led international forces and re-establish their regime in Afghanistan after their ouster in 2001.

“Pakistan is an essential element in long-term stability in Afghanistan,” McKenzie told members of the Senate Armed Services Committee on Tuesday during his confirmation hearing for commander of the US Central Command (CENTCOM).

Pakistan could play a key role in facilitating talks between the Taliban and government of Afghanistan, he said.

“Pakistan does not appear to be using the full extent of its influence to encourage the Taliban to come to the table,” he said.

“We continue to see the Taliban being utilised as a hedge against India rather than as part of a stable, reconciled Afghanistan,” McKenzie said.

His answers to the Senate Armed Services Committee came after it became public that Trump had written a letter to Imran Khan, seeking his help in the Afghan peace process.

“President Trump sent a letter to Prime Minister Khan, requesting Pakistan’s full support to the US-led Afghan peace process and Special Representative for Afghanistan Reconciliation Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad’s upcoming trip to the region,” a spokesperson of the National Security Council, White House, told PTI.

“In the letter, the President recognises that Pakistan has the ability to deny the Taliban sanctuary on its territory,” the spokesperson said.

“The letter also makes it clear that Pakistan’s assistance with the Afghan peace process is fundamental to building an enduring US-Pakistan partnership,” the spokesperson said.

McKenzie told lawmakers that he did not see much of a change in Pakistan’s behaviour towards Afghanistan or its stand against terrorist groups.

Despite Pakistan’s positive rhetoric in support of the US’ South Asia Strategy, violent extremist organisations (VEOs) operated along its border with Afghanistan, he said.

“While Pakistan has conducted some operations against VEOs in the country, they must continue to expand these operations and remain aggressively engaged,” McKenzie said.

“Taking concrete steps that deny VEO safe havens in Pakistan and VEO freedom of movement from Pakistan to Afghanistan remain an important task that Pakistan needs to fulfil. Pakistan must leverage their influence over the Taliban leadership to help compel them to come to the table for reconciliation negotiations,” he added.

McKenzie said the US CENTCOM would continue to support the State Department as it worked towards a diplomatic solution to the conflict in Afghanistan, which included ensuring that Islamabad’s equities are acknowledged in any future agreement.

“Pakistan’s action or inaction, as it relates to stability in Afghanistan, has often led to US’s frustration,” he said, adding that stability in the South Asia region remained the most important mutual strategic interest for both the US and Pakistan.

“We must continue to engage with the Pakistani leadership to realise how we can achieve this mutual interest,” McKenzie said.

“I do believe that any solution in Afghanistan is going to require the assistance of Pakistan. It has to be a regional solution, not just a solution centred in Afghanistan,” he said.

It is in Pakistan’s long-term interest to have a government in Afghanistan that is stable, and that they can do business with, he said.

“So I think Pakistan has not shown indications, by and large over the last few years, of being a serious partner in this regard,” McKenzie said.

US Special Representative for Afghanistan Zalmay Khalilzad on Tuesday met Pakistan Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi in Islamabad. McKenzie said the meeting was to see if the US could find some way forward.

“Probably Pakistan knows very clearly that their assistance will be required to reach an end-state in Afghanistan. I think the task that we have is to make it attractive to them so that they see that it is in their best interest to do that,” McKenzie said. PTI

 


Honey-trapped’, jawan shares Arjun tank info

Posted with armoured unit, was lured on FB, now in police remand

‘Honey-trapped’, jawan shares Arjun tank info

Somveer Singh

Yash Goyal

Jaipur, January 13

An Army jawan, posted with an armoured unit in Rajasthan’s Jaisalmer district, has been arrested for allegedly sharing sensitive information with a Pakistan agent after being honey-trapped. A special court has remanded him in police custody for seven days.

The jawan, Somveer Singh, hailing from Haryana and posted with 75 Armoured Regiment, was allegedly honey-trapped by the agent by posing as “Anika Chopra”, “Captain” in the Military Nursing Corps, on the Facebook. Somveer Singh was arrested under various sections of the Official Secrets Act, 1923, by the Intelligence Wing of the Rajasthan Police and produced before the Special Criminal Court on Saturday, said a senior official of the state police today.

The accused, who allegedly received Rs 5,000 for spying, was currently lodged at the Central Police Station here and was being interrogated, he said. A unit of Military Intelligence had found the jawan allegedly sending pictures, locations of exercises and sensitive information, including that on Arjun tank, to the Pakistan agent. In a joint surveillance, the Military Intelligence and state police’s Intelligence Wing headed by DG-Intelligence arrested Somveer.

Gadgets, including a smart phone, were seized from his possession. His call details were being examined to ascertain the kind of information sent across the border. “The accused has confessed to having shared crucial information with the Pakistan agent,” the official said. Asked about the possibility of other Army personnel being honey-trapped by the Pakistan operative on the Facebook, the official said: “The matter is being investigated.”

“It is not just a case of honeytrap, but that of spying too as this jawan was paid Rs 5,000 through another account to avoid suspicion. He transferred the money into his account, probably an e-wallet,” the official said.

“Eight months ago, the operative posing as ‘Anika Chopra’ befriended him on the social networking platform by sending lewd messages. During online chats, intimate pictures and videos, besides sensitive information, were shared on the smartphone,” he said. “The fake account originating in Karachi, Pakistan, was closed after the Military Intelligence spotted Somveer sharing sensitive information,” the official said.

 


Navy’s salvo against IAF The rocky path to achieving military jointness

Navy’s salvo against IAF

THE Indian military has held its own in all military ventures since Independence, barring the 1962 conflict with China. After Kargil found the Indian military stretched, deep introspection about the archaic system of organising the forces gave way to a nearly two-decade endeavour to achieve tri-service integration. The Fusion Doctrine, as it is known the world-over, involves drawing together all military capabilities in which the might of the three services is brought to bear on the enemy in an integrated manner. The efficacy of the CDS system has been proved in five dozen countries, but in India, serious and sincere efforts to remodel the present higher defence organisation have run into political and inter-services opposition.

The Navy Chief’s disclosure that his Air Force counterpart has raised the red flag over joint theatre commands indicates the tough road ahead in taking all stakeholders on board for an eventual reorganisation of the Indian military. The appeal of sole ownership over existing military assets and the possibility of restructuring shaking up present channels of promotion have contributed to foot-dragging by one service or the other. But there is no escape from restructuring — a single Chinese theatre command faces India’s six commands of the Air Force and the Army. The snafus in coordination during hostilities can be easily visualised.

That jointness imparts speed and optimum concentration of military assets is known. Restructuring will also help an emerging, but resource-strapped power like India to eliminate commonality and overlap in many tri-service arenas, including equipment, training and utilisation of surveillance assets. The Vajpayee and the Manmohan Singh governments hung back from pushing the envelope for fear of a backlash from the services. The Indian armed forces have risen to national emergencies without fail. But corrective measures too are long overdue. The government must lose no time in setting up joint theatre commands. With a budget of just 3 per cent of GDP, the armed forces need to pool their manpower and firepower to play a more cost-effective and active role in guarding and building the nation.


A Liability Called Rafale | Point of View

A fully loaded Rafale is only as capable as the Su-30, MiG-29 and Mirage 2000. The talk of Su-30/Rafale for distant nuclear delivery against China is a joke.

Illustration by Tanmoy Chakraborty

Illustration by Tanmoy Chakraborty

The French Rafale combat aircraft is a political embarrassment and a military liability. It’s an inappropriate, cost-ineffective buy that adds no real operational value to the Indian Air Force (IAF) in terms of enhancing its reach, clout and mission versatility, but adversely impacts the air order-of-battle.

Per current plans, by 2025 and with the induction of the 36 Rafales bought in flyaway condition, the IAF will have between 272 and 312 Su-30MKIs or 17-20 squadrons upgraded to the ‘Super Sukhoi’ configuration, more than 90 Jaguars or five squadrons, more than 60 MiG-29s or four squadrons, and over 50 Mirage 2000s or three squadrons-totalling 34 squadrons of 4.5 generation aircraft. Seven squadrons of the indigenous Tejas Mk-1A and Mark-2-also 4.5 generation-replacing MiG-21 for short-range air defence means an IAF force profile of 41 squadrons (by mid-2030s).

So, what’s wrong with this force structure? Other than Jaguar for low-level strike and Tejas, the Rafale has, with full ordnance loading, the same operational range and capability as the Su-30, MiG-29 and Mirage 2000. These are all medium multi-role combat aircraft (MMRCA) which, given range constraints, can be optimally fielded against Pakistan alone and in border affrays against China, but have zero strategic reach and worth. So, the talk of Su-30/ Rafale for distant nuclear delivery against China is a joke. This fits in with the IAF’s thinking and conduct as a tactical adjunct in the region of superior extra-territorial air forces (Royal Air Force in colonial times and the US Air Force in the immediate post-1962 war period and, perhaps, in the future). Whence the service’s emphasis solely on short- to medium-legged aircraft with no interest whatsoever in acquiring long-range strategic bombers, such as the Tu-22 ‘Backfire’ (first offered in August 1971) or the more lethal Tu-160 ‘Blackjack’, either of which could long ago have been purchased or leased from Russia. It would have enlarged the IAF’s operational/ mission envelope and firmed up the manned, recallable vector for nuclear as well as conventional deterrence of China. The IAF has had no bomber after the phasing out of the medium-range Canberra.

Until the April 2015 Rafale announcement by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the erst­while defence minister, Manohar Parrikar, correctly favoured the option of quickly and economically augmenting the fleet of Su-30s-rated the best fighter aircraft in the world. It had several merits. For the price of one Rafale, the country would have had two Su-30s and Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd, Nashik, which assembles this aircraft, would have had a contract to produce more of them. The ‘Super Sukhoi’ version of the Su-30, more­over, meets the Rafale level of on-board data fusion capability. The upgrade of the Su-30 is, therefore, a critical need, except it is now imperilled by the Rs 59,000 crore down pay­ment for the Rafale, which leaves little funding for anything else.

The Rafale’s only other attribute is the exorbitantly priced Meteor air-to-air (A2A) missile, whose effectiveness is exaggerated. Even the most advanced A2A missiles have limited ‘kill zones’. The certainty of tracking, identifying, targeting and hitting enemy aircraft diminishes markedly beyond 50-80 miles. Worse, with so few Rafales and such high investment, the IAF will be loath to deploy them in war because every Rafale lost would mean over Rs 1,600 crore down the drain and, proportionately, a seriously attrited force.

Besotted by Western-origin aircraft, the IAF had hoped to use the initial order of 36 Rafales as a wedge to procure 90 more. That ruse being blown, it has indented for 114 new type single-engine MMRCA. With Donald Trump turning up the pressure, the 1960s vintage, museum-ready F-16 is likely to be the gap filler. It will pose no danger to the Pakistan Air Force that has been operating this plane for 30-odd years, but will fritter away resources and exacerbate an already hellish logistics problem for the IAF, created by the unmanageable diversity of aircraft in its inventory, each requiring its own expensive maintenance infrastructure.

The writer is author of Staggering Forward: Narendra Modi and India’s Global Ambiti.

Making Pakistan ‘secular’ Army Chief ventures into unchartered waters again

Making Pakistan ‘secular’

Army Chief Gen Bipin Rawat’s homily to Pakistan asking it to turn into a secular state from an Islamic nation if it has to stay together with India would have ruffled several feathers in the Foreign Office. It has been India’s consistent policy, bar a few aberrations, not to be prescriptive about the political arrangement in other countries. This stance is on display in the ongoing G-20 summit in Buenos Aires. Mohammad bin Salman of Saudi Arabia may be in the West’s doghouse for the murder of journalist Adnan Khashoggi and is an Islamic country to boot. That didn’t prevent PM Modi from discussing urgent matters of state with him.

Similarly, it is of little concern to India that China is a one-party state. As long as it does not imperil its national interests, India is happy to go along with China regardless of its political structure and sense of destiny. That also presumably is the political line the Army Chief is compelled to adhere to. The Army is the last line of defence and the Chief has to keep the morale of his men high and inspire them into combat. His exposition on the need for Pakistan to change its identity hardly promotes any of those prerequisites.

General Rawat superseded two senior officers on the way to becoming the Chief. The reason for the supersession, a rare happening in the Indian Army, was his vast experience on the Line of Control and in the Northeast. The Army has risen to the occasion in both sectors, but General Rawat betrays a lack of sensitivity and propriety when he weighs in on issues outside his domain. In this case, he also displays a naivety, if that is the case, about the fragility of the circumstances. The Kartarpur corridor has provided an extraordinary opening for India and Pakistan to get out of a diplomatic cul de sac. The situation requires India to display a unity of purpose among different actors for the tough bargaining that is inevitable. It could do without creating the impression of dissonance.