All posts by webadmin

Modi, Parrikar to decide on chief of defence staff role

NEW DELHI: Major military reforms are in the offing with defence minister Manohar Parrikar slated to meet Prime Minister Narendra Modi early next month to discuss the mandate of a proposed chief of defence staff (CDS).

Work has begun on creating joint commands to optimise resource utilisation among the three armed services; the Army, Navy and the Air Force.

South Block sources told Hindustan Times that the Modi government has decided to appoint a CDS, a single point military adviser to the political leadership in matters of acquisition, procurement policy and resource rationalisation.

The mandate for the proposed CDS will be decided by defence minister Parrikar in consultation with the PM and National Security Adviser Ajit Doval. “The new post of CDS will not be used for parking slots for super-ceded generals and a new man will be tasked with the job once work profile is clearly defined,” said a senior official.

Parrikar is currently studying the report of retired General DB Shekatkar on making military more effective with better teeth-to-tail ratio.

The Shekatkar committee has also identified areas where there is redundancy, and downsizing of the military could be undertaken without compromising combat effectiveness.

“For example, a couple of hundred signal troopers had been deployed to listen to radio broadcasts in 1962. This unit is still functional despite it being technologically redundant. Similarly, the National Cadet Corps could be downsized by more than 50% by hiring retired soldiers,” said the official.

After preferring merit to seniority in appointment of Army Chief, the defence ministry is now examining the case for a joint command as a step towards integrated theatre commands.

The Army, Air Force and Navy currently operate in silos with each protecting its turf and operations. The ministry now is looking towards creating integrated structures where all three services are synergized towards military operations.

For example, it is proposed that Northern Command could come under one overall commander from any one of the three services, with overall control of all military and air assets. “This does not mean that top level vacancies will be reduced. Only that there would be one overall commander in one theatre and future roles of military chiefs being redefined and refocused. Essentially, the reforms will be close to what has been done in US Armed Forces with tweaking on ground,” said a senior official.

However, top defence analysts are sceptical about the theatre command concept as it not only required dedicated military resources but also command synergy at the cutting-edge levels. According to them, maybe the first step could be formation of triservices battle groups before the theatre command concept is followed.

“US has global armed presence and hence the theatre command concept works with dedicated land, air and naval assets earmarked for each command. In India, we have flexible air and naval assets that are earmarked as per operational requirement,” said an analyst.

NEW MILITARY ORDER

Once the proposed post of chief of defence staff is made official, the Army, Navy and the Air Force will have a shared command structure For instance, it is proposed that Northern Command could come under one overall commander from any one of the three services with overall control of all military and air assets Currently, the three wings of the military operate in silos, each protecting its turf and operations But experts say the concept should come only after joint battle groups are created


Parrikar writes to Didi, says ‘deeply pained’ at allegations against Army

Tribune News Service

New Delhi, December 9

Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar has written to West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee saying he is “deeply pained” at allegations made against the Army. He said the forces were “apolitical”.Mamata and her party members in a series of tweets had alleged that the Army had carried out its movement in West Bengal without any sanction from the state government. The country-wide exercise was to keep a count on movement of heavy vehicles on December 1 and 2.Parrikar in his letter written on Thursday cited the allegations made by the West Bengal CM and reported in the media and told her, “Your (Mamata) allegations in this regard run the risk of adversely impacting the morale of the country’s armed forces and the same were not expected from a person of your standing and experience in public life.”The Defence Minister reminded the TMC supremo that there was extensive correspondence between the Kolkata-based Eastern Command of the Army and the state government.He said the Army was one of the most disciplined institutions of the country. “The country is proud of their professionalism and apolitical conduct,” Parrikar said, adding that as political parties we have the luxury of making wild and unsubstantiated allegations but one must be very careful when referring to our armed forces. He also assuaged the CM that the Army was forced to go public with the correspondence after allegations.Mamata hits back at Defence MinisterKolkata: Unrelenting West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee on Friday replied Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar’s letter, saying while she has the highest regard for the Army, she will not tolerate if the Centre uses the Army to intimidate BJP’s political opponents. In her letter to the minister, she reiterated that the exercise was carried out without taking permission of the state government. She also claimed the police had objected to deployment of jawans at the toll plaza near the state secretariat and the objection was ignored by the Army. TNS

PARRIKAR ‘PAINED’ AT MAMATA OUTBURST, BENGAL CM SAYS GRIPE WITH GOVT, NOT ARMY

KOLKATA: Defence minster Manohar Parikkar has written to Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee expressing ‘anguish’ at her recent remarks against the armed forces and said her comments could adversely impact the morale of the forces.

In the evening, Banerjee shot off a reply alleging she has never seen such a political vendetta.

Parikkar’s letter, dated December 8, also said that the comments were not expected from the Trinamool chief who has decades of experience in public life. “Your allegations in this regard run the risk of adversely impacting the morale of the armed forces and the same was not expected from a person of your standing,” wrote Parikkar.

Mamata shot back saying, “My complaint was not against the army. It was against your government and the government policy as they act under your directions. During my long political and administrative life I have never seen such political vendetta by misusing the role of an esteemed organisation.”

The chief minister is yet to receive the letter that has been leaked to the media. She will send a strong reply as we have a strong case,” remarked Trinamool Rajya Sabha MP Derek O Brien on Friday.

On December 1, Banerjee had lashed out at the Centre for deploying army in her state without informing the government, which she said, amounted to a coup. Her comments came against the backdrop of her high-pitched battle against the Centre on the Prime Minister’s demonetisation move.

As the news hit headlines, army officers retorted saying it was nothing but a “routine exercise” that was conducted in other states.

Parrikar ‘pained’ by Bengal CM’s remarks on army, Didi cries vendetta Screen govt’s public campaigns in theatres: Centre tells states

KOLKATA: Defence minster Manohar Parikkar has written to Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee expressing ‘anguish’ at her recent remarks against the armed forces and said her comments could adversely impact the morale of the forces.

In the evening, Banerjee shot off a reply alleging she has never seen such a political vendetta.

Parikkar’s letter, dated December 8, also said that the comments were not expected from the Trinamool chief who has decades of experience in public life. “Your allegations in this regard run the risk of adversely impacting the morale of the armed forces and the same was not expected from a person of your standing,” wrote Parikkar.

Mamata shot back saying, “My complaint was not against the army. It was against your government and the government policy as they act under your directions. During my long political and administrative life I have never seen such political vendetta by misusing the role of an esteemed organisation.”

“The chief minister is yet to receive the letter that has been leaked to the media. She will send a strong reply as we have a strong case,” remarked Trinamool Rajya Sabha MP Derek O Brien on Friday.

On December 1, Banerjee had lashed out at the Centre for deploying army in her state without informing the government, which she said, amounted to a coup. Her comments came against the backdrop of her high-pitched battle against the Centre on the Prime Minister’s demonetisation move.

As the news hit headlines, army officers retorted saying it was nothing but a “routine exercise” that was conducted in other states.


Economists speak up on demonetisation

Featured are summary views, solicited by The Tribune, on the government’s demonetisation move from nine economists of impeccable credentials, differing ages, a spectrum of ideological persuasions, and a variety of locations. We encounter amidst this diversity of backgrounds a profound sameness of opinion, as reflected in unanimous denunciation of the government’s action in sentiments and assessments such as: “essentially political move,…insensitive,…,gratuitous,..,appalling”; “firing cannonballs to kill mosquitoes”; “arrogance and insensitivity”; “an exercise in Manichean economics”; “authoritarian quackery”; “heavy cost to the economy”; “frightening abandonment of reason”; “throwing the baby out while retaining the bathwater”; and “a cavalier or even cynical political calculation”Here’s a cross-section of  scholarly opinion.Essentially political move

Venkatesh Athreya

(retired Professor of Economics, Bharatidasan University, Tiruchi)The demonetisation measure of the Government of India may, at best, disable a portion of black wealth held in the form of currency notes that have ceased to be legal tender. The stock of black wealth held in currency form has been generally estimated at around 5 to 6 per cent of the total. A portion of this stash has already been laundered. Current estimates of black money trapped through demonetisation do not exceed three lakh crore. The claim that the demonetisation was aimed at immobilising counterfeit currency is lacking in credibility, with such currency estimated to value no more than Rs 400 crore, a very small proportion of the value of the high-denomination notes that were in circulation. The current measure does not address the continued generation of black money through tax evasion. Demonetisation as a weapon against terrorism is a claim bordering on the ridiculous.  Corruption is not a one-time activity to be put an end to through this measure. The move seems essentially political. The Prime Minister’s statement that the opposition parties are unhappy because they were not “prepared” can be construed to imply that the ruling party at the Centre was prepared. The mounting criticism of the government on its failure to bring back black wealth stashed abroad as promised in the Lok Sabha polls, agrarian distress, industrial stagnation, rising unemployment, intolerance of alternate points of view, and the perception that this government is anti-Dalit and anti-Muslim, could all have been seen as negative in the context of the impending elections in some major states. Demonetisation may have been seen as a “big-bang” measure that would enhance the regime’s credibility in fighting black money and divert attention from its perceived failures.  The informal economy accounts for 80 per cent or more of the workforce and nearly a half of total output. It has been grievously stricken by the government’s woefully inadequate preparation and complete failure to anticipate the impact of the move it has unleashed.  This has been the inevitable consequence of the massive reduction in liquidity visited on an economy that conducts nearly 90 per cent of its transactions in cash. It has not only meant a great deal of avoidable distress, including deaths, for the mass of the people but also a devastation of the economy in the short and medium terms, with no guarantees for a revival subsequently. The advice to ordinary people to go digital in a context of poor bank and internet penetration is not only insensitive and gratuitous, but positively appalling.


Huge collateral damage

Maitreesh Ghatak

(Professor, The London School of Economics and Political Science, London)The demonetisation policy, at best, is a one-time tax on black money that is stored in the form of cash.  But only around 5-6 per cent of undisclosed income is held in cash. Therefore, even if all of it gets targeted by this measure, it will not be an effective way to go at the existing stock of black money. Moreover, black money generation is a continuing process that involves evading taxes and regulations, and engaging in corrupt and criminal activities. These cannot be tackled with a one-time measure. They will continue unabated with the new currency notes. Ironically, this reform may even increase the stock of black money held in cash in the future by facilitating hoarding in currency notes of a higher denomination (the Rs 2000 notes). Even if the effectiveness of the policy in curbing black money will be minimal, the cost will be very high.  Other than the direct cost of printing new notes, given that the affected currency notes constituted 86 per cent of the total volume of cash in the country, this policy effectively led to a much higher drop in liquidity than even the drop in the money supply (about 30 per cent ) that the US Fed is criticised for doing during the Great Depression. The informal sector is largely cash-dependent and alone accounts for 40 per cent of the GDP and employs 80 per cent of the workforce. It, along with the rest of the economy, is suffering perhaps the biggest policy-induced recessionary shock in post-Independence India.  Add to it the physical hardship imposed on ordinary citizens in terms of standing in line, and strain on the capacity of the banking sector, which have resulted in deaths. This may go down in recent history as the biggest example of firing cannonballs to kill mosquitoes (granted that these were causing the malaria of corruption), with huge collateral damage. 


Breathtaking insensitivity

Jayati Ghosh

(Professor, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)The declared motivation of this drastic demonetisation keeps changing: from stopping “black money” to combating terrorist funding through counterfeit notes, to moving to a cashless society. But the welfare of ordinary citizens clearly forms no part of the government’s agenda. The flawed design suggests a basic lack of knowledge of the nature of the black economy, and an unwillingness to address the processes that allow parallel untaxed incomes.  To deal with counterfeit notes a more gradual withdrawal of old notes would have been possible. Instead, the blanket ban on the bulk of notes in circulation has abruptly denied liquidity to the bulk of the economy’s transactions, without providing a sufficient supply of new notes to replace them. The ensuing chaos has gone well beyond causing mere “inconvenience”, to immense and continuing personal hardship and even deaths among the worst affected; destruction of livelihoods in informal and formal sectors; terrible effects on farmers caught between harvesting and sowing seasons; contracting demand that impacts the macroeconomy.  Constantly changing implementation rules point to more than inefficiency and lack of preparedness. They suggest that the government essentially has no trust in the citizenry. Therefore, the need for secrecy and the sudden strike; the constraints put on the exchange of old notes; the suspicion of deposits put into Jan Dhan bank accounts; the denial of exchange facilities to cooperative banks and other institutions run by state governments. The underlying premise is that anyone who is the holder of the now-delegitimised currency notes is either a criminal or acting on behalf of criminals. Effectively, only those using plastic or electronic money are “honest”. In this whole episode, the government’s arrogance and insensitivity have been breathtaking. But as the mess continues and the material damage grows, its ability to hoodwink the population cannot last for too long. 


Save economy from slump

Parikshit Ghosh

(Associate Professor, The Delhi School of Economics, Delhi)The sudden demonetisation of 86 per cent of the country’s currency stock, ostensibly to fight black money, counterfeiting and terrorist funding, is an exercise in Manichean economics. The decision seems propelled by a desire to project an epic battle against evil rather than any pragmatic weighing of costs against benefits.Replacing one currency by another will not prevent the kind of cash transactions the parallel economy thrives on. Demonetisation will wipe out only a small fraction of the stock of wealth accumulated through illegal means, since most of it is held in gold, land and real estate. Fake notes are rare and the new ones do not seem to have vastly superior security features. The massive liquidity shock has predictably dealt a big blow to production and trade in a primarily cash-based economy. The agriculture and construction sectors, and textile hubs in places like Tirupur, Banaras and Ludhiana, are badly hit, as are day labourers, craftsmen, hawkers, migrants and 80 per cent of workers who earn a living in the shadow economy. The greater the delay in infusing liquidity, the more lasting will be the damage.Although banks are now flush with new deposits, a large part of it comes from the informal sector’s transaction money, which will flow out as soon as withdrawal restrictions ease. It is, at any rate, egregious to recapitalise banks by raiding the cash reserves of the poor, while the informal lenders and microfinance organisations who actually lend to them are crippled by demonetisation. This should not be a magic pill for the Non-Performing Assets (NPA) in banks caused by corporate defaulters. Nor can it be justified as shock therapy for promoting financial inclusion and a cashless economy. Those are worthy goals better pursued with gradualism than paternalism. The government’s immediate priority should be to restore liquidity and save the economy from a deep slump.


Authoritarian quackery

Arjun Jayadev

(Associate Professor, Azim Premji University, Bengaluru)Until November 8, 2016 independent India had by and large avoided financial melodrama. Certainly there have been foreign exchange crises and some credit bubbles that broke nastily, but there has never been the sort of widespread debacle and panic that have been experienced in other developing economies. This makes the demonetisation decree all that more puzzling.  Demonetisations are really unheard of in the absence of a hyperinflation or a situation of war. It is perhaps the most explicit recognition of a failed state of affairs, an acknowledgement that the most basic universal dealings of human beings between each other have broken down and that the society needs a reset. Let us, for a moment, think of what has been shaken to the core. It is not “black money” or illegality. It is not a rearrangement of affairs in favour of cashlessness. It is the belief in the integrity of the monetary system—that legal tender will be widely accepted, that our “pay community” is meaningfully solid and not subject to the whims, however well-intentioned, of a small group of people. It’s important to think about what the rupee note has represented to people. Like very few of our social contrivances, it is universally accepted. The denomination, written in all the major languages, allows citizens of all creeds and backgrounds to make binding commitments to each other. A rural labourer with that note in his pocket can interact, coordinate and cooperate with people who might otherwise have nothing to do with him. It is this very basic trust that is in question. Already, rumours abound that the new Rs 2000 notes will be demonetised soon enough. If demonetisation is to work as an attack on black money, it will only work if it is done repeatedly to any means of settlement that is used for illegal activities, and illegality is of course, not limited to cash transactions. No form of settlement is then safe from the arbitrary fancies of those in power. This is far from either a “surgical strike” or a “dose of strong medicine”. It is quackery. Worse, it is authoritarian quackery that cannot help but do deep damage to the basic institutional understandings that underpin our society.


Will impose cost on economyArun Kumar

(Retired Professor of Economics, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi; and author of  The Black Economy in India, Penguin (India).The withdrawal of high- denomination currency notes from circulation is seen as a move to curb the black economy. Questions are being asked about its effectiveness and its economic costs. The immediate impact has been adverse and large.The current size of the black economy is 62 per cent of the GDP, or about Rs 90 lakh crore, and what may be held in cash would be only a few per cent, say Rs 2 to 3 lakh crore. Reports are that businessmen have found ways of converting their cash into new currency so that hardly any black money hoard may be demobilised. Thus, the expected bonanza to the government may be marginal. Most of those who generate substantial black incomes may be untouched by demonetisation. Further, generation of black incomes in different sectors is untouched by demonetisation and will continue.The heavy cost to the economy is becoming apparent. Households, farmers and businesses are being adversely affected as transactions have become difficult. A large part of the economy does not use plastic money or cheques. A black market has emerged for exchange of currency and there is a premium for gold and foreign currency, which will lead to loss of savings. Hoarding of currency is aggravating shortage of liquidity. Discretionary expenditure has dropped and this may persist, leading to demand shortage and dislocation of commerce and industry. This could aggravate NPA, and sickness in industry and unemployment, resulting in irreversible changes and hardship to the citizens even though most of them are not responsible for generating black incomes. Thus, while demonetisation will hardly impact the black economy, it will impose huge costs on the economy  especially on the marginalised. The way out is to restore liquidity in the markets by allowing the older notes to continue in circulation till enough new notes are printed.


Abandonment of reason

Prabhat Patnaik

(Professor Emeritus, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi)For a government to demonetise overnight 86 percent of the currency, when nearly half the economy runs entirely on the basis of currency transactions and gets crippled thereby, makes no sense. When it transpires that this was done when no new currency had been printed, against which the old could be exchanged, then this move betrays an abandonment of reason that is truly frightening.This impression is not lessened one bit by the arguments advanced for the move. The first states that it attacks “black money”. But since the ratio of currency holdings to the volume of business in the “black economy” is extremely small, the profitability of engaging in “black activities” will be hardly affected by demonetisation, especially since only a fraction of the demonetised currency will be disabled anyway (the rest getting converted into new legal tender through a mushrooming of new “black avenues”). And since the “black economy” would continue, it would suck out the cash it needs, but which has been disabled by demonetisation, from the “white economy”, to the longer-term detriment of the informal sector. The second argument talks of moving to a cashless economy. Even if the need for it is accepted for argument’s sake, sudden demonetisation as a means towards it is like holding a gun to people’s heads to force them towards cashless modes of transacting. It is authoritarian and unacceptable.The third argument concerns counterfeit currency which terrorists apparently have injected into the economy. But getting rid of counterfeit currency does not require sudden demonetisation. Even if the old notes were replaced in a phased manner, as has happened occasionally in the past, counterfeit currency would still have been eliminated.Whether the people accept the hardships induced by demonetisation is immaterial; a government imposing such hardships betrays astounding irrationality.


Neither necessary nor sufficient

M. Govinda Rao

(Former Member,  14th Finance Commission;  & Professor Emeritus , National Institute of Public Finance and Policy, New Delhi)The Prime Minister’s announcement invalidated 86 per cent of the currency with a sleight of hand, which has plunged the economy into a tailspin.  In an economy in which over 96 per cent of the transactions are carried out in cash, such a chaos is inevitable.  While nobody can find fault with the objective of curbing black economy, or ending terror financing or nullifying the counterfeit notes, the important questions are: first, whether this is the appropriate policy choice to justify the pain inflicted on the people and second, does the banking system have the capacity for implementing it to achieve normalcy within a reasonable time?As regards the policy mix, clearly demonetisation of the type undertaken is neither necessary nor sufficient. First, the policy will not impact the incentives for, nor deter, the earning of illegal incomes and evasion of taxes.  The principal sources of the black economy in activities like political funding and election expenses, real-estate transactions, construction, tax evasion and bureaucratic corruption will continue.  Second, the stock of black economy does not get affected much for, only a small portion of black money is held in currency. Much of it is stashed abroad or held in real estate, and gold and foreign currency.  It is obvious that the shock therapy of such a magnitude cannot be implemented by the banking system.  Over 30 per cent of the people employed in India are casual labourers who receive their wages and pay for their purchases in cash, and they have been put to severe hardships.  With trade, tourism and construction activity coming to a standstill and with agricultural sectors requiring but unable to get cash for purchasing seeds and fertilisers at a time when rabi sowing is on, the GDP in the economy will decelerate significantly.  This is a typical case of throwing the baby out while retaining the bathwater!


Avoidable human cost

Sanjay G Reddy

(Associate Professor, The New School of Social Sciences, New York)The government’s decision to scrap existing currency notes which make up a large proportion of those in use in transactions is an ill-thought out action which has little economic justification, and acts as a smoke-screen for the failure of the government to act in more fundamental ways to address people’s justified anger at ill-gotten wealth and ongoing corruption.   However, better alternatives existed to what the Supreme Court has rightly referred to as “carpet bombing” and not a surgical strike, including the gradual replacement of targeted notes.  The action has rightly been referred to as expropriation as it will lead to loss of wealth of many citizens who had trustingly stored their wealth in this form, either permanently or transiently, including the poor, thus also affecting economic activity.  At the same time, those supposedly targeted have very likely avoided serious damage through a variety of evasive techniques.  The question of whether the human cost is acceptable would be hard enough to answer if the move were somehow successful in addressing its supposed aims.  In fact, there is every reason to believe that it will be unsuccessful, which makes the avoidable human cost a tragic consequence of a cavalier or even cynical political calculation, or of poor economic ideas compounded by incompetence.  The loss of trust in the currency and in the ability of the government to manage the economy has, ironically, also dealt a blow to the confidence of the domestic and foreign private investors whom the government is otherwise keen to please. Despite its debacle, the government and its faithful, some pliant economists among them, will likely assert that it has advanced its aims, as it can always claim that things would have been still worse.  In such a case, there is no better recourse than common sense.

An Opportunity to Bring Heart Back to Kashmir

Something that escaped most observers even as queues at ATMs increased and worries about the next purchase of vegetables kept attention focused, is the sudden quieting of the situation in the Kashmir Valley. In ferment since 08 July 2016, when Burhan Wani was killed, stamina just collapsed after the Durbar moved to Jammu for the winter. Perhaps it was realised well in time that demonstrations and stone throwing are supposedly instruments to communicate collective negative emotions and angst. However, when there is no government to paralyse, no tourists to harass and no minorities to intimidate, there is not much point in protesting. That is the phenomenon that always takes place around the end of the year in the Valley. No doubt this year the de-monetisation exercise is contributing to ensure that professional stone throwers cannot earn their bread nor the smack, ganja or other drugs because there is not cash around with the organisers.
There is an opportunity beckoning here that needs to be grabbed. The emerging window is one in which the missing outreach can be restored. There has been much public debate through the summer such that awareness levels on the real problem of J&K have risen considerably. Everyone blames Pakistan for creating the mayhem on the streets and the strife. But equally after many years there is a majority consensus that the governance and outreach deficits are as much to blame. It is long since any commentaries have appeared blaming Article 370, the failure of ensuring conditions for safe return of the Pandits or even the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA). Jammu has approached the problem with sincere maturity through the last many months, without raising a voice of protest despite that there has been reason to feel slighted. There cannot be a better time than now to demonstrate how the Establishment can empathise with the plight of those in the Valley who want to be delivered from the control of the young vigilantes and stop becoming a mirror image of Pakistan with radical faith dictating their lives. Scratch and scratch hard, because under the surface, there is a public awaiting a kind word and a change of heart.
The Army has been the quickest to realise it, as usual, sensing an opportunity. Throughout the summer and the autumn, it doggedly continued its counter-terrorism campaign without getting involved with too many stone throwers and demonstrators. As Headquarters Northern Command made available two brigades to 15 Corps, the challenge was in understanding, evolving, communicating and executing the concept of operations. The demonstration of its concept is best exemplified not by its operations on the LoC, which have been professional no doubt and not by the quick control it established over the so called fedayeens who were threatening to go out of control at a point in time. Instead, it is demonstrated by the runaway success of the most innocuous of all things – a program called ‘School Chalo’ (Let us go to School), once again confirming the immense role of military soft power.
Readers would be aware that schools in the Valley have been shut for the last four months. An atrocious program of burning of schools has been undertaken by unknown elements that are anti-national in character. The Separatists perceive that a way of preventing the return of normalcy is to ensure schools remain closed. The young vigilantes in the rural areas, the ones controlling the stone throwing and holding their parents and elders to ransom, also have no wish to return to school.
However, a vigorous social media campaign run by the Army in South Kashmir to bring home the message of its support to elders and parents, resonated splendidly in the hearts of the weary population. Schools reopened, the examinations drew 98 per cent attendance and the enthusiasm as per ground reports, was palpable.
This is one of the major successes of the Army employing a combination of ground campaign and social media outreach. It gives an indicator that more than anything else, the Army has simply to lead the way in outreach, social engagement and restoration of confidence. The State Government must take ownership of this success; it is not the Army’s success alone because through and through it would have been discussed at the frequent Unified Command meetings and the Chief Minister would have been well aware of it, making it her success.
What does this signify? For those observing the virtual great game in the Valley, it should send home the lesson that a weary population needs to be handled with a heart and requires its hearts to be touched. This is a hearts game waiting to be played all over again. Restoration of self-esteem is the need as much as weeding out of rabble rousers. A degree of reverse vigilantism on the mosques; facilitation of the movement and meeting of political representatives with their constituencies; energetic return of governance demonstrated by good administrative performance against the vagaries of the expected severe winter; and domination of the social media space by positive messaging, will communicate the State Government’s will and capability. The Army must assist in this energetically and whole heartedly. Just remember, it is all about ‘whole of government approach’ which will turn the tide and the Army must guide the government through with all its experience and knowledge of conflict.
The concept of Moral Dominance of the narrative remains the job of the Army, just as I strongly advocated in September 2016 when two infantry brigades were moving into deployment in South Kashmir. That is the way forward. Subsequently, build on it next summer. India will yet mainstream the Kashmiri populace – the Awam.
Lt Gen (Retd) Syed Ata Hasnain
Member, Governing Council, IPCS, & former GOC, 15 Corps, Srinagar

Navy refuses to deploy ‘overweight’ Tejas on aircraft carriers

New Delhi, December 2The Indian Navy has ruled out deploying indigenously built light combat aircraft Tejas on its aircraft carriers because it was “overweight” and did not meet their requirements.Admiral Sunil Lanba, Chief of Naval Staff, said the navy is looking at procuring another aircraft.”As far as the carrier-based aircraft is concerned, we need it in a time line of the induction of the aircraft carrier. We have the MiG 29K, which operates from Vikramaditya and will operate from (indigenous aircraft carrier) IAC Vikrant. We were also hoping to operate the LCA (Light Combat Aircraft-Tejas) from these two aircraft carriers.” Lanba said. “Unfortunately, the LCA is not being able to meet the carrier’s required capability. That is why we need an alternative aircraft to operate from these two aircraft carriers.”He said that the navy was currently identifying an aircraft that would meet its requirements and was likely to take 5-6 more years.”If you look around the world, there are not too many options available and we need this carrier capable aircraft sooner than later. So, I am looking at next five-six years,” he said.LCA-Tejas is an indigenously built fighter aircraft and has been inducted into the Indian Air Force.Lanba said the navy is still encouraging India’s Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) to develop the Naval LCA.The naval chief said that it is also looking at UAVs that can operate from ships and autonomous sub-surface vehicles for surveillance. — PTI


US Congress seeks major defence partner recognition for India

US Congress seeks major defence partner recognition for India
The Indo-US ties of late have strengthened considerably

Washington, December 1

A powerful US Congressional conference committee has asked the Defence Secretary and the Secretary of State to take steps necessary to recognise India as America’s major defence partner in a bid to strengthen bilateral security cooperation.The provision mentioned in the voluminous Congressional conference report, running into more than 3,000 pages, on USD 618 billion National Defence Authorisation Bill (NDAA), in another significant development asks the Defence Secretary and the Secretary of State to conduct an assessment of the extent to which India possesses capabilities to support and carry out military operations of mutual interest of the two countries.This, including an assessment of the defence export control regulations and policies, needed appropriate modification in recognition of India’s capabilities and its status as a major defence partner, said the conference report which was unveiled by the House and Senate Armed Services Committee on Wednesday.It now needs to be formally passed by the two chambers of the Congress–the House of Representatives and Senate–before US President Barack Obama can sign it into law.Majority of the decisions of the Section 1292 of NDAA called ‘Enhancing defence and security cooperation with India’ would, however, have to be taken by the incoming Donald Trump Administration which would take charge on January 20.The language arrived in the conference report and NDAA has been agreed upon by both the Republican and Democratic Party.NDAA 2017 authorises funding for the Department of Defence and the national security programmes of the Department of Energy.Senator John McCain said, it “enhances security cooperation between the United States and India”.McCain is Chairman of the powerful Senate Foreign Relations Committee.However, NDAA 2017 is still a step below what friends of India have been working for in the Congress for the past few years–bringing the defence relationship on par with top NATO allies and Israel.“The President shall ensure that the assessment” is used, consistent with US conventional arms transfer policy, to inform the review by the US of requests to export defence articles, defence services, or related technology to India under the Arms Export Control Act and to inform any regulatory and policy adjustments that may be appropriate, it said.

(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)

NDAA 2017 also urged the Administration to designate an individual within the executive branch who has experience in defence acquisition and technology–to reinforce and ensure, through inter-agency policy coordination, the success of the Framework for the US-India Defence Relationship and to help resolve remaining issues impeding Indo-US defence trade, security cooperation and co-production and co-development opportunities. PTI


Havaldar Sukhraj Singh’s final journey home

Havaldar Sukhraj Singh's final journey home
Havaldar Sukhraj Singh

Ravi Dhaliwal

Tribune News Service

Batala, November 30

Tuesday is a day that will be etched deeply in the minds of Havaldar Sukhraj Singh’s family forever. The 34-year-old was to come home to his family and his 7-year-old daughter, to whom he had promised a vacation. His senior officers sanctioned his leave from Tuesday. He was to board a train from Jammu to Batala at 1 pm.His family was awaiting a phone call at 11 pm. What they got instead was a phone call that changed their lives completely: a senior officer of Singh’s regiment called to say Havaldar Singh was one of the seven people killed in a militant attack on an army base in Nargota on Tuesday.Singh was part of the Sikh regiment he had joined in 2004 and was posted at Nagrota six months ago.His body will be flown to Tibri Cantonment on Thursday morning and later driven home.Gurdaspur Deputy Commissioner Pardeep Sabharwal, who visited the family earlier in the day, said his family would receive Rs 5 lakh ex-gratia. “He will also be given a plot of land and his wife will be given a job commensurate with her qualifications. Sukhraj is a martyr and a martyr cannot be dishonoured,” Kunwar Ravinder Singh Vicky, general secretary of the Shaheed Sainik Parivar Suraksha Parishad, said.      AAP candidate Gurvinder Singh Shampura from the neighbouring Vidhan Sabha seat of Fatehgarh Churian and SAD candidate from Batala, LS Lodhinangal, also visited the family.

Havildar was to visit home the day he died

Ravi Dhaliwal

Tribune News Service

Batala, November 30

Havildar Sukhraj Singh (32), who was killed in a fidayeen attack at Nagrota in Jammu and Kashmir yesterday, was to visit his family at Maan Nagar here on the day of the attack. He had promised his daughter Subpreet Kaur (7) that he would take her on a vacation this time.But destiny had other plans. Sukhraj was to board a train from Jammu to Batala at 1pm yesterday. But at 5am, militants attacked his base. He was among seven soldiers, including two officers, to be killed.His seniors had sanctioned his leave on Monday, following which he had called up his family about his impending arrival.Around 11am yesterday, the family was expecting a call from Sukhraj. Instead, an officer of his regiment called. “We regret to inform you that Sukhraj has been killed in a militant attack,” he told the family in a matter-of-fact way.The last rites will be performed tomorrow.Sukhraj had joined the Sikh regiment in 2004; he was posted in Nagrota about six months ago.Gurdaspur Deputy Commissioner (DC) Pardeep Sabharwal, AAP’ Fatehgarh Churian candidate Gurvinder Singh Shampura and SAD candidate from Batala LS Lodhinangal visited the family today.The DC said Sukhraj’s family would be given Rs 5 lakh ex gratia.“I will ensure that his family gets a plot and his wife, a job commensurate with her qualifications. Sukhraj is a martyr and a martyr cannot be dishonoured,” said Kunwar Ravinder Singh Vicky, general secretary, Shaheed Sainik Parivar Surakshna Parishad.


Don’t take Pak’s patience as weakness: Gen Sharif

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s outgoing army chief Gen Raheel Sharif on Tuesday warned India not to mistake his country’s restraint over tensions in Kashmir for weakness as he handed over power to his successor, Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa.

Lasting peace in South Asia could not be achieved without resolving the Kashmir issue, Sharif said while addressing a change of command ceremony at a stadium near the army headquarters in Rawalpindi.

In a blunt message, Sharif, who once referred to Kashmir as an “unfinished agenda of Partition”, said: “Unfortunately, in recent months, increasing state terrorism in (Kashmir) and India’s aggressive stance have endangered regional peace.

“I want to make it clear to India that mistaking our policy of patience for weakness would be dangerous for it.”

Sharif added, “This is the reality, that in South Asia, lasting peace and progress is impossible without the solution of the Kashmir issue. For that, international community’s special attention is necessary.”.

Tensions between the two countries erupted following a terror attack on Pathankot airbase in January that was blamed on the Pakistan-based Jaish-e-Mohammed.


Efforts on to bring soldier back from Pak custody: MoS Defence

Pune, November 29

Union Minister Subhash Bhamre on Tuesday said the government is making all efforts for the safe return of 22-year-old soldier Chandu Chavan, who is in Pakistan’s custody after inadvertently crossing the LoC.“We are in contact with the neighbouring country (Pakistan) through DGMO and diplomatic channels and one good thing is that Pakistan has acknowledged that Chavan is in their custody. Today or tomorrow, they will have to return Chavan to us,” the MoS for Defence told reporters on the sidelines of the passing-out parade (POP) of the 131st course of the National Defence Academy (NDA) held here.He assured that as soon as the situation (at border) gets back to normal, Chavan will be brought back.”I am in touch with the family of Chavan as he is from my constituency,” said the MP from Dhule in Maharashtra.On September 30 after the surgical strikes, Chavan from 37 Rashtriya Rifles had inadvertently crossed over to the other side of the LoC following which Pakistan had been informed by the DGMO (Director General of Military Operations) on the hotline. He has been in Pakistan’s custody since then.Soon after the news broke, Chavan’s aged grandmother Lila Chindha Patil had died of shock.To another query, the minister said OROP was pending for 40 years. However, since Modiji (PM Narendra Modi) assumed office, he gave priority to OROP.”There are a section of people who are spreading lies about it (OROP). However, 90 to 95 per cent ex-servicemen are happy. Yes, there are some anomalies. But efforts are on to get rid of them as the government is studying the report submitted by one-member committee,” he said.The Centre had appointed a committee under the Chairmanship of retired Chief Justice of Patna High Court L Narasimha Reddy to look into the anomalies.He said the government thrust is on indigenisation of products in the defence sector. “(under Modi government) Indigenisation has increased and India is one step towards self reliance,” Bhamre added.Talking about the terrorist attack on an army camp at Nagrota near Jammu, he said, “We expect peace from our neighbouring country. But our forces are alert and we are proud of them. We are ready for any kind of challenge, be it military or any other kind of aggression.” — PTI


Bajwa is new Pak army chief

Bajwa is new Pak army chief
Lt Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa

Islamabad, November 26

Lt Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa, who has extensive experience in handling Pakistan-occupied Kashmir, was today appointed Pakistan’s new army chief to succeed Gen Raheel Sharif. Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif appointed Bajwa as the chief of army staff (COAS) by elevating him to the rank of a four-star general, officials said.Bajwa will take charge of the world’s sixth-largest army by troop numbers in a formal handover on Tuesday, when General Sharif retires. General Sharif in January had declared he would not seek extension. There was speculation that the PML-N government would give him extension at the eleventh hour, citing reasons that he was needed by the country to lead war on terror. The post of army chief is the most powerful in Pakistan.Defence minister Khawaja Asif confirmed that Bajwa had been appointed as COAS and Zubair Hayat as chairman, joint chief of staff committee (CJCSC). Bajwa, currently serving as Inspector General of the Training and Evaluation, had commanded 10 Corps, responsible for the area along the Line of Control (LoC).As a major general, he led the Force Command Northern Areas. He also served in the 10 Corps as lieutenant colonel. He also served with a UN mission in Congo as a brigade commander alongside former Indian Army chief General Bikram Singh, who was also there as a division commander. Previously, he remained the commandant of the Infantry School in Quetta. The new army chief has wide experience of LoC affairs due to his extensive involvement with PoK and northern areas, reports said here. His military colleagues say he is not attention-seeking and remains well-connected with his troops. Lt Gen Bajwa is from infantry’s Baloch Regiment, which besides him has produced three army chiefs — Gen Yahya Khan, Gen Aslam Beg and Gen Ashfaq Pervez Kayani. — PTI

Handled LoC affairs

  • Because of his involvement with PoK and northern areas, Lt Gen Bajwa has wide experience in handling LoC affairs
  • He had commanded 10 Corps, responsible for the area along the LoC, and led the Force Command Northern Areas

About Bajwa clan, here and in Pak

Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, November 26

The appointment of Lt Gen Qamar Javed Bajwa as the next Pakistan army chief to replace Gen Raheel Sharif has kicked up social media traffic, with speculation in some quarters that his family may have old ties with the Sikh Bajwa families in India.While many Indians bearing the Bajwa surname and those who are members of “Bajwa” groups on the social media have been receiving congratulatory messages, some of them have clarified that people bearing the Bajwa surname on both sides of the border originally come from the same clan, from the Sialkot-Narowal belt. All were originally Hindus before they conversion to Sikhism or Islam began a few hundred years ago. Some Pakistani Bajwa families also claim that they converted from Sikhism. In fact, majority of the Sikh Bajwa families migrated to India after Partition and some of them who chose to stay back in Pakistan are said to have converted to Islam later. There are several surnames common to Sikhs and Muslims.Though little is publicly known about the ancestry of Gen Bajwa, he is said to be a Jat belonging to the Punjabi Muslim stock. This also has a coincidence with the Indian Army Chief, Gen DS Suhag, who also happens to be a Jat.Though there may no longer be any direct blood relationship between the present generations of Sikh Bajwas and Muslim Bajwas, social interaction between the two continues.