Sanjha Morcha

What’s New

Click the heading to open detailed news

Current Events :

web counter

Print Media Reproduced Defence Related News

‘Not enough fighter jets is akin to playing cricket with just 7 players’: Air Chief Marshal B S Dhanoa flags concern

The IAF’s authorised strength of 42 fighter squadrons “is the minimum strength necessary to dominate a two-front conflict”, Air Chief Marshal Dhanoa said.

indian air force, air chief bs dhanoa, fighter jets, fighter squadrons, iaf fighter sqaudrons,

The IAF’s authorised strength of 42 fighter squadrons “is the minimum strength necessary to dominate a two-front conflict”, Air Chief Marshal Dhanoa said.

Highlighting the shortfall in the number of fighter squadrons in the IAF as a challenge to “dominat[ing] a two-front conflict”, Air Chief Marshal B S Dhanoa has said “it is akin to a cricket team playing with seven players instead of 11”. The Chief of the Indian Air Force also said that while the IAF is ready for the use of air power against Pakistan in response to a terrorist attack, it is an option that has to be exercised by the government.

In a candid and wide-ranging interview to The Indian Express, the Air Chief asserted that the IAF has the capability, and is in a position to strike against the Maoists, as and when it is cleared to do so by the government — but that he does not envisage any air attacks in India’s own territory.

The IAF’s authorised strength of 42 fighter squadrons “is the minimum strength necessary to dominate a two-front conflict”, Air Chief Marshal Dhanoa said. The IAF currently has 32 fighter squadrons, and is tasked with tackling a two-front collusive threat from China and Pakistan.

The “reduced numbers place a severe handicap akin to a cricket team playing with 7 players instead of 11,” Air Chief Marshal Dhanoa said. “Though we are operating under challenging conditions, we have devised mitigating strategies,” he added.

“IAF’s plans of prosecuting a two-front scenario with available resources are based on a judicious force employment philosophy. Once the strengths and capabilities are augmented, we would be in a better position to overcome our combat differential and be in a position to dominate the air space,” he said.

Asked whether the IAF had given options to the government about some kind of an “aerial surgical strike” inside Pakistan occupied Kashmir (PoK), the Air Chief said: “The use of air power in response to heinous acts or terrorist attacks is an option that is to be taken by the government. IAF is prepared for any eventuality.”

The situation on the Line of Control (LoC) has been tense over the past several weeks, particularly after two Indian soldiers were killed and beheaded last month by a Pakistan Army Border Action Team. Last year, special forces of the Army had launched surgical strikes in PoK after 19 soldiers were killed in a terror attack at Uri. The IAF was not used in that operation.

On the possible use of air power against the Maoists, Air Chief Marshal Dhanoa said: “Our roles are restricted to providing intelligence and surveillance to the forces on ground. We use the RPAs [remotely piloted aircraft] extensively in these operations for intelligence collection, as well as helicopters, mainly for speedy movement of forces between area of operations, and casualty evacuation. As far as terrorist threats are concerned, we do not envisage carrying out air attacks on our territory, to prevent any sliver of possibility for collateral damage. But we have the capability, and are in a position to strike as and when we are cleared to do so by the government.”

The IAF chief also stated his objections to the proposal to establish Integrated Theatre Commands of the Army, Navy and the IAF: “You could argue that this concept is worth attempting if we had older types of air assets whose reach was limited, for which they would have to be placed in specific locations and concentrate their efforts to achieve the military objectives in a sector.

“But with our modern acquisitions, it is possible now to exploit the agility and reach of our platforms to near simultaneously affect the battles on the two fronts, and meet the objects of war. Air power needs space for manoeuvre to exploit its varied characteristics of surprise, shock and speed. If restricted to one sector, the potential of this arm of the military will not be optimally exploited and thus, the Air Force desires to have independence for execution so that the purpose of conflict is best served.”

The Air Chief, however, came out in support of a Permanent Chairman, Chiefs of Staff Committee, who “would thus be the fourth four-star officer who would also be responsible for the various Tri-Service Commands. The Service Chiefs however, will continue to exercise operational control and training over their respective Services and have direct access to RM [Raksha Mantri, or Defence Minister].”

The issue, he said, is still under consideration of the political leadership.


Valley to be normal soon: Army Chief

Valley to be normal soon: Army Chief
Army Chief General Bipin Rawat presents wings to a flying officer during the Combined Graduation Parade held at the Air Force Academy in Hyderabad on Saturday. PTI

Tribune News Service

Hyderabad, june 17

Commending the security forces for doing a good job under difficult circumstances, Army Chief General Bipin Rawat today asserted that the situation in the strife-torn Jammu and Kashmir would be brought under control soon.“Some parts of south Kashmir are troublesome. The necessary action is being taken to ensure that the situation there is soon brought under control. I don’t think there should be any cause for concern in any of you,” he told reporters after reviewing the Combined Graduation Parade at the Air Force Academy in Dundigal near here. He said “misinformation and disinformation” was “possibly compelling” youngsters to take up arms in the Valley.“I am quite confident that they (youth) will soon understand that what they are doing is not good for their own state. All that armed forces and security forces want is peace and tranquility in the Valley,” General Rawat said.

Kashmir tense, militants give gun salute to killed Lashkar man

SRINAGAR: Thousands of people, including militants, participated on Saturday in the funeral of three alleged Lashkar-eTaiba men killed by security forces a day earlier when Kashmir saw a wave of bloodshed.

APFamily members of Jammu and Kashmir cop Tasveer Ahmad mourn as his body arrives for funeral at Surasyar village near Srinagar on Saturday.Much of Kashmir was tense on Saturday, prompting chief minister Mehbooba Mufti to make a renewed call for peace.

Friday’s deaths included top Lashkar commander Junaid Mattoo, who was seen as the third most prominent face of the insurgency after Burhan Wani and Sabzar Bhat. Militants at his funeral in Kashmir’s Kulgam district gave a gun salute, underscoring the challenge for security forces that often face hostility from civilians while pursuing militants.

Thousands of the attendees jostled to touch Mattoo’s body. Similar scenes played out during the funeral of the other two LeT militants, Nasir Wani and Adil Mir. Mattoo, like Wani and Bhat, enjoyed support from sections in the Valley.

Wani was killed in July last year — a death that triggered one of the worst phases of violence for the region and left at least 100 civilians dead — and Bhat was killed late last month.

Union defence minister Arun Jaitley hit out at the insurgents on Saturday, calling the killing of five policemen on Friday an “act of cowardice”.

Mattoo’s outfit, the LeT, claimed the attack as a revenge for his death. The Jammu and Kashmir director general of police (DGP) promised on Saturday to catch the suspects “very soon”. Two civilians, including a teenager, were also killed on Friday when forces opened fire on people pelting stones at them in an apparent attempt to intervene in the operation against Mattoo and the two LeT rebels.

The opposition National Conference and the Congress protested outside the assembly against ‘innocent killings’.

Mehbooba Mufti said instances of 12 year-old boys going to encounter sites with stones in their hands or the killings of policemen were a repercussion of democracy being denied in the state.

“Guns or army can’t solve any issues. Only dialogue can,” she said in the assembly. AWANTIPORA:In a chronicle of his death foretold, Feroz Ahmed Dar wrote, “Just imagine…yourself in your grave. Down there in that dark hole…Alone.”

The 32-year-old Jammu and Kashmir police officer was buried on Friday night in the family’s ancestral graveyard in Dogripora village in Pulwama district, with many from the village and his department bidding him a tearful farewell.

Dar and five other policemen were killed on Friday when suspected Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) militants ambushed a police party in Anantnag’s Achabal area. The militants also tried to disfigure the faces of the policemen before walking away with their weapons.

As his family and friends prepared for the last journey, Dar’s words written on January 18, 2013, came back to haunt. “Did you ever stop for a while and asked yourself, what is going to happen to me the first night in my grave? Think about the moment your body is being washed and prepared to your grave.

“Think about the day people will be carrying you to your grave And your families crying …think about the moment you are put in your grave,” he had written on his Facebook wall.


37 commissioned as lieutenants at Western Command’s nursing school

AS MANY AS 753 NURSING OFFICERS HAVE GRADUATED FROM WESTERN COMMAND SCHOOL OF NURSING

Thirty seven probationer nurses from 48th batch of the School of Nursing, Western Command, were commissioned as lieutenants at a ceremony held at Western Command Hospital, Chandimandir, on Wednesday.

HT PHOTOSNurses celebrating the culmination of their training and the commissioning ceremony at the Western Command in Chandimandir on Wednesday; (right) Major General Manomay Ganguly felicitating Lt Jyoti Prusty with the rolling trophy.

Major general (medical), Manomoy Ganguly, of Western Command headquarters and major general Mukti Sharma, awarded the rank of lieutenant to the newly commissioned military nurses.

General Ganguly later gave the medals and trophies to distinguish performers.

Brigadier SV Saraswati, principal matron of Western Command Hospital, administered oath to the newly-commissioned nursing officers.

Lieutenant Chinchu Eldhose won the gold medal for securing the first position in academics. Lieutenant Binsa K Sasi won the silver medal for standing second in the batch.

Lieutenant Malini Lama was adjudged the best all-round cadet and lieutenant Jyoti Prusty was awarded the best bedside nurse rolling trophy.

Till date, as many as 753 nursing officers have passed out from the Western Command School of Nursing.

While addressing the newlycommissioned nursing officers, chief guest General Ganguly said, “Military nursing is a noble and highly challenging profession where a nurse needs to work hard even in difficult terrain to provide a compassionate and comprehensive care to the soldiers and their families.”

He called upon the young officers to keep abreast with the latest trends in the health care delivery system to ensure optimum care and well being of the patients.

Major General Mukti Sharma, in her address emphasised upon the importance of the health profession which requires constant and selfless devotion and preparedness to meet requirements of the armed forces.

Principal, School of Nursing, colonel R Saraswathi, presented the school report and deputy principal Lieutenant Colonel RJeyanthi gave the vote of thanks.


Peace in post-Khaplang North-East by Lt Gen KJ Singh (retd)

With the passing away of Shangwang Shangyung Khaplang, in Nagaland the baton now passes on to a new generation of rebel leaders. For the first time, the control of the NSCN-K is with an indigenous Konyak. Elders like TH Muivah, the last of the old tribe, can help to leave a legacy of reconciliation for future generations.

SS Khaplang: Nobody’s friend?

H Muviah: Now, a legacy of truce?

Trecent demise of SS Khaplang, referred to as “Baba,” combined with the passing away of Issac Chisi Swu in June 2016 and the frail health of 83-year-old Thuingleng Muivah sets the stage for the advent of a new generation of rebel leaders. It is these leaders that hold the key to the future of the “Act-East policy”. Our traditions and the Stockholm syndrome (a condition that causes hostages to develop a psychological alliance with their captors as a survival strategy during captivity) have sprouted eulogies about Baba, a Hemi Naga and the senior-most member of the trio. Sadly, driven by vote-bank politics, the Chief Minister of Nagaland has even released an official obituary. On balance, this foe-turned-friend who almost got Issac and Muivah eliminated in 1988, was nobody’s friend. He showed his viciousness with deadly ambush on unsuspecting Dogras in Chandel in June 15, resulting in the martyring of 18 bravehearts. His death opens new possibilities as the control of the he National Socialist Council of Nagaland-Khaplang (NSCN-K), for the first time is with an indigenous Konyak, Khango Konyak. Naga insurgency, that began in the early 1950s, was initiated by the first-generation leaders, Phizo, Mowu Angami and Kaito Sema with the Naga National Council (NNC), and the Naga Federal Government (NFG) as the rallying force. The seeds of proxy war were sowed as early as 1950s with East Bengal (Bangladesh) as the springboard. Phizo’s foiled bid to escape to East Pakistan in 1952, followed by successful forays by Mowu and Kaito, resulted in Phizo finally making it in December 1958. Later, Phizo visited Karachi in 1962 and Pakistan trained nearly 2,500 Naga rebels in the Chittagong Hills between 1962 and 1968. The mischief by the ISI continued even after the liberation of Bangladesh with ISPR as their partner and relationship with new clients like the United Liberation Front of Asom (ULFA).  Mercifully, Sheikh Hasina put an end to this aberration, which was making Bangladesh a sanctuary for all centrifugal forces. The current generation of “armchair warriors, locked up in analysing the ongoing proxy war in Jammu and Kashmir, will be well advised not to lose sight of this not-too-distant history and dangers of the Dragon using it again as a leverage to vitiate the situation in the North- East.There is an uneasy peace with the National Socialist Council of Nagaland-Isak Muivah (NSCN-IM) since the ceasefire agreement in 1999. This accord has, unfortunately, partially legitimised the Naga quest for sovereignty as ceasefire is generally signed between two sovereign nations. Ceasefire with the smaller but equally deadly counterpart, NSCN-K, inked in 2001 lasted till end March 16. Abrogation of the ceasefire resulted in Khaplang’s last fling at fiefdom building, manifesting in the formation of United National Liberation Front-West South-East Asia (UNLF-WSEA), a conglomeration of NSCN-K, Paresh Barua faction of ULFA, Manipuri Meitei groups with allegiance to another combination called CorCom. There is an urgent need to redouble our efforts, along with Myanmar, to regain the control of Taga and adjoining liberated sanctuaries in Kachin forests, serving as training camps for UNLF-WSEA. The Naga society, led by Ho-Hos (tribal bodies), particularly the Konyak Union and the Church, stare at a decisive turning point wherein they could bring all marginal groups (including NSCN-K) together for reconciliation and talks. Muivah, the only link to the old generation, should seize the moment to leave a legacy of being a problem solver, something that Issac missed out on. The third and new generation of Naga leadership, though dominated by Manipuri Tangkhuls, needs to be persuaded to display pragmatism on contentious issues, which despite the sanctity of the Naga Framework agreement of 2014, have been leaked out probably to satisfy their local constituency. These are: unification of all Naga territories, shared sovereignty and joint defence.This is the most opportune period to resolve these issues as the ruling party is in the saddle in relevant states and a thaw between the Nagas and the Meities seems to be on cards, with the lifting of the blockade and the recent visit of the Chief Minister of Nagaland to Manipur. Shared sovereignty within bounds of Article 371, applicable to tribal areas, can be refined with additional autonomy. However, all such measures have to be carefully worded with constitutional safeguards and time stipulation. Joint defence can be worked out with the additional Nagaland Armed Police (Indian Reserve Batallion) battalions and enhanced recruitment in Assam Rifles. Once again, the previous experience of two Naga BSF battalions, comprising surrendered militants, hopefully, will not be lost sight of by policy makers. Even Nagalim, a compulsion with IM due to its almost Orwellian over-reliance on Tangkhuls, can be resolved by setting up a quasi-legal tribal body with a mandate on specified tribal-related subjects and jurisdiction extending to Naga areas in the adjoining states. Our quest to match the Chinese One belt one road policy (OBOR) can gain traction only through the actualisation of the “Act-East policy”, with focus on connectivity to South-east Asia. They say, when you cross Brahmaputra, life is governed by lahe, lahe (slow and slow) but even in the North-East, the new generation needs to shift gear and not deny themselves an opportunity that beckons. The writer is currently Maharaja Ranjit Singh Chair at Panjab  University


Late army officer’s family denied life insurance claim

 

 

 

ROHTAK: The Rohtak-based family of Lt Nitish Kakkar, who died in a road mishap in Bathinda two years ago, is still struggling to cope up with the loss of their only son but the rejection of the insurance claim over his death has now further upset the bereaved family.

HT PHOTOLt Nitish Kakkar with his parents in 2015.

CLAIM REJECTED BY INSURANCE COMPANY, SAYING IT RECEIVED RELEVANT DOCUMENTS ONE DAY LATE

Lt Kakkar, 26, who got commissioned into the 45 CAV Armoured Corps of the Indian Army in 2015, was killed on May 26 in the same year in an accident in Bathinda Cantonment area— the place of his posting.

However, the life insurance claim pertaining to the late army officer has been rejected on the ground that his documents were received by the company one day late.

“At first, Reliance General Insurance declined to process our claim saying we did not intimate them about our son’s death within 90 days. But when I showed them the receipt of their acceptance of our intimation, they changed their stance and said the payment was declined because the requisite documents had reached their office on the 181st day of Nitish’s death, and not within the stipulated period of 180 days,” Nitish’s father Jitender Arya said, adding that he had sent the documents in time.

The family said their repeated requests to the army to intervene in helping them get insurance claim elicited no response. The competent authority also denied special family pension and ex-gratia lump-sum compensation to the bereaved family, despite recommendations from the senior army officers.

“The authorities concerned have not told us why the family pension and ex gratia were rejected even when it was recommended by the top army officers officers ,” Arya said.

Meanwhile, the family said, the police are yet to reach a logical conclusion about the death of their son.

“All they know is that his body was found by the side of his bike on the highway. They have not been able to find out what happened and which vehicle (s) was involved in the accident,” he added. .

 

 

clip

clip

 


Army reaches out to Valley stone-throwers

Srinagar, June 11

The Army is zeroing in on young stone-throwers in Kashmir — not to lock them up but to take them around India and give wings to their dreams.A group of 20 boys from restive south Kashmir will be taken on an educational tour to showcase India and its development, a senior Army officer said.The idea struck Major General BS Raju, General Officer Commanding of the Victor Force, the Army’s anti-insurgency grid responsible for much of south Kashmir, when he interacted with young boys caught throwing stones at security forces during counter-insurgency operations.“One can easily make out that they indulge in stone-throwing because that is what they have seen while growing up. They are prisoners of the images that they see around them since their birth,” Major General Raju said, adding quite a few did not even know why they were throwing stones.“It was surprising to find that many of them threw stones just out fun,” he said.The Army officer, who is a father of a son and a daughter, decided to go by the rule book of a parent and started interacting with the stone-throwers informally — to discover that they, too, had dreams.Recalling the late President APJ Abdul Kalam’s quote — “Dream, dream, dream! Conduct these dreams into thought, and then transform them into action” — the seniormost officer of the Army for south Kashmir soon started counselling the young students on careers.“When one talks to them, one finds they too have dreams and, because of unforeseen circumstances, these dreams have no wings. My only attempt is to give wings to their dreams and that is why I thought 20 such children be taken around India under the Army’s Sadhbhavna scheme,” he said.The Army, with the help of the local police, has been identifying the youth who will be taken to Delhi, where they will meet people in the government, to Mumbai, the financial capital of the country, Jaipur and other places of historical importance.“Kalam seemed to be a much-respected figure with these children and I narrated his statement about India’s diversity to them. It was heartening to find these boys listening with rapt attention and raising some valid questions,” he said.The attempt, he said, was to shape their lives. “If we can contribute the bare minimum, it will definitely be an achievement,” he said.The Army believes the children, after returning from their multi-city tour, will narrate their experiences to other young Kashmiris, encouraging them to join the next group.“For that they don’t have to pick up stones,” the officer quipped. “All they need to do is approach their own Army men and the needful will be done.” — PTI


Women troops will deal with female protesters: Army chief

Rawat says social media campaign in Kashmir is misleading youth

DEHRADUN: Indian army chief General Bipin Rawat suggested on Saturday that the force could deploy its first women combatants for operations in regions such as Kashmir, where soldiers are facing pushback from stonepelting female protesters.

Rawat’s comments came days after he said the army will open combat roles to women, and the process will begin with them initially recruited in the military police.

“Sometimes we have to face women in the front during counter-insurgencies. They could be tackled easily if we have enough strength of women officers and sizable other rank and file cadre,” Rawat said at the passing-out parade of the latest batch of soldiers at the Indian Military Academy (IMA). Women are currently recruited into selective areas of the army such as medical, legal, educational and engineering wings. His statement came in reply to a question from reporters on how the army planned to tackle rising incidents of stone pelting by women in Kashmir.

The General said a social media campaign in Kashmir was misleading youth and spreading hate against security forces.

Kashmir has been on the boil since last July when Hizbul Mujahideen militant Burhan Wani was killed by security forces. In the months since, more than a 100 civilians have died in clashes with the army and police during counter-insurgency operations.

Rawat also played down the issue of Chinese incursions into Indian territory, saying they were matter of “perceptions” by the two countries.

“A disinformation campaign against India and Indian security forces is being run in valley among every section of the society in general and youth in particular via social media but it will not be allowed to succeed” he said. On China, he stressed on the need to improve relations with the Communist giant. “Counter intrusions take place from both the sides of LAC. We also fly our helicopters on the space that may be considered intrusion by the other side,” Rawat said.

He was referring to the recent incident of a suspected Chinese helicopter violating Indian airspace by hovering over Uttarakhand’s Chamoli area along the border. He denied that these cross overs were attempts by Beijing to intrude into Indian Territory.

Incidents of Chinese troops crossing over to the Indian side of the border often spark fear in the bordering areas and at times even lead to standoffs between the two countries.

Sources said that such violation of the Indian airspace in Chamoli and other areas of the state from the Chinese side have occurred in the past as well.

In July 2016, some members of the People’s Liberation Army of China entered into Indian Territory in the state’s Chamoli area, triggering a nationwide outrage. The intruders even shooed away Chamoli district administration officials who had gone to investigate the matter.


38 militants killed, 22 infiltration bids foiled along LoC in 2017: Army

38 militants killed, 22 infiltration bids foiled along LoC in 2017: Army
A total of 59 Army personnel have been killed in counter-terror operations in the state since 2016. Tribune file photo

Jammu, June 8

Thirty-eight armed militants have been killed as the Army foiled a total of 22 infiltration bids along the Line of Control (LoC) in Jammu and Kashmir this year.

(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)

According to the Army, infiltration attempts have been foiled at Gurez, Machhil, Naugam and Uri sectors in the last 48 hours, in which seven armed intruders have been eliminated.

“In the current year, 22 infiltration attempts have been foiled and 34 armed intruders eliminated on the LoC,” a senior Army officer said today.

“The relentless operations by the security forces have defeated the desperate attempts by Pakistan and its agents to spread terror in Jammu and Kashmir during the holy month of Ramzan,” he said.

As compared to this, 28 infiltration attempts took place in 2015 and 88 such attempts in 2016.

Minister of State for Defence, Subhash Bhamre had said in the Parliament that 116 cross-border infiltration attempts were made in the Valley in 2015 and 2016, including 88 last year.

A total of 59 Army personnel have been killed in counter-terror operations in the state since 2016.  — PTI


100-yr-old birth records in Cant still attract British

100-yr-old birth records in Cant still attract British


Over 100-year-old birth and death records of British officers and their families are still lying with Cantonment Board Hospital in Jalandhar. Tribune Photos


Rachna Khaira
Tribune News Service
Jalandhar, June 5
A visit to the office of the birth and death records here may not appeal interesting to many, but the office of the Jalandhar cantonment hospital is nothing less than an amusement for some.
A few months ago, a 90-year-old retired British army officer landed in the Jalandhar Cantonment Board (JCB) office and sought some records of the pre–independence era. Elaborating, he said he had served here as a young British officer in 1945 and wanted to collect the death certificate of his father who had died during his tenure here. The JCB office immediately took out the old records and handed him over the death certificate of his father.
Though the office could not ask for his details and take his photograph, they still remember the satisfaction on his face upon seeing the changed look of the Jalandhar cantonment after so many years.
This is not the first time that someone from the erstwhile British army landed in the JCB office. Many a time, descendents of British officers who served here came to this place to get their birth certificates.
According to an employee of the department, though the office has birth and death records since 1890, sometimes they face difficulty in providing such certificates to the families as a majority of these are in Urdu.
“While the records after 1950 are mostly written in English, the ones before this time were written in Urdu which we could not understand. We have now requested to get these translated so as to avoid any difficulty in future,” said an employee. Also, he said that the digitisation of the historic records had begun and soon these could be retrieved from the Internet as well.
On The Tribune team’s visit to the office, birth and death records as old as 100 years ago were found intact in the office. Surprisingly, a majority of the records were found to be those of Britishers, as if no need was felt during that time to keep records of Indian families as well. As far as the records of the British families were concerned, the name of the parents was written, but in the column of the child’s name it was written “not yet baptised”!
More surprisingly, at some places the birth and death records were found completely blank. When asked, officials were told that due to the commencement of World War 1 and II, the records might not have been maintained during that time.
Sources said while the General Hospital had been recommended to the Archaelogical Survey of India (ASI) to be declared a historical monument, the JCB should also make efforts to preserve the historic records that might contain birth and death details of some historic personalities who played a major role in the pre-Independence era of the country.


Trump must play pacifier between Iran and Saudi Arabia By Lt Gen (retd) Syed Ata Hasnain

 

President Trump delivering a speech to the Arab Islamic American Summit, in Riyadh on May 21

US President Donald Trump was reportedly a reluctant traveller during his nine-day international tour which took him to the Middle East and Europe. First international tours of US Presidents are supposed to be trendsetters, but Trump had too much on his mind about the impending and existing scandals back home; all reflective of the inexperience he brought to office and the awkward belief that high officials can get away with anything. The US system is full of checks and balances, and gives little leeway for political mistakes. The effects of becoming tainted are most telling on foreign policy.
There was a time when we eagerly awaited the speech of an American President, on tour to a crucial region of the world. From his words, geopolitics was molded. From Kennedy to Obama, US Presidents were known for their wit, presence of mind and sense of balance. I recall Obama’s message to the Islamic world from Al Azhar University in Egypt on June 4, 2009.

His legendary Assalamualaikum may not have impacted with the intent it was delivered, but the symbolism of delivering it from Egypt could not have been missed. Egypt and its ancient civilisation has been much to the Arab world.

Egypt was also the first to recognise the reality of fruitless confrontation against a US-backed Israel. Pragmatism and moderation ruled the country from where Obama decided to commence his journey of engagement with the Islamic world.

He adopted a policy of pragmatism rather than tilting favour to any segment of that world. He was aided by the fact that the US need for energy from West Asia was getting restricted during his time, with internal energy resources increasing within the US. Although he did not support Iran in any strident manner, his accommodative approach enabled the signing of the Iranian Nuclear Deal which is severely opposed by Saudi Arabia and Israel.

In fact, it was Obama’s more apparently neutral policy which peeved Saudi Arabia and led to a greater cementing of Israeli-Saudi ties to balance the increasing power of Iran. The US refusal to help the Saudis in the war in Yemen was another sore issue between the two nations.

All this led to a cooling of US-Saudi ties, necessitating Obama to go back twice to Riyadh during his second term to assuage feelings among the Royal leadership. By sheer contrast, President Trump, eight years later, decided to start his foreign tours from Saudi Arabia. It hogged headlines, but not too positively.
Trump’s USP was anti-Islamism during his campaign, which should clearly put him on the other side of the divide. It was, therefore, probably a smart thing on the part of his foreign policy team to have the Middle East as his first stop. The Trump visit also took in the Saudi initiative of putting together a virtual summit of the Sunni Islamic world; the President addressed it and had something to say for almost every country.

The message is becoming clearer. Trump, too, is a Realist, or at least his advisers have finally prevailed upon him to be one. Possibly, he has been told that his views on foreign policy are not sufficiently mature and that the US interests in it cannot be dictated by personal whims. So how does this impact the US approach to the Middle East?
Trump had the option of playing midway between Iran and the Saudis. That would have helped improve relations with Iran and sustain the Iran Nuclear Deal, offset the growing Russian and Iranian influence in Levant, put together some joint initiative against the IS and hope to resolve the mess in Syria.

However, the US mindset, based on the ignominy of the hostage crisis of 1979-80, will take years to look at issues concerning Iran in a more positive way. That makes the Russian link with Iran stronger. None of this is going to help the world resist the threats of Islamism.
Yet, Trump has only gone halfway. He has not rescinded the Iran Nuclear Deal, nor has he taken a decision on the visa restrictions against Muslims. He has signed billions of dollars’ worth of arms deals to sustain the US economy, with no assurance from where his hosts would find the money to pay for that; given the low cost of oil and an economy under threat.The fight against Radical Islam has to be focused in the Middle East. At the core of it is the Shia-Sunni divide manifesting politically as the Iran-Saudi divide. If the US really wished to take the lead in resolving an enduring problem affecting the world, it perhaps should look towards reduction of Iran-Saudi enmity instead of enhancing it. Israel can play a crucial role in this. For now, that may be utopian, but if Trump’s advisers are sensible, this is what they should work towards.

atahasnain@gmail.com