All posts by webadmin

Theme for the Chinese dreamby Pravin Sawhney

In the standoff between India and China at Doklam, little has been said about north Sikkim. India is extremely vulnerable there because of geography and defunct infrastructure, especially roads. China has excellent roads and airlift capability and our Army is at a disadvantage.

Theme for the Chinese dream
ROCKY ROAD TO PEACE: The highway in north Sikkim needs upkeep. Photo by the writer

Pravin Sawhney

THE crucial meeting between the National Security Adviser Ajit Doval and the Chinese leadership has not resolved the Doklam crisis. The two sides discussed “bilateral and major problems”, suggesting that diplomatic channels are functioning. While neither side wants war, it is certain that China will not accept a reciprocal withdrawal of forces.Will this lead to a long haul of armies’ face-off? Probably not. Unlike any of his predecessors, Xi Jinping dons four hats — President, Communist Party General Secretary, Chairman of the Central Military Commission and the Commander-in-Chief Joint Operations Command. He has positioned military power as the anchor of his aggressive China dream and will not wait for long before adopting detrimental measures towards India. Hence, a valid question: What next? A senior Chinese diplomat had told me on July 5 in his embassy that China had informed the Indian side about their intentions on June 1, two weeks before their road construction party started work in Donglang (Doklam for us) area. Yet, instead of diplomatic outreach, the Indian side chose military. “On June 16, Indian troops entered 183 metres inside Chinese territory (in Donglang) to block our road-building party. India has opened a pandora’s box. For the first time since the formation of the People’s Republic of China, foreign troops have entered Chinese territory… the foundation of the 19 rounds of border talks (held since 2003) would no longer be there,” he said, adding that, “While we want diplomatic channels to solve problems, we will not wait for very long.” This is a serious issue. Border talks by the Special Representatives are not capable of yielding tangible results because the five Sino-India border agreements have given Beijing enormous political, legal and military advantage with little incentive left to resolve the dispute. Yet, they have helped in upholding the pretence of normalcy allowing the two sides to continue with “development partnership,” while chanting the mantra of peace. In the 1993 agreement, the traditional border was renamed as the Line of Actual Control (LAC) — a military line which can be pushed by either side since the border is neither agreed on maps nor on the ground. This allowed the Chinese to transgress the disputed border at will since 1998 when India cited China as the reason for its nuclear tests. Prime Minister Modi had sought to correct this foreign policy blunder by publicly asking President Xi Jinping during his September 2014 visit to mutually define the LAC, which was ignored. Similarly, the 1996 agreement has laid down the bare minimum troops and equipment that each side can bring to the LAC without mutual consent. Since China has excellent roads and airlift capability, this agreement has placed the Indian Army at a grave disadvantage. Likewise, in the 2003 joint declaration, India formally accepted the Tibet Autonomous Region (TAR) as a part of China. By doing so, it diluted the Dalai Lama’s definition of Tibetan autonomy within China (to include the three provinces of Amdo, Kham and U-Tsang along with TAR). China, in return, refused to endorse Sikkim as a part of India in the joint declaration. It merely changed a few of its maps to accommodate the Indian requirement; these, going by the Chinese diplomat’s threat, can be changed again. Meanwhile, the 2013 Border Defence Cooperation Agreement (BDCA) has downgraded the Army’s border-guarding role to border policing during peacetime. Since the BDCA prohibits “tailing or following” of the other sides’ patrol which cross the LAC without being noticed, the Indian Army has been compelled to physically hold the 3,488-km border entailing huge manpower. This is not all. Unlike India which says it has 3,488-km border with China, Beijing has truncated it to a mere 2,000 km by excluding Ladakh. So, if China calls off the border talks, all confidence-building measures available to local commanders and senior diplomats in case of transgressions and intrusions too will become defunct. The consequences are all too evident. Let’s look at Sikkim, which is militarily divided into north and east Sikkim. While much noise has been made about the Indian Army holding favourable defensive positions in north-east and east Sikkim, which faces the Chumbi Valley funnel, little has been said about north Sikkim, where India is extremely vulnerable because of geography and defunct infrastructure, especially roads. Given the difficult terrain in north Sikkim, it has limited Dropping Zones (DZs), and the single road that connects it to Gangtok has weak military bridges (class 12), and the track itself (class 30 road) is non-existent in parts because of innumerable water-falls, seasonal rivers, and a longish monsoon. Despite the Army’s best efforts, the state government has not cleared the building of an alternate highway, citing environmental issues and economic viability as the reasons. Standing at the northern-most part of the Kerang plateau, one can see the flat expanse of the Tibetan plateau with excellent motorable roads on the other side. Chinese troops will have little difficulty in moving mobile forces, equipment and land-based firepower in north Sikkim. They can justify this as the quid pro quo  —if India can move troops into Donglang/ Doklam, why can’t they do the same in north Sikkim? Hopefully, China will not use the military option in Sikkim. Unlike India, they are not focussed on a battle but the war — to address their “major problem”, perhaps, of Tibet, by diplomacy, failing which by using military power to their advantage.Prime Minister Narendra Modi has been unrestrained while talking about China which is economically, politically, technologically and militarily more powerful. He was the first senior political leader to caution China to desist from its “expansionist tendencies” in his election speeches in 2014. It was the first time, Sikyong (Prime Minister of the “Tibetan government-in-exile”) Lobsang Sangay attended an Indian Prime Minister’s swearing-in ceremony. The next year, Modi became the first Prime Minister to visit Arunachal Pradesh to mark statehood celebrations. It was the first time in seven visits to Arunachal Pradesh that the Dalai Lama was accompanied by a Union Minister. The Modi government ignored Chinese displeasure on each occasion. If the previous government opted for appeasement, this government has swung to the other extreme. To quote the Chinese diplomat once again: “You (India) are not a super-power which you regard yourself to be.” The writer is the Editor FORCE newsmagazine.


The verdict & unseen hand of Generals BY Vivek Katju

Pakistan’s superior courts have often commented on difficulties in legally applying ideals of conduct to concrete cases. The qualities of leadership are rooted in the Islamic concept of righteous rulers, so no politcal party has amended these. Nawaz Sharif’s case proves vagaries of litigation but is there a whiff of politics too?

The verdict & unseen hand of Generals
DOWN BUT NOT OUT: Ousted Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif addresses members of PML-N, in Islamabad. AFP

Vivek Katju

AS Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif resigned on July 28 after the Supreme Court decision in the Panama Papers case, memories, two decades old, of his success in hounding out Sajjad Ali Shah from the office of Chief Justice of Pakistan would have come back. He may well have wondered what the world had come to when he had no alternative but bow to a decision based on one technical ground taken through a controversial judicial procedure. Back in 1997, Nawaz Sharif exercised such control over the country that for the “insult” of the Chief Justice summoning him in person to answer charges of contempt of court he had allowed zealous supporters to storm its premises, split the Bench, which by majority declared that Shah’s appointment, by then three years old, as illegal ab initio and sent their Chief packing.  All through, the army Chief Ge. Jehangir Karamat had not stirred. But that was then. This time the bisaat was totally different, except in one aspect: if Sajjad Ali Shah was a “political” judge, the whiff of politics comes from the present judgment too. The Panama Papers became public in April 2016. They revealed that Nawaz Sharif’s children — daughter Maryam who is being groomed for politics and businessmen sons Hussain and Hassan who live outside Pakistan — owned off- shore companies and lucrative properties abroad. These included four apartments in London’s posh Park Lane. For many in Pakistan, these revelations only established what was suspected all along, that Nawaz Sharif had sent abroad his ill-gotten wealth acquired from business and misuse of office. The Panama Papers provided the opposition, especially Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) Chairman Imran Khan, an opportunity to corner Nawaz Sharif. Between April and August 2016, Nawaz Sharif’s attempts to appoint commissions to investigate these charges failed. The government and the opposition could not agree on the terms of reference of a commission and Pakistan’s Chief Justice also refused to nominate judges to any commission which in law would be “toothless”. Finally, Imran Khan filed a case seeking  the Supreme Court to declare Nawaz Sharif unfit to be a Member of the National Assembly ( hence, Prime Minister) as he did not meet the tests prescribed in Articles 62 and 63 of the constitution. Most constitutions and peoples’ representation laws prescribe conditions relating to nationality, age, residence, health, absence of criminal convictions by courts, and in some cases that a person should not be in debt. Seldom do they venture into the domain of character. This was also the case with the Pakistan constitution till General Zia-ul-Haq amended Article 62 and introduced a character test. Art. 62 (1) (f) now requires Members of Parliament to be, “sagacious, righteous, non-profligate, honest and ameen”. Pakistan’s superior courts have commented many times on the difficulties in legally applying these ideals of conduct to concrete cases. However, as these qualities of leadership are rooted in the Islamic concept of righteous rulers no political party has taken the initiative to amend it. Gradually case law seems to be developing to apply them narrowly such as in cases of wrong declaration on nomination forms for elections. The courts refrain from entering into an MP’s personal conduct.Imran Khan asserted that the Panama Papers revealed that Nawaz Sharif owned properties abroad, including the Park Lane flats, and been dishonest to not disclose them in his nomination form. He further alleged that in his speeches to the nation and parliament after the Panama Leaks, he had prevaricated and contradicted himself, thus falling short of the qualities mentioned in Art. 62. The Court heard the matter for over two months. It decided, as noted by Justice Khosa who led the five-judge bench, “to focus mainly, but not exclusively, on the properties relevant to Respondent No.1 (Nawaz Sharif) and his children which were revealed in the Panama Papers”. By a majority of 3-2, it decided that the Panama Papers did not conclusively establish that Nawaz Sharif was the owner of these properties and therefore a Supreme Court monitored probe was required through a Joint Investigation Team (JIT) to establish facts. Surprisingly, the JIT included ISI and MI officers thereby involving the army which assured the nation that it will fulfil the mandate conferred by the Court. Though the majority and the dissenting judges agreed that Nawaz Sharif and his children’s claims were contradictory and deliberately confusing and incomplete,the two dissenting judges found these sufficient to disqualify him the majority three did not reach this conclusion. Strangely, the minority two inferred that while a person could  be sent to jail after establishing his guilt through a regular trial, disqualification in terms of Art 62 could be done through a lower standard. The Supreme Court Chief Justice appointed a bench of three judges who had given the majority judgement to monitor the JIT probe. The JIT gave its report on July 10 and the three-judge bench heard arguments about its tenability for a week. In violation of procedural norms, the original five-judge bench met to pronounce the judgment. The dissenting two thus had no opportunity to hear arguments on the report and yet they considered it fit as obviously did the Chief Justice that in a matter relating to the Prime Minister standard procedure could be short-circuited. Now comes the strangest part. On the issues in the Panama Papers on which the JIT extensively reported, the majority three did not obviously concur with the dissenting two and did not find the report sufficient to disqualify Nawaz Sharif.  However, as the JIT found the family guilty of misrepresentation and fabricating documents, the five unanimously ordered the National Accountability Bureau to launch corruption cases against all. In a move which can only be called dubious, the five took note of Nawaz Sharif’s chairmanship of FZE Capital, his son’s company in Dubai (which did not figure in the Panama Papers)  and held that while he did not draw any emoluments they were nevertheless his assets. This may be technically so. They held that as he had not declared them in his nomination form in the 2013 election, he was dishonest and fell short of the requirements of Art 62. No real opportunity was given to him to defend himself. The judges clearly forgot that justice has to be manifestly done. It brings no credit to the Supreme Court and can only spread speculation of bias and the unseen hand of the Generals. The writer is a former Secretary, Ministry of External Affairs.


Doklam Standoff: The Real Reasons And How Far Can It Be Taken by Lt Gen Syed Ata Hasnain

Doklam Standoff: The Real Reasons And How Far Can It Be Taken

SNAPSHOT

There is no alternative for India but to do more than lip service to its dire need for better infrastructure and military capability for a two-front conflict.

Doklam will not be the last time it will face intimidation.

The standoff in the general area tri-junction and specifically the Doklam Plateau on the China-Bhutan border has now been on for over six weeks without a bullet being fired. There is rhetoric on both sides but many times more by the Chinese public relations and propaganda machinery to send home the most intimidating messages seen in a long time. The status is stuck on national egos with both sides under public pressure. In such standoffs, situations can go out of hand with the faintest of wrong gestures, words or even perceptions. The Nathula incident of 1967 comes immediately to mind where large-scale casualties were reported by both sides once the standoff developed into a conflagration.

A few facts will set the tone for this analysis. The Chumbi Valley is a narrow wedge of territory between Bhutan and the Indian state of Sikkim. The boundaries of China, India and Bhutan meet at the disputed tri-junction near the southern end of the valley. Doklam is an 89 square kilometre plateau on the eastern side of Chumbi. The Chinese claim it as theirs and so does Bhutan.

The issue in contention is that the Chinese commenced constructing a road on the disputed plateau to bring an artery to the southern end of the Chumbi Valley. The road, if completed, will alter the operational picture quite drastically as the Chinese can more effectively develop operations southwards, although they would be reasonably unsure of success with their base wedged between two potential adversaries. India’s objection is from two angles. First is that the road construction alters the strategic and operational scenario. Second that it transgresses disputed territory of a country with whom it has a mutual assistance treaty.

So if the Chinese are really professional why have they chosen to address this border issue where they are at operational disadvantage? There can be much conjecture on that, commencing from the question whether this entire standoff is an accidental one, which the Chinese did not think through sufficiently, to whether it is a deliberate selection of a point of dispute where the complexities are large; the Chicken’s Neck and the involvement of Bhutan making it a little more out of the ordinary than Depsang Plateau or Chumar in Ladakh, where the standoffs took place in 2013 and 2014.

The answer lies in a couple of factors, which have not emerged in recent analyses. It’s a question of forcing India to remain fixated on the continental dimension of its security. To do that, it is important for China to draw India into these standoffs to keep the threat of the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) alive and making it two front by also playing the Pakistan card. This is the domain, where India is all alone as land boundary disputes do not draw as much international attention as maritime disputes or even just the entire gamut of the maritime domain. The latter draws far greater attention with sea lanes, continental shelves and exclusive economic zones.

China’s strength lies in the continental dimension; that is the matter of detail that chairman Deng Xiao Ping, the father of modern China, possibly misread and did not direct as part of his four modernisations. Although the military domain was the last in priority, within that domain the PLA Navy received even lower priority. That was surprising because China’s actual security priority lies in the maritime zone. Its economy is dependent on energy transported by sea. Its disputes in South East and East Asia are both in the oceans.

The Indian Ocean in its huge expanse is vulnerability for China, because located at the crown is India, which with a strong navy can remain a threat in being against China’s sea lanes of communication (SLsOC). These SLsOC carry almost 80 per cent of the energy needs especially to the well-developed eastern seaboard. That is the reason for China focusing on its string of pearls strategy, which off late has received a bit of a fillip. None other than Raja Menon, the doyen of India’s maritime experts, has argued for long along the above lines. In fact, China’s New Maritime Silk Route is partially based upon the need for strengthening its outreach to overcome the weaknesses of its stretched SLsOC.

Thus China must keep India pegged to the continental security domain to prevent it from concentrating on and developing its maritime security capability. The increasing cooperation of the Indian Navy with other naval forces, primarily the US, Japan and Australia, is not in China’s interest and this phenomenon keeps it worried. The politico-diplomatic reasons for China resorting to intimidation along with the above rationale can only be traced to three issues.

First is the moral victory, which India appeared to have scored over the Dalai Lama visit to Arunachal Pradesh earlier in 2017. Second is most likely the refusal of India (and Bhutan) to join in even the basic sensitisation discussions on the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) conducted by China in May 2017; China’s self-perceived magnum opus. Third, perhaps are the increasing indicators of a stronger and more strategically emerging relationship between the US, India and Japan. The plain deduction in the Chinese strategic mind would be the necessity to intimidate India and show it its place in the international strategic scenario at a time when the world order seems more confused than ever before.

The choice could have been anywhere along the disputed areas; Doklam made response and subsequent handling by India more complex. Little did China realise that the complexity will also become a millstone around its neck after India refused to be intimidated and came to Bhutan’s assistance. So where does it go from here? The viral propaganda in the official Chinese media, quite uncharacteristically impolite by any international standards of behaviour, is also a crude attempt at intimidation with the hope that it will force India into submission. The reverse has happened.

However, it is not something for India to be happy about because it does not seek conflict anywhere along its borders and is committed to its economic growth and betterment of lives of its people. China too has to realise that in its relationships it cannot expect nations to acquiesce to its strategic desire at the cost of their self-respect.

Such politico-military-strategic situations cannot simply be glossed over without at least a brief commentary on the military aspects. The most noticeable thing this time is China’s attempt to employ hybrid aspects with psychological warfare at the core. Its aim is to create fear in the minds of the Indian leadership and paint a scenario of India’s helplessness in comparison to China’s economic and military strength. There hasn’t been any subtlety about it reflecting crass attitude in the hope that India will back off.

It is a misnomer for China to think that it can walk all over India’s armed forces. What it is achieving in the bargain is the buying of new generation enmity, which will last into the future. While it may not be correct to assume that we have the fullest support of the international community yet China-Pakistan collusion to target India is not going to be viewed very positively either.

A long standoff stretching into winter, which analysts are speculating about, is not in anyone’s interest as a single spark can anytime put a full border on fire. Bhutan, which has unfortunately been caught between the interests of its giant neighbours, could actually hold the key to a potential dilution of tension. Considering that mutual withdrawal is being considered as a potential Indian success, Bhutan’s request to India to withdraw its troops alongside stoppage of all construction activity by the PLA with a follow up of a resumption in China-Bhutan talks could be a face saver for all. Bhutan could insist on subsequent PLA vacation of Doklam and return to status quo ante for the talks to resume.

The important thing is that with this incident the next may not be too far away. There is no alternative for India but to do more than lip service to its dire need for better infrastructure and military capability for a two-front conflict. Doklam will not be the last time it will face intimidation.


Indo-Thai joint military exercise concludes

Indo-Thai joint military exercise concludes
The GOC, Dah Division, at the Bakloh Cantt on Sunday. Photo: Ravinder Sood

Our Correspondent

Palampur, July 16

A fortnight Indo-Thailand joint training exercise “Matree” concluded at the Bakloh Cantt, 90 km from here, this morning.The major thrust of the joint training was to understand the operational methodology, interoperability and conduct tactical operations by joint command post. The exercise finally concluded based on counter-terrorism setting.The General Officer Commanding, Dah Division, while presiding over the event appreciated both the armies. He said the professionability, conduct and confidence of both units had resulted in successful completion of the exercise.The GOC said the military exercise would strengthen friendly relations between India and Thailand and build up the understanding between rank and files of both armies. This exercise had benefited both the armies. In future such training would continue to strengthen the relations of both the countries.


Two militants killed as Army foils infiltration bid in Kashmir’s Naugam

Two militants killed as Army foils infiltration bid in Kashmir's Naugam
The operation is under way. PTI file

Tribune News Service

Srinagar, July 10

The Army on Monday foiled an infiltration bid along the Line of Control (LoC) in Naugam sector of north Kashmir, killing three militants.

(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)

“Suspicious movement was noticed along the LoC in Naugam sector last night and the terrorists were tracked till dawn, when they were challenged by troops,” an Army official said.

He said in the ensuing gunfight, three militants have been killed so far as the operation was in progress. With PTI


Mission Israel: India’s new strategy evolvingby Lt Gen Syed Ata Hasnain

8

The optics from the scenes at the Ben Gurion airport, bear hugs, gestures and words all displayed the final arrival of a strategic partnership in the making for last many years. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu stated that Israel had been waiting for this moment, of a visit by an Indian Prime Minister to Israel, for the last seventy years; it finally happened and that too symbolically on the anniversary of Israel’s famous intervention operations at Entebbe in 1976 in which Netanyahu lost his elder brother. The visit needs to be viewed beyond the expressed emotions for its true worth in an increasingly dangerous world in which India and Israel find themselves with many common threats.

Driving into Israel from Jordan over the famous King Hussain Bridge some years ago what struck me were the vast plantations in the Jordan Valley, all brought to life through drip irrigation, the agro technology which Israel mastered and which enabled water deficient countries to make use of their arid lands. I start with this observation because mention Israel and every one jumps to only issues related to military technology. The latter will find much reference in this piece but it’s the ability to innovate for survival in diverse fields and take those innovations well beyond which has been the major strength of the Israeli state from which India needs to learn.

While understanding that this is one of Prime Minister Modi’s most important foreign visits it is also relevant to understand what prevented the development of the relationship to this level in the last 25 years after establishment of diplomatic relations. The beginning was shackled by the legacy of Cold War ideas and relationships although the desire for closer defense, economic and people to people ties existed for almost seventy years. What held India back even after 1992 were the compulsions of the management of our ties with the Arab world and in turn with the Islamic world. As a nation with a large Islamic population, the handling of ties with the Islamic world was important. India was extremely concerned because of its ongoing spat with Pakistan who would have exploited any relationship perceived inimical to interests of the large comity of Arab nations and turned them against India. In addition India with its huge dependence on the Arab world for its energy needs could have ill afforded not maintaining strong political ties with them.

Prime Minister Modi’s foreign policy involved almost three years of managing, cultivating and strategizing for this big event; it could not have been possible without that. Sensitive to the presence of an eight million Indian diaspora in the Gulf region and considering all the angles of the implications on India’s energy security and trade relations he first tied up the ends, visited important Islamic nations such as Saudi Arabia, UAE, Qatar and Iran and received delegations from them. He thus ensured that a substantive move towards Israel would not come in the way of relationships in a fast changing strategic environment of the Middle East. The relationship with Israel could not be taken to the next level with the shadow of the Arab world looming in the background and any mention of Israel could not be simply hyphenated with the long standing problems of Palestine. Nations ultimately seek their interests independent of their concern for other nations although this need not substantially change the way they do business with those nations. By not visiting Ramallah on the West Bank Mr Modi is not necessarily shunning a relationship with Palestine but rather giving it a status separated from Israel. In many ways, that should work positively for the Palestinian Authority too.

While there are many issues on the agenda of the visit the dominant part of the relationship remains the security domain. There will be talks on agriculture, water and disaster management, startups, university adoption, student exchange programs and technical education but there is no denying that the domain which drives Israel’s virtual existence is security. Netanyahu’s call for taking ‘Make in India’ to ‘Make with India’ is a relevant one as no other technically advanced nation will share technology with India the way Israel does. Fully aware of the limitations of its own markets Israel would definitely be seeking to enhance its share of 7.9 percent of the Indian arms and equipment market to something much higher. With India it gets to partner a nation both with a security environment with almost similar threats and one which is hungry for technology.

Leading the pack in military equipment is the recent agreement for the Indian purchase of ten Heron advanced armed drones at a cost of almost 450 million USD. Capable of substantially changing the offensive capability across the LoC in a No War No Peace environment the drones can undertake surgical strikes much deeper in adversary territory than can be executed by foot borne Special Forces. The other equipment keenly awaited is the Barak 8 surface to air missile system to boost Indian air defence systems which have been largely deficient in capability. In the field of cyber security, intelligence acquisition and intervention in counter terror operations there can be a no match to the Israeli expertise. The Spike anti-tank guided missile launchers and missiles for Indian infantry units will be a boon in view of the repeated failure in the development of the Nag anti-tank missile. My last important take away from this domain is the creation of an electronic wall for border management. With India’s intent of upgrading border management substantially the Israeli deployment and response system along the Lebanese border is one of the best models to look at.

There will be many nations watching with keen interest the emergence of India’s de-hyphenated foreign policy in the making and it is good that display of complete strategic independence is going to be a part of Indian policy for the future.  Two more days of high profile events beamed live from Israel and discussed threadbare by Indian TV channels are  surely not going to go waste.


Captain among 3 injured in militant ambush in Kashmir’s Bandipora

Captain among 3 injured in militant ambush in Kashmir's Bandipora
Photo for representational purpose only.

Majid Jahangir

Tribune News Service

Srinagar, July 8

At least three Army men were injured in the wee hours of Saturday in a militant ambush in north Kashmir’s Bandipora district.The ambush took place at a time when the entire Kashmir was on a high alert on the death anniversary of militant commander Burhan Wani.The ambush was carried out at Hajin, some 32 km from Srinagar, around 3 am when the Army jawans were going for patrolling in the area.Three Army men, including a Captain-rank officer got injured in the ambush. All of them are stable.Sources said that the militants took advantage of the darkness and congested the locality and fled from the spot.Soon after the shooting, the area was cordoned and searches were being carried to trace the militants involved in the attack.


Six attacks within hours in Kashmir Army, CRPF camps targeted; 16 hurt

 

Six attacks within hours in Kashmir
CRPF camp attacked in Pulwama. ANI photo

Azhar Qadri & Suhail A Shah

Tribune News Service

Srinagar/Anantnag, June 13

For the first time in recent years, militants carried out a series of near-simultaneous attacks in four districts of Kashmir valley on Tuesday, injuring 16 security personnel and looting four rifles.The first attack took place in Tral sub-district in the evening and by the night-fall, the militants had carried out a total of six attacks—five in south Kashmir and one in north Kashmir.(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)DGP SP Vaid said there was prior intelligence about possible escalation in attacks to commemorate the anniversary of Battle of Badr, the first battle fought by a Muslim army in the seventh century.  “Today was the 17th day of Ramazan, it is also the day of Battle of Badr. We had inputs on escalation of their activities and grenade attacks,” he said. In Tral, located in volatile south Kashmir, militants hurled a grenade at a CRPF camp in which 10 paramilitary personnel were injured.Zulfiqar Hassan, IG (Operations), CRPF, said the injured were rushed to Army 92 Base Hospital in the city and were reportedly in a stable condition. Following a brief lull, the militants carried out five attacks within a span of an hour, targeting a guard post at the residence of a retired judge, a police station, CRPF camp and two Army camps.At the guard post securing the residence of retired Justice Muzafar Attar in south Kashmir’s Anantnag district, militants injured two policemen and looted four self-loading rifles.A police official said the militants opened indiscriminate fire at policemen guarding the house, injuring two of them. Attar, who is now affiliated with a political party, and his family were not at home.“Both the injured have been shifted to Anantnag district hospital. While one of them is stable, another is in a critical condition,” the police official said.In Pulwama district, militants hurled a grenade at a CRPF camp in Padgampora locality. Minutes later, militants fired a rifle grenade at the police station in Pulwama town and opened fire at the policemen. A police spokesman said two of their personnel sustained minor injuries. The fifth attack of the day targeted an Army camp in north Kashmir’s Sopore sub-district. The DGP said a rifle grenade was fired at the camp.Later in the night, the militants also attacked an Army camp at Lurgam village of Tral. Two personnel were injured in the attack. A police spokesman said the militants fired a rifle grenade at the 42 Rashtriya Rifles camp. 

Meeting on security

New Delhi: After holding meetings with CMs of Naxal-affected states and those having boundaries with Pakistan, China and Myanmar, Union Home Minister Rajnath Singh has called a conference of state Home Ministers on July 3 to discuss internal security.

 

 

 

clip

clip

clip


For a multi-pronged, pragmatic K-strategy Lt Gen Vijay Oberoi (retd)

download (2)

The use of both hard and soft power, a clampdown on all seditious elements and a changed game plan can help restore stability in Kashmir. However, for this an all-party consensus is a must, as the issue is one that affects the entire nation.

For a multi-pronged, pragmatic K-strategy
Treading a Tricky terrain: Soldiers stand guard at their Army base after it was attacked by suspected separatist militants in Panzgam in Kashmir”s Kupwara district. REUTERS

THE current instability in Jammu and Kashmir that had commenced in late 1989 has seen many ebbs and flows. The situation has deteriorated. It is not a case of “panic stations” at present, but the nation needs to work hard to bring about peace and tranquility. Calm can be restored but it must be carried out with a changed game plan.The problem is politico-military-administrative in nature, needing a holistic solution in accordance with a comprehensive plan.  While doing so, we need to ignore the whining of the “bleeding hearts” of all varieties and biased utterances of their fellow-travellers.  “Change” must emanate from the highest political level and be carried out in a cohesive manner.The political leadership must make course corrections and check the obvious drift in the state. This needs governing in earnest, with political leaders fanning out in their constituencies, ensuring that people-friendly projects move; give assurances; motivate the polity and deliberately stop politicking. The policy of appeasement and allowing anti-nationals to instigate the populace by using religion — “opiate of the masses” (Karl Marx) must end. This will close the window to Pakistan that has been used to create mayhem and havoc in the state by exporting Wahhabism, alien to Kashmir’s ethos.Political bungling in the past, both by the Centre and state leadership, needs to be re-visited. Jawaharlal Nehru  bungled by first going to the UN; then accepting plebiscite; and finally being persuaded by Sheikh Abdullah to add Article 370. Shastri grossly erred in reverting to the status quo on the ceasefire line after the 1965 war. After India’s decisive victory in 1971, Indira Gandhi missed a golden opportunity to enforce peace at gunpoint. VP Singh was blackmailed into releasing several terrorists for the “hostage,” the elder sister of the current Chief Minister. This was a decisive victory for the insurgents. Rajiv Gandhi erred in getting elections rigged through Farooq Abdullah. The UPA government that followed reinstated Farooq and continued the appeasement policy. Much was expected from Vajpayee but he slipped badly when he allowed the hostage swap, during the Kandahar hijacking and then was back-stabbed (Agra and Kargil). The next UPA government, in both tenures, showed little interest in Jammu and Kashmir, as it was too busy in other activities. Narendra Modi unilaterally extended his hand to make peace with Pakistan, till he realised that it was the powerful Pakistani Army that sabotaged all overtures. Within Kashmir, his link-up with PDP to form a coalition government has been a major mistake. At the state level, three Abdullahs, two Muftis’ (the senior Mufti twice) and a host of others have ruled the state. Not one provided good governance, but kept asking for additional funds. Today the per capita infusion of funds in Kashmir is 10 times higher than it is in the rest of India.Sheikh Abdullah spent 11 years behind bars for treason, yet Nehru released him and made him Chief Minister. His son brought militancy/insurgency/ terrorism to the state during his 1986-1990 tenure, when Pandits were massacred/driven out. As soon as stability was achieved during Governor’s rule, Farooq was brought back as a bad penny. From late 1989, when the Valley started boiling, the Army was the lead player. It stabilised the situation by 1996. Elections were held and Farooq Abdullah became the Chief Minister again. There was a spurt in infiltration from Pakistan, following the 1999 Kargil War, but the Army stabilised the situation again. Having made no headway, Pakistan changed tack and commenced instigating local youth through a highly emotive use of social media and liberal cash payments, to interfere in anti-insurgent operations, including by resorting to stoning.What is now needed is the use of  smart power (a mix of hard/soft power), devoid of any appeasement. Simultaneously, political/ administrative initiatives must explain pitfalls of violence and confrontational approach; and motivate the youth to shun violence. Additional jobs must be created, including massive recruitment to the Territorial Army (TA) and the police of all varieties.A complete clampdown on all factions of the Hurriyat is a must. They need to be charged with sedition and taken out of the state to face trial. Placing the state under Governor’s rule for a finite period is an option worth considering as the people have lost faith in the political dispensation. An all-party consensus is a must. It is not a party issue but one that affects the entire nation. Opposition parties need to play a constructive role and not continue with divisive acts and utterances. The Centre needs to set up an exclusive “Department of Perception Management”, under a dynamic non-bureaucratic head, comprising the media and tech-savvy technocrats, to counter the vicious propaganda of Pakistan’s ISI. It should produce and air programmes both in conventional and social media. Such a department must not be placed under any intelligence organisation or any uniformed force, as it will then have no credibility. There should be no talks with anyone at this stage, but responsible individuals and organisations, which can wield influence with the alienated youth and others should be identified. The “liberal pseudo-seculars” who falsely cry for “human rights” need to be ignored. They need to be attached to the Army and CAPF units operating in Kashmir to feel actualities on the ground. Only then they will realise that a soldier is the greatest victim of “human rights”.Pakistan, can never be trusted, however much we bend over backwards. We need to ignore biased world opinion and take decisions in our national interest. We should build allies in UN and with great powers to negate overtures by Pakistan. Our media (judged as the second worst in the world in a report by the World Economic Forum) needs to shun sensationalism and play a constructive and unbiased role in all security-related issues. Publicity is “oxygen” for all insurgents, therefore the need for reports to be circumspect.Stability operations by security forces must continue; all acts must be lawful but anybody breaking the law must not be spared. To ensure that massive funds being given are spent properly, an organisation, minus politicians, needs to be set up under the Governor to fund productive and people-friendly projects. Imposing strict “Rule of Law” is of paramount importance. Anyone acting against national interest must be dealt with expeditiously. Taking a cue from the handling of insurgency in Punjab in the 1970s-80s, a carrot-and-stick policy is needed. A professional Kashmiri Muslim police officer, if appointed as the DGP will achieve wonders. At the appropriate time, remove Article 370 after explaining how the state is suffering on account of this Article. The writer is a former Vice Chief of the Army Staff