
File photo of Christian Michel.
New Delhi, April 5
Christian Michel, alleged middleman arrested in the AgustaWestland VVIP Chopper scam, told a Delhi court on Friday that he has not named anyone in connection with the deal during investigation by the Enforcement Directorate, which has filed a supplementary chargesheet.
Michel, who alleged that the Central Government was using agencies for political agenda, filed an application after the reports appeared that ED in its chargesheet has named politicians of the previous UPA dispensation, defence personnel, bureaucrats and journalists as the beneficiaries of the controversial defence deal.
Michel’s counsel appeared with the application before Special Judge Arvind Kumar who issued notice to the probe agency and sought its reply by Saturday when he will take up the matter.
“Michel has not named anyone in his statement before the agency which is being leaked to media. This is only to make the matter sensational and prejudice the case against my client,” his counsel, Aljo K Joseph said.
He claimed the copy of the chargesheet, which was filed on Thursday, was provided to the media before it was provided to Michel.
He has questioned as to how the chargesheet was leaked to the media even before its cognisance was taken by the court.
The plea said that trial by a judge and free and fair trial rights override media rights and the court can temporarily curtail the freedom of the media to ensure that.
“The court is duty bound to balance it. Even to ensure a free and fair trail the court can temporarily curtail the freedom of media to ensure free and fair trial,” the plea said.
It further said that at the time of filing the chargesheet, the counsels for the accused had asked for supply of copies of the chargesheet, but it was objected to by the ED on the ground that the court has not yet taken cognisance of the chargesheet.
“Since this court is yet to take cognisance of the chargesheet, it appeared that the ED has clandestinely provided a copy of the same to the media houses, which were publishing the same in instalments only to sensationalise the issue and prejudice the accused named therein even before cognisance was taken by this court,” the plea claimed.
It said selective portions of the chargesheet have been published in the media which make it clear that the ED was not interested in a fair trial in a court of law but in a trial by media.
“The ED is making mockery of the judicial process resulting in complete travesty of justice. The extradition treaty prohibited the extradition of accused involved in the political offences and the government is now using the ED and all the investigating agencies for the political purpose. The supply of the chargesheet to the media houses is the best example of that,” it said.
The plea said that even though the court has not taken cognisance over the documents filed before it, in order to make the entire case a sensation again in the media, the ED had supplied the charge sheet to the media.
“The act of the prosecuting agency is highly condonable and contrary to the procedure established by law. It is pertaining to mention here that the prosecuting agency is acting as a weapon in the hands of the government and by clandestinely giving the documents to the media houses engineered in media trial with ulterior motives,” it claimed.
The plea further claimed that such hostile remarks might curtail the rights of Michel to a free and fair trial as he was a citizen of another country.
The ED had told the court on Thursday that Michel and other accused received 42 million euros as kickbacks in the defence deal.
The probe agency, in its 3,000-page supplementary chargesheet had also named David Syms, Michel’s alleged business partner, and two firms owned by them—Global Trade and Commerce Ltd and Global Services FZE—as accused.
Michel, extradited from Dubai in December last year, was one of the three middlemen being probed in the case, besides Guido Haschke and Carlo Gerosa, by the ED and the CBI.
On January 1, 2014, India scrapped the contract with Italy-based Finmeccanica’s British subsidiary AgustaWestland for supplying 12 AW-101 VVIP choppers to the IAF over alleged breach of contractual obligations and charges of paying kickbacks to the tune of Rs 423 crore by it for securing the deal. PTI
The Government advised by the Civil Service manning the MoD and aided by the Military Bureaucracy duty bound to obey due to the strict discipline code, seems to embark on a dangerous course of action.
The ECHS when merged with Ayushman Bharat will have two possible implications:
First: The scarce budget of the Veterans will be gobbled by the general patients leaving the Veteran patients sucking their thumbs. While today a few reputed hospitals are opting for de- panelling, in post Ayushman Bharat era , most reputed hospitals will be out of reach of Veterans.
Second: the quality of the treatment and patient care would fall so drastically that every Veteran would be forced to pay for his treatment in a reputed non empaneled hospital. This will create such dissatisfaction about the post retirement Medical Care of Veterans leading to possible poor morale among the serving soldiers as most of the Veteran are theirvclose kin and such burden of medical bills would fall on the heads of serving personnel.
By purpose or unwittingly, is there a campaign to change the way the Armed Forces live, administer themselves and look after the Veteran. Let the Political, Bureaucratic and Military leaders understand that the way that the Military lived, administered its serving and retired personnel ensured that the Armed Forces remained apolitical, professional and loyal to the country. Any whole sale change in these aspects can have far reaching consequences for the country, Government and the Armed Forces.
Why is there a fund crunch for ex servicemen? Reduce the salaries of all MP’s, MLA’s to 1/4 of their existing salaries, remove all their perks, security , no increase in their salaries. Stop pension for all who have not completed minimum 20 years. No Government vehicles to transport them, the Government will never be have any shortage of funds.
Also get the unaccounted money parked abroad, there’s plenty of funds.
It’s a challenge for the Government & not remove all entitlements agreed at the time of recruitment. A written promise committed by the Government in the form of advertisement can be challenged in the court of law. They can no longer take us for granted.
Why a scheme like ECH purely meant for Armed Forces should be merged with any other scheme,90%of soldiers after retirement suffer from serious health problems which are result of serving in extreme adverse physical and psychological conditions which adversely effect physical and mental health.There is no comparision to such conditions with civilian counter parts.So taking away the only post retirement health care scheme from soldiers who served the nation with utmost loyalty is grave injustice,it is already starving of funds inspite of one time contribution paid by retiring Sainiks.It is high time the serving Generals should take care of veterans and not submit to undue demands from politicians who act on mis guided and distorted information fed by bureaucracy.I give my own example,within six months of retirement i developed back ach,my hyper tension disease detected one and half year before retirement not granted any disability pension,because detected in peace station without giving due consideration to prior servicr done in Counter insugency operations and field areas.
Before government goes ahead with this merger etc it must take into account the impact on already crumbling ECHS. Costly and important medicines prescribed for cardiac care critical kidney disease etc are already in short supply for want of funds. Overloading of the system will bring in further resentment from the veterans and lower morale of the serving.
Needs a relook and bit of spine where top brass is concerned,
Politicians get free treatment abroad leave alone within the country…ample cases can be cited, similarly bureaucrats also enjoy almost similar privileges! Let them first opt for PMJAY! And set an example before eying already burdened & struggling ECHS!
Just see what treatment is given to our enimy solders and compare it with ECHS. Why should a soldier fight if he or his family not given the health care promised by Govt at the time of joining the force. There has been too much detetioration since the Chiefs do not speak up. Time has come that the soldiers will question ability of our officers to command. That will be sad day for the Nation. Our burocracy and politicians have done so much of damage to the forces. It is already too late even they realize it
God bless the Indian Army.JaiHind
Brig JD Sapatnrkar(Veteran)
Looking as though the country doesn’t want the Armed forces, let everyone become an ordinary civilian. Maybe it’s in the best interest of the politicians. But for the country, …. I suppose it’s
WHO CARES.
Most appropriate heading.What else is expected of a govt run by Beurocrates.The govt with a difference & vision here sees only the benifits it will gather by merging in the PM’s pet project a copy of Barack health scheme.However they donot realise that though the scheme is for ESM, yet it affects the services.Such shortsitedness will affect the rectt in the services & those who are serving & retire early will find it a big shock, thus affecting moral.If it has to merge what about additional load sharing resources.Then the excusiveness for services will diappear which have added advantage of most of doctors are Brothers in arms.The additional Health centres which come up due this scheme will have differant working ethos.I appeal to all ESM that they should unite & represent to govt.to stop such a merger & reinfuse new energy in the present scheme.Ifor one favour reforms.In any social scheme people do exploit lacunas, but it is also prudent that course correction must be done at regular intervals.