All posts by webadmin

US aid to Pakistan falls 76% in 17 yrs after 9/11

NEW DELHI: US aid and military assistance for Pakistan has plummeted from more than $2.2 billion a year during the period immediately after the 9/11 terror attacks to a little more than $500 million in 2017 and is set to fall further next year, reflecting the strain in ties between the two sides.

The total civilian and military assistance for 2017 was estimated at $526 million, a steep fall from the figures of the past decade. The total assistance in 2018 is expected to be even lower – $345 million, including $134 million in security-related assistance and $211 million in economic aid, according to figures collated by the Congressional Research Service (CRS).

Despite a sharp dip in relations following the killing of al-Qaeda chief Osama bin Laden in the Pakistani garrison town of Abbottabad in 2011, US assistance increased over the next two years to a little more than $2.6 billion a year before falling rapidly.

During the period between 2002 and 2011, the total aid — including economic support funds, foreign military financing, Coalition Support Fund reimbursements and anti-terrorism funding – was worth a total of $22.14 billion.

This included $8.8 billion in reimbursements from the CSF and a total of $5.7 billion in security-related aid. The CSF is used to reimburse Pakistan for logistical and operation support for US-led military operations in Afghanistan. The killing of Osama in a compound located close to a military academy had a significant impact on funding from the CSF.


WHERE ARE WE TAKING INDIA LEGACY :: ARE WE LESS THAN MOGULS OR WORSE TO ERASE INDIAN HISTORY

THE VEDIO GIVES INSIDE OUT OF THE CONTRIBUTION OF DAYAL SINGH MAJITIA , A WELL KNOW APOLITICAL LEADER EVER BORN IN INDIA.

WHERE ARE WE TAKING INDIA, IS INDIA NOW VANDE MARATAM ONLY AND NOTHING ELSE. WHY ARE WE PLAYING AND DISTORTING HISTORY AND ERASING A NOBLE SOULS CONTRIBUTION TO THE SOCIETY FOR EDUCATION.

WHY CAN’T  GOVT BUILD NEW COLLEGE WITH THE NAME “VANDE MARATAM OR JAN GAN MANN, OR SADAR PATEL OR DIN DAYAL UPADIYA . IT SEEMS THE AIM IS TO RUIN THE INTERNAL FABRIC  OF THE SOCIETY WITH CHEAP IDEOLOGY  AND DEGRADED MORALS.


HC reserves verdict on plea to recruit women in TA

New Delhi, November 30The Delhi High Court today reserved its verdict on a PIL alleging discrimination against women in the recruitment for the Territorial Army (TA), the second line of defence after the regular army.“Judgment reserved”, a Bench of Acting Chief Justice Gita Mittal and Justice C Hari Shankar said after arguments on behalf of the Centre, the petitioner and the amicus curiae appointed by the court.Petitioner Kush Kalra, in his plea, has alleged “institutionalised discrimination” against women for not being recruited in the TA. The court had earlier asked the Centre and the Army why women were not considered fit for the TA, in which actor Mohanlal and cricketers Kapil Dev and MS Dhoni are honorary members holding senior ranks. — PTI


Epic Battles: Revisiting Jaswantgarh And Rezangla Of 1962 On Their Anniversaries by Syed Ata Hasnain

The Jaswantgarh war memorialThe Jaswantgarh war memorial
Snapshot
  • Fifty-five years ago, this day, the heroic battle of Jaswantgarh was fought and here’s an account of how 4 Garhwal Rifles along with the Garhwali Bhullas stood up to the aggressor with valour.

17 and 18 November 1962 are two days enshrined boldly in India’s abundant military heritage. These two dates, so close to each other, symbolise valour and sacrifice of the highest order; they relate to the Sino-Indian Border Conflict 1962. As the Chinese People’s Liberation Army (PLA) fought a largely unprepared Indian Army, thrust into battle at foreboding heights in winter, post after post and defended area after another fell in the way of its advance. Almost a month after the Chinese launched their invasion on 20 October 1962 in NEFA and Ladakh gaining large tracts of territory and forcing the Indian Army to withdraw, two brave units fought an epic battle, each to bloody the Chinese and restore the image of the Indian Army. Coincidentally, one battle was in each of the two theatres of conflict – NEFA (now Arunachal Pradesh) and Ladakh.

A bust of Major Shaitan Singh (Medovar/Wikimedia Commons)A bust of Major Shaitan Singh (Medovar/Wikimedia Commons)

On 18 November 1962, in the forward defences of Chushul in the Eastern Ladakh sector, an Ahir company of 13 Kumaon under the command of Major Shaitan Singh, Param Vir Chakra (posthumous), withstood a series of attacks on its position and imposed heavy casualties on the enemy. This company occupying defences at Rezangla, provided depth to the Chushul Bowl, which was defended by 114 Infantry Brigade. In the morning of 18 November 1962, the Chinese PLA contacted the defences of one of the forward platoons. From then onwards it was a battle of attrition between them and the Kumaonis. Outgunned and outnumbered, the Kumaonis stuck on with the age old doctrine adage – ‘last man, last round’. Inspiring this obstinate stand and refusal to withdrawal was the company commander Maj Shaitan Singh who too was finally martyred. 13 Kumaon lost 114 all ranks and nine were severely wounded. This was a classic case of employment of sound sub unit tactics and it resulted in hundreds of PLA soldiers being killed. 13 Kumaon was bestowed with the battle honour Rezangla, the only honour granted for operations in Ladakh.

The second battle honour of 1962 was bestowed on 4 Garhwal Rifles (Garh Rif), for the heroic performance of the unit at Nuranang now called Jaswantgarh on 17 November 1962. It was the only battle honour won by a unit in the eastern theatre in 1962. 4 Garh Rif is my unit; raised by my father in 1959. I was its 14th Commanding Officer. This write up is not a tactical explanation of the battle of Jaswantgarh. It is simply a rendering of a layman account for public knowledge of what really happened and how the unit stood out so valiantly. It is my dedication to the three officers, four Junior Commissioned Officers (JCOs), 147 other ranks and seven non combatant tradesmen who were martyred at the Battle of Jaswantgarh. I knew almost all of them having been a six year old with the unit when it was raised. The unit is celebrating and marking the 55th anniversary of the battle on 17 November 2017, located far into the mountains of Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) where this year on Independence Day it was again the recipient of the largest number of honours and awards for its spectacular operation against infiltrating Pakistani terrorists. The operation was quoted to me by none other than Gen Bipin Rawat, Chief of Army Staff (COAS); he described the conduct as a copy book model for counter infiltration operations.

Before going on to provide a non tactical explanation of the battle of Jaswantgarh, it may be motivating for the reader to be aware of what Lt Gen BM Kaul wrote about the unit in his book The Untold Story. Describing the performance of units on the eastern front, he wrote “if more units of the Indian Army had fought the way 4 Garh Rif did, the history of the 1962 War may perhaps have been different”

In mid 1962 the unit was serving at Ramgarh, Bihar, and had just returned from counter insurgency operations in Nagaland. In September, it received its mobilisation orders and moved to Chardwar, near Rangia, Assam. As the Chinese threat increased progressively, the unit moved up from Tezpur and was deployed north west of the Tawang Chhu river. It did extensive patrolling and dominated the Tawang area. C company under its company commander, Maj (later Col) Hasta Bahadur Rai, patrolled the upper reaches of Tawang to prevent any infiltration.

When the Chinese attacked on 20 October 1962, the operations commenced from Thagla on the flank and then moved on to Bumla. The aim was to outflank and get to Tawang at the earliest before resting the front on the Tawang Chhu River to allow road building, move up of artillery and build up of logistics. Maj Rai’s company went out of communication with the battalion HQ and fell back much later as the withdrawal to own side of Tawang Chhu commenced through the bridge of Jang. (Please refer to the not to scale sketch in which most landmarks being referred here are reflected).

Schematic sketch showing the advance of the Chinese to Sela between 20 October and 20 November 1962.Schematic sketch showing the advance of the Chinese to Sela between 20 October and 20 November 1962.

The first phase of the Chinese operations ceased with the fall of Tawang. 4 Garh Rif was not involved in any of the serious fighting till then. It had reinforced Bumla with a company for a short while before operations commenced, but it withdrew on orders well before. With the Indian Army defeated and pushed back behind the Tawang Chhu, HQ 4 Infantry Division under Maj Gen MS Pathania issued orders for the occupation of Sela, the highest pass in the area, and its preparation as the new main position. In order to do this, it was necessary to keep the Chinese reconnaissance parties at bay and prevent them from crossing the Tawang Chhu.

It was also necessary that should the Chinese decide to attack earlier there should be sufficient organised defence ahead of Sela, the new main position where the ultimate battle would be fought for the restoration of the prestige of the Indian Army and the defeat of the PLA. Such a task is performed by what is called ‘covering troops’ by deploying ahead, absorbing the initial weight of the attack and preventing contact with the main defences. 4 Garh Rif was given the onerous task of occupying Nuranang, between Sela and Jang, as a covering position and performed the role of covering troops.

An inscription at the war memorialAn inscription at the war memorial

In current times you can drive from Tezpur to Tenga, break journey for the night before you start the next day, the arduous but highly picturesque drive to Sela (13,500 feet) via Roopa, Bomdila and Baisakhi. As you descend from Sela towards Jang, approximately 11 km away is a huge memorial, dedicated to the battle for the covering position at Nuranang fought valiantly by the unit. It succeeded in giving the Chinese a bloody nose. The memorial has changed shape and size many times but it has never lost the reverence of the local people, the Monpas nor that of the hordes of travellers who now halt to stretch, photograph, consume glasses of tea and pay obeisance at the virtual shrine which has emerged over a period of time. The shrine next to the memorial is that of Jaswant Baba. It’s a post martyrdom personification giving him great reverence. Jaswant was a rifleman of 4 Garh Rif. He earned a Mahavir Chakra posthumously for his gallant action at Nuranang. In his memory and honour, Nuranang is now called Jaswantgarh; it’s actually the location of the battlefield which is called by that name.

Here is a description of that heroic display by the unit at Jaswantgarh:

After the fall of Tawang, as the unit withdrew through Jang, almost the last unit to do so, the iron bridge over the river Tawang Chhu was finally destroyed as a reserved demolition. Alfa company under the command of 2/Lt (later colonel) S N Tandon was deployed at the current location of the memorial at the plateau which falls steeply towards the road going down to Jang. The battalion HQ, a company and the three-inch mortars were deployed approximately 1.5 km towards Sela, along the track. One company occupied the high ground to the north across the road and beyond the deep depression through which the Nuranang river flows. The fourth company was towards the south and slightly west of the memorial area covering the southern approach.

By 16 November 1962, the defences were in reasonable state although there was little overhead protection. The defences were being constantly shelled by the Chinese who had good observation from across the Tawang Chhu. Our artillery observation post officers also did likewise against PLA deployment. In the interim the CO, Lt Col (let Maj Gen) BM Bhattacharjee, decided to send some patrols to dominate the forward zone. One of these patrols led by 2/Lt Vinod Goswami volunteered to cross the Tawang Chhu by improvised means to ascertain strength and deployment of the PLA and if possible to capture a Chinese prisoner. The patrol moved by stealth, performed its task. While returning it targeted a PLA bunker and captured a sentry alive. Unfortunately, while bringing the prisoner across the Tawang Chhu it became extremely difficult to handle him as he was also wounded. He was finally abandoned believed dead. Goswami led some other daring missions during the run up to the battle at Jaswantgarh.

Finally on the night of 16/17 November, almost in sync with operations at Rezangla, the Chinese commenced phase two of their offensive. Probing actions against Alfa company were made by Chinese dressed as Monpa women but the troops (Bhullas) responded in time. Through 17 November and till the night of 17/18 November the location came under five heavy attacks and all were beaten back. After the third attempt, the Chinese managed to deploy a heavy machine gun (HMG) on the left (southern flank of Alfa company and its fire made it impossible for the Bhullas to fight effectively. This was the crucial moment. A party of three volunteers was formed. It comprised L/Nk Trilok Singh, riflemen Gopal Singh and Jaswant Singh. This party moved first by stealth and then under covering fire. In a hand to hand melee lasting several minutes the HMG was silenced and the crew was killed.

The bold action involved Trilok providing covering fire from a short distance away while Jaswant and Gopal assaulted and beheaded the PLA detachment with khukris. While recovering the weapon and dragging it back, Jaswant was killed by a burst. Trilok similarly died when the Chinese targeted him realising that it was his fire which had enabled the action. Gopal succeeded in returning with the weapon. The area around Alfa company and the slope towards Jang was strewn with a large number of bodies of PLA soldiers. The fourth and fifth PLA attacks were equally ferocious virtually following the tactics of human waves. However, Number 3 Platoon of Alfa company, under Sub Jatan Singh held on tenaciously.

As the battle was enjoined and the Garhwalis were creating history, the Chinese probed the flanks from a wide arc infiltrating self contained troops into the depth areas north and south of Sela. The pass was well stocked for battle and nearing completion of its defences, which were spread on both shoulders. Unfortunately there remained a perception in the mind of senior commanders about the invincibility of the Chinese soldier and an image of them being 10 feet tall, persisted. The masterful resistance by the Garhwalis at Jaswantgarh could not alter that perception.

As reports of Chinese infiltration came into HQ 4 Infantry Division there was panic, and orders to withdraw from Jaswantgarh were issued even as 4 Garh Rif was ready for more. It had sustained very few casualties, in fact, just three killed and a few wounded. Its three remaining companies were largely untouched except for shelling. However, through 18-19 November the unit withdrew on orders and reached Sela. There, the Commander 62 Infantry Brigade, the famous Brig Hoshiar Singh, briefed Lt Col Bhattacharjee. Two columns for the withdrawal to Bomdila were formed one each under the Commander and the CO. Two companies each of 4 Garh Rif formed the protection of each columns, which had many HQ personnel and stragglers withdrawing in panic.

The two columns ran into a series of Chinese ambushes as they tried cross country movements. In one of the ambushes, Brig Hoshiar Singh is reputed to have been wounded and captured. His refusal to submit to his captors is reputed to have enraged them leading to him being killed in cold blood. The Chinese strength of infiltrators far outnumbered the strength of the withdrawing columns. The attrition on the ambushes was intense and the troops dispersed in small groups many crossing into Bhutan on the west and made their way towards the rear, suffering intense cold with many cases of frost bite. Many were taken prisoner, including Lt Col BM Bhattacharjee and the Adjutant Capt Dharam Pal. Major HB Rai, 2/Lt SN Tandon and 2/Lt RP Singh were among the prisoners. 2/Lt VInod Goswami, Lt Hari Kishen Dev and Capt BK Nath(RMO) were killed at unknown places and time during the withdrawal.

The Garhwalis proved heroic in the custody of the Chinese too. They were singled out for maltreatment because of their stiff resistance at Jaswantgarh. Capt Dharampal was tortured and placed in isolated confinement due to his numerous attempts at escape. He was my first CO when I was commissioned in 1974. The strength of martyrs of the unit amounted to three officers, four JCOs, 147 ORs and seven non combatised tradesmen. A very large number became winter casualties. When the unit assembled at Ramgarh, the new CO Lt Col IS Rawat, KC had to virtually carry out re-raising. All citations were sent under his pen after meticulously charting out events from interviews with the men. The unit had lost its war diary and all its property. The citations led to award of two Maha Vir Chakra (MVC), 7 Vir Chakra (VrCs), 6 SMS and a host of other awards. Lt Col BM Bhattacharjee and Rifleman Jaswant received the MVC; among the VrC winners were L/Nk Trilok Singh, Rifleman Gopal Singh, 2/Lt SN Tandon, 2/Lt VINOD Goswami and Subedar Jatan Singh Gusain. The unit was finally awarded the battle honour Nuranang which is colloquially called Jaswantgarh.

Unfortunately the local people have created a myth around the battle of Jaswantgarh, crediting the resistance and heroic action only to Jaswant Singh and two young girls, Nura and Sela, who allegedly helped him resist the Chinese. Local folklore has it that the Chinese finally captured Jaswant Singh and beheaded him, taking his head away as trophy. These tales have their own place and have been written about and romanticised by media; even a film is being made about the myth of Jaswant Singh.

The only truth lies in the historical record of The Garhwal Rifles and the great spoken reputation that the Garhwali Bhullas acquired after the heroic battle of Jaswantgarh. Today, on 17 November, on the 55th anniversary of the battle, we, the members of the community of the Jaswantgarh Battalion bow our heads in reverence to our ancestors and resolve never to let down the reputation and name of the Nation and the Regiment.

This has to end with the war cries of the Garhwalis and Kumaonis.

Kalika Mata Ki Jai! (war cry of the Kumaonis).

Bol Badri Vishal Lal Ki Jai! (victory to the followers of Badri Vishal). Badri Vishal is the personification of Lord Vishnu, the presiding deity of the Garhwalis.

Jai Hind!

The author is a second generation officer of 4 Garhwal Rifles, the unit which fought at Jaswantgarh. He was its 14th Commanding Officer.


Two summits & an agenda by KC Singh

Two summits & an agenda
Big picture: PM Modi must realise the real challenge is without, not within.

KC Singh

THIS week focus returns to Asia as two major summits — Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) and East Asia Summit (EAS) — are held in Vietnam and the Philippines, respectively. India is not a member of the first, though desirous of joining it. PM Narendra Modi shall interrupt relentless campaigning in Gujarat to attend the latter on November 12. US President Donald Trump, combining bilateral visits to Japan, the Republic of Korea (ROK), China, Vietnam and the Philippines with attending both summits, heightens interest, particularly as earlier he was skipping the EAS. Chinese President Xi Jinping, newly endorsed for a second five-year term by the 19th Party Congress, attending the APEC Summit completes the Asian drama. The US State Department announced that Trump’s focus would be on neutralising nuclear threat from the Democratic Republic of Korea (DPRK), promoting a free and open Indo-Pacific (euphemism for contesting Chinese corralling of two- thirds of South China Sea, via artificial island building) and reciprocal trade, i.e., balancing the huge US trade imbalances with China, Japan and ROK. Trump is also expected to reassure allies and partners concerned over perceived US retreat from the region. Essentially, the summits this year are a power play between the US and China and a contest between two alternative visions of growth and governance. The Western liberal, democratic and free trade model is posited against the Chinese model, fine-tuned by President Xi, of economic success through centralised and authoritarian management underpinned by  nationalism minus civil liberties and elective government. The 19th Chinese Party Congress has allowed Xi to consolidate power and perhaps become the most powerful leader since Mao Zedong, with allies and followers controlling important institutions. Significantly, no clear successor is visible, thus breaching injunction by Deng Xiaoping, father of the Chinese economic miracle that his successors would only hold two five-year terms. Among the seven-member standing committee of the politburo, the de facto Chinese cabinet, is Wang Huning — professor, ideologue and adviser to all post-Deng presidents. He devised the “Three Represents” of President Jiang Zemin, recommending party reachout to private business and professionals and is now behind “Xi Jinping Thought” embedded in the constitution. He has, over decades, provided intellectual ballast to Chinese rulers’ view that social and economic change can only be accomplished by centralised and authoritarian rule, while freezing political evolution. The Tiananmen Square uprising by students in 1989 was taken by them as confirming its validity. Xi has added an anti-graft edge, thus enhancing his own “legitimacy”, which in Chinese tradition is called the “Mandate of Heaven”. Ensuing public support has enabled him to purge potential rivals or dissenters.At the 19th Congress, President Xi reiterated his “China Dream” to make the nation a “basically modernised nation” by 2035 and a “rich and powerful socialist nation” by 2050. The 21st century continental and maritime Silk Route, called the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), is the next step to achieve this. It is imagined as a Sino-centric network for trade and investments to rival, if not supplant, existing post-World War II architecture created by the West under US leadership. The Xi-Trump summit thus assumes importance. China seeking “great power relationship” is nothing but a desire for the US to accept them as the only “other” in a bipolar engagement. Trump has frequently praised Xi in the past, even calling him “King of China”, perhaps in line with his penchant for authoritarian rulers, assuming he can flatter them for a shortcut to strategic compromise. Trump would seek China to compel DPRK to accept nuclear restraint, if not disarmament; balance bilateral trade; and end Chinese predatory trading practices and poaching of intellectual property. Xi will tactically yield some ground but is unlikely to kow-tow fully. Asian neighbours of China, concerned over Trump’s erratic and vacillating policy making, must devise alternative strategies, assuming Trump will, at best, henceforth, be an off-shore balancer. In a Pew Research Centre poll, only 24 per cent Japanese trust Trump compared to 78 per cent giving thumbs up to former President Barack Obama. PM Shinzo Abe is hewing a path by not allowing the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) to collapse, inviting 11 members, minus the US which quit, to a meeting before Trump’s visit. He has also resurrected and elevated to political level the 2007 meeting of Australia, India, Japan and the US, dubbed the Quad — a gathering of major regional democracies, expandable to include others later. As a swing power, India must use these emerging China-containing mechanisms as, indeed, alternative groupings, where China and India share space, for instance BRICS, etc. Meanwhile, authoritarianism is spreading globally like a pandemic. Polls in India indicate a vast majority preferring a “strong” ruler. The play book is almost identical, despite differences in political and historical contexts. Crown Prince Mohammad bin Salman in Saudi Arabia or President Xi in China or PM Modi in India use anti-corruption crusades to purge rivals, isolate opponents and bolster public image. Trump himself operates beyond the confines of own party and the Congress, sustained by social media. Nationalism becomes the handmaiden to suppress dissent and demoralise, or even silence media. Differences of power use or abuse are obliterated between authoritarian rulers straddling different political systems. An Atlantic Council study predicts Indo-Pacific as globally the most economically dynamic region by 2050. With a fundamental power shift underway, the study concludes a “Trans-Pacific century” has already begun. China’s BRI, advances in Artificial Intelligence, Asian Infrastructure and Investment Bank, renewal energy advances and rededication to futuristic industries is its path to growth and rapid power accrual. The BJP-led Modi government, meanwhile, expends energy on eliminating opposition and constant electioneering, implementing ambitious, but poorly conceived schemes like demonetisation and now GST, corralling media, exulting in selective positive economic news and soaring stock market. The bubble may be more than in share prices and reality has been known to prick it inopportunely. PM Modi has a narrowing window to close ranks domestically and realise his challenge is without, not within. Unless he self-corrects soon, like Rajiv Gandhi in 1984 when China under Deng Xiaoping had only a four-year head-start over India, his would be a wasted mandate. The writer is a former Secretary, Ministry of External Affairs


China objects to Defence Minister Sitharaman’s visit to Arunachal

China objects to Defence Minister Sitharaman’s visit to Arunachal

Sitharaman on Sunday visited forward army posts in remote Anjaw district of Arunachal Pradesh bordering China to take stock of the defence preparedness. PTI file

Beijing, November 6

China on Monday objected to Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman’s first visit to Arunachal Pradesh, saying her tour of the “disputed area” is not conducive to the peace and tranquillity in the region.

(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)

Sitharaman on Sunday visited forward army posts in remote Anjaw district of Arunachal Pradesh bordering China to take stock of the defence preparedness.

“As to Indian Defence Minister visit to Arunachal Pradesh, you must be very clear about China’s position,” Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Hua Chunying told a media briefing.

“There is a dispute on the eastern section of the China-India boundary. So this visit by the Indian side to the disputed area is not conducive to the peace and tranquillity of the relevant region,” she said in a response to a question.

The Indian side should work with the Chinese side to make contribution to properly revolving the issue through dialogue and create enabling environment and conditions, she said.

“Hope India will work China for the shared goal, seek a solution acceptable to both sides and accommodate our concerns in a balanced way,” she said.

China claims Arunachal Pradesh as part of South Tibet and routinely objects to top Indian officials’ visit to the area.

The Line of Actual Control (LAC) between India and China stretches to 3,488 kms. Both sides have held 19 rounds of talks by the Special Representatives to resolve the dispute.

Sitharaman had visited Nathu La area on the India-China border in Sikkim last month and greeted the People’s Liberation Army soldiers across the border. PTI


Guru Nanak Gurpurab: A Dedication To The Brave Sikh Community by Lt Gen (retd) Syed Ata Hasnain

A Sikh devotee takes bath in the holy sarovar and pays obeisance at Golden Temple in Amritsar. (Sameer Sehgal/Hindustan Times via Getty Images)

SNAPSHOT

The Sikh community celebrates the birth anniversary of the first Sikh guru, Guru Nanak, on 4 November this year.

Lt Gen (retd) Syed Ata Hasnain writes about this brave and generous community on the occasion of Gurpurab.

My years in the Indian Army, as an Army brat and an officer, taught me the love and respect I carry for all faiths and ethnicities in India. It’s a part of service life because one has friends, superiors and subordinates from all over India, representing the country’s vast diversity. Most of all, those years instilled in me the realisation that not many nations give their citizens a chance to share their lives with people from a diverse stock. Being a part of the services community was an education in sensitivity and pride in the wider plurality of India. The Army, of course, is a great example of unity in diversity, India’s greatest asset and contribution to humanity.

On Gurpurab, my sincere good wishes to our Sikh friends and indeed to the Sikh people all over the world. I wish to convey to them that they follow a great faith, sensitive in respect for others, rich in its history of sacrifice and unique for its great sense of tolerance for plurality. They are a people famous for loyalty and friendship. To them I doff my hat because they contribute to India’s uniqueness far more in proportion than the numbers they exist in. When a flood hits Kashmir, it is their gurudwaras which contribute food packets in hundreds, all cooked by volunteers. When Muslims do not have a place to offer their Eid namaaz, they offer them the facilities of their gurudwaras. When Rohingyas at the far away borders become refugees, Sikhs offer them solace and relief without asking for anything in return. Is there anything Sikhs do not do to enhance feelings of oneness among human beings?

Once I was invited to a college in Ludhiana to deliver a motivational talk to a group of people. There was a large Sikh presence in the audience – people of all ages and professions. I was clear in my mind about what needed to be spoken. Commencing slowly and softly, I stated that I was a reluctant speaker because I knew I was addressing a great community of people. I told them I had not come to Ludhiana to motivate them because in my opinion the Sikh community needed no encouragement and no motivation; in fact, I had come to be motivated by their collective presence, by their history of courage and fortitude, their passion for life and, most of all, their humility; the followers of the great Guru Gobind Singh needed no one to come and give them lectures in courage and motivation. The tears in the eyes said it all. It’s a memory close to my heart.

How does humility connect with Sikhism? For those who may never have had the pleasure and honour to visit a gurudwara, it’s a visual treat to observe the cleanliness around; volunteers there can put any ‘swachch’ campaign to shame. The devotion is intense, with volunteers undertaking every possible chore to make the community event successful. You won’t ever feel the need to secure your footwear because there will be many people to protect your possessions with their lives. The ‘guru ka langar’ or the community lunch eaten together by devotees, is an exercise in devotion, love and humility. Volunteers cook up a simple fare, but the divine hand of the gurus instills in that fare a taste which you cannot find anywhere. The driest of rotis and the simplest of dals (lentils) combine to give the flavour of the gods. Anyone and everyone are welcome with no questions asked. Stories abound of experiences of people who have stopped at gurudwaras in emergencies and had food served at odd hours, before they could even utter a word about their problem.

When it comes to fun and games, none can beat the Sikhs. They know how to laugh at themselves and can out-drink and out-dance anyone. Their boisterousness can be a tad unnerving for a few of those who are more sedate in outlook. Friendships with them come from the oddest of things. During my school days at the hostel, at the beginning of the year I always feared having my bed next to a Sikh friend. For no other reason but that I had to rise 30 minutes earlier to help my young friend to wrap up his turban in that amazing thing called a pooni(wrapped turban cloth). Young Sikh boys wrestling with outsized turbans, was a common sight in days when the patka was still passé and considered highly informal. Today, none of my Sikh friends allow me to help them with the poonibecause they refuse to believe my prowess and experience in this fine art.

Through my growing years, I was fortunate to see many Sikh units in my father’s command and equally many Sikh friends with their families who visited us and we them. The throaty cries of “bole so nihal, sat sri akal” from those days still reverberate in my memories.

In my years as a senior officer, I had my unique way of paying obeisance to Guru Nanak on Gurpurab. First, as much as could be helped, I had one of the Sikh units from my formation mount the residential guard or provide protection to a convoy of vehicles. This allowed me to visit them first thing in the morning and do a matha teko (prostration) at their small gurudwara. Second, I would use a helicopter to visit every Sikh unit of the formation, do a prostration at the unit gurudwaraand present sweets. The round robin would end at the unit deployed at the most difficult location. Guru ka langar would be partaken there with the troops and all devotees of the revered guru; many local villagers would usually join in.

The Army continues to be an institution which consciously promotes India’s unity in diversity through the ‘sarv dharm sthal’ concept; all faiths praying beneath one roof with symbols of every faith together on display. That is why a soldier is comfortable with any religious symbolism, any devotional music and with any sermon being addressed to him. It is because he is uniquely the Indian we all must desire to be.


Rising debt-trap Demonetisation spurred credit card trap

Rising debt-trap

Credit card holders’ collective liability to banks has soared to nearly 60,000 crore by the end of this September, a whop  ping 39 per cent jump in a year. Indeed, it is one of the side effects of demonetisation that was unleashed a year ago. Banks, particularly private ones, took advantage of this cash squeeze to boost credit card use; selling over 60 lakh credit cards in just one year. First time users of the plastic cards were thrilled by the new found power of nearly-unlimited purchase, unaware of its potential to land them in a debt-trap. They did not realise the ease of purchase had an attached cost – exorbitant interest rates of 40 per cent or more with the interest calculated on an average daily balance method. Banks justify the usurious interest rates in order to neutralise the impact of payment defaults. Thus, a credit card may well become an instrument non-performing asset (NPAs) for banks and debt-traps for customers. The credit card is one of the innovative and modern payment options. It is not an evil per se provided one knows how to uses it. A credit card comes in handy in cases of emergencies such as hospitalization or emergency travel. The smart user avails all its benefits including discounts, complimentary insurance, rewards points and special privileges associated with individual cards. To the frustration of banks, a smart user never allows any outstanding to accumulate. But, the temptation of ‘purchase now and pay later’ also encourages conspicuous consumption and some cardholders end up spending more on their ability to repay. Thus the debt-trap is created.Notwithstanding the accumulated arrears, banks aggressively promote their plastic cards. The industry is growing faster especially after last November’s demonetisation. It is intriguing; either the banks are sitting on another NPA bomb or they are minting money by charging high interest rates. This is alarming in either case. The card business needs to be properly regulated. Banks require to acquaint consumers unambiguously about every intricate detail associated with the usage of plastic cards. The RBI too should monitor interest rates charged by banks on credit cards.


Army to build foot overbridge in Mumbai, many wonder why

Army to build foot overbridge in Mumbai, many wonder why
Commuters queue up near the Elphinstone railway station foot overbridge, where a stampede killed 23 persons recently. PTI

Tribune News Service

Mumbai/New Delhi, October 31

The Army has been roped in to build foot overbridges at the Elphinstone road railway station in Mumbai where 23 persons were killed in a stampede a month ago.Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis, along with Railway Minister Piyush Goyal and Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, visited the railway station with engineers from the Army this morning. Fadnavis said the new overbridge would be completed by January 31. (Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)The Army would also build foot overbridges at the Currey Road and Ambivali railway stations, Fadnavis said. While Currey station lies in Mumbai city limits, Ambivali lies between Kalyan and Kasara on the outskirts of the city. Earlier, the Railways had floated a tender for the construction of a foot overbridge at Elphinstone station. However, Goyal was told that the new bridge would take a year to complete. “We have decided to take help of the military…  as there is an urgent need to complete the bridges at the earliest. The three stations have been identified as these witness a very high footfall,” Goyal said.Sitharaman said this was the first time that the Army had been called in for carrying out civil work in the country’s financial capital. “The Army conducted a feasibility study to assess whether it could complete the work or contribute to the process,” Sitharaman added.The move, meanwhile, has led to severe criticism.

download

Punjab Chief Minister Capt Amarinder Singh, a 1965-war veteran, said “the Army’s job is to train for war and protect the country’s borders, not to build bridges and clean  roads”. He said there could be serious implications of such misuse of the armed forces by utilising their services for non-emergency civilian jobs.Urging Defence Minister Sitharaman to refrain from diverting critical defence resources to civilian works, he cited what he termed a mistake that Maj Gen BM Kaul, GOC of ‘Red Eagles’ 4th Division, had made before the 1962 war with China. The scandalous misuse by him of military manpower to build accommodation cost the Indian Army heavily during the Sino-Indian war, the Chief Minister said.The Defence Minister, instead of being party to this decision and announcing it with such pride, should have  rejected any such suggestion in the interest of the armed forces, Capt Amarinder said.

Former Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Omar Abdullah said the Army was supposed to be called in as a last resort at times of emergencies. “Now, it seems like it is the first number on speed dial,” he said. Congress’ Sanjay Nirupam said “calling in the Army to construct the bridges underlines the failure of BMC. Hope the Army will not be asked to fill potholes here”. 


China mulls 1,000-km tunnel to carry Brahmaputra water

Beijing, October 30

Chinese engineers are testing techniques that could be used to build a 1,000-km long tunnel, the world’s longest, to carry water from the Brahmaputra in Tibet close to Arunachal Pradesh to the parched Xinjiang region, a media report said today.The move, expected to “turn Xinjiang into California”, has raised concerns among environmentalists about its likely impact on the Himalayan region, a Hong Kong-based daily reported. The proposed tunnel, which would drop down from the world’s highest plateau in multiple sections connected by waterfalls, would provide water in China’s largest administrative division, comprising vast swathes of deserts and dry grasslands.(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)The water would be diverted from the Yarlung Tsangpo river in southern Tibet, which turns into the Brahmaputra once it enters India, to the Taklamakan desert in Xinjiang. China’s longest tunnel is the 85-km Dahuofang water project in Liaoning province, while the world’s longest tunnel is the 137-km main water supply pipe beneath the city of New York.India, a riparian state, has already flagged its concerns to Beijing about various dams being built by it on the Brahmaputra, which is known as Yarlung Tsangpo in China.  Beijing has been assuring India and Bangladesh, which is also a recipient of the waters from the river, that its dams were of the run of river projects and not designed to storing water.Wang Wei, a researcher who helped draft the latest Tibet-Xinjiang water tunnel proposal, said over 100 scientists formed different teams for the nationwide research.  The team suggested to drain Brahmaputra at Sangri county in southern Tibet. — PTI

Commanders meet

  • Military commanders of India and China met at the Bum La (pass), north of the historic monastery town of Tawang in Arunachal Pradesh, on Monday
  • The Indian delegation was led by Brig MP Singh and the Chinese delegation by Sr Col Liu Jiang Xun
  • A defence spokesman said thaw in the relations was evident during the meeting as both delegations interacted in a free, congenial and cordial environment TNS