All posts by webadmin

China wants to ‘keep alive’ border dispute, says parliamentary panel

China wants to ‘keep alive’ border dispute, says parliamentary panel

Ajay Banerjee

Tribune News Service

New Delhi, September 16

China seems to be interested in keeping alive the boundary dispute with India, a parliamentary panel has said. An overarching “border engagement agreement” should be concluded between the armies of the two counties, it has suggested.The panel, headed by former Minister of State for External Affairs and Congress MP Sashi Tharoor, said: “It is difficult for the committee to escape the perception that China sees it as being in its interests to keep the (boundary) dispute alive indefinitely for the purpose of throwing India off-balance whenever it so desires.”

Till such time as a definitive solution can be negotiated, maintenance of peace and tranquillity in border areas is an important pre-requisite for the smooth progression of bilateral relations.The committee said: “It would strongly desire that a comprehensive Border Engagement Agreement is concluded between the Indian Army and the PLA (Peoples Liberation Army)”.

This, it says, should subsume all established mechanisms for confidence building, including border personnel meetings, flag meetings, meetings of the Working Mechanism for Consultation and Coordination on border affairs (WMCC) and other diplomatic channels.

Since Parliament is not in session, the panel presented the report “Sino-India relations, including Doklam, border situation…” to the Speaker Sumitra Mahajan on September 4.

The committee requested “Direction 71A of the Directions by the Speaker” with the request to permit the printing, publication and circulation of the report under Rule 280 of the rules of procedure and conduct of business in the Lok Sabha. The report was made public on September 12.

It has suggested that baseless claims made by China on the limits of the boundary with India need to be fully exposed before the international community. These claims are devoid of any amount of credibility or justification.


Assam extends AFSPA for 6 mnths

Guwahati, August 29

The Assam Government has extended application of the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act, 1958, for six more months with immediate effect. “The Governor has declared Assam as ‘Disturbed Area’ up to 6 months,” a release said. — PTI


Who defends the defenders? by Admiral Arun Prakash

Serving soldiers have approached SC over AFSPA. They must not be made to pay for governments’ failures.

The imposition of AFSPA is not a requirement of the army, but a fig leaf used by successive governments to hide egregious failures of governance

The imposition of AFSPA is not a requirement of the army, but a fig leaf used by successive governments to hide egregious failures of governance. (Illustration: C R Sasikumar)

On India’s 72nd Independence Day, while all and sundry were paying saccharine tributes to the armed forces, a development that will have a deep and long-lasting impact on the morale, cohesion, and integrity of India’s military, went unnoticed. In an unprecedented and hitherto inconceivable step, 356 serving officers and jawans of the Indian army filed a writ petition in the Supreme Court seeking relief for officers and troops serving on counter-insurgency duties from “persecution and prosecution” for performing their “bona fide duties carried out in good faith”. The very notion of proud Indian soldiers, ranging in rank from serving brigadier to rifleman, seeking the protection of the courts in the discharge of their duties represents a national shame. This development has several far-reaching and serious implications, not only for the military and its leadership, but also for the Indian state, which appears to have, yet again, failed in its responsibilities vis-à-vis the military as well as governance.

Focusing first on the armed forces, a collective action of this nature by serving personnel has legal and moral/ethical connotations for the military. By jointly filing a writ petition, this 356 serving personnel could be considered as violating the Constitution, which denies armed force personnel the right to form “associations” and the Army Act, which forbids collective petitions or representations. However, the petitioners face action under the civil criminal law and, astonishingly, received no advice, guidance or legal assistance from the Army HQ or the Ministry of Defence (MoD).

Hence their representation before the court that, “a situation of confusion has arisen with respect to their protection from prosecution… while undertaking operations in … proxy war, insurgency, ambushes and covert operations”, is justified. Their petition pertinently asks whether they should continue to engage in counter-insurgency operations (CIO) as per military orders and standard procedures “… or act and operate as per the yardsticks. of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC)?”

From the moral/ethical angle, soldiers approaching courts of law used to be an infringement of the “fauji” ethos. Resort to litigation, once rare and considered distasteful has, however, became common amongst military personnel mainly due to judicial activism. Any residual stigma that may have clung to litigation in the military was erased by a former serving chief who went over the head of the MoD to seek remedy from the apex court for a personal grievance. While the feeble and fumbling government of the day looked the other way, the succeeding government seemed to have approved such conduct by rewarding him with a ministerial berth. Against this background, is there any justification — legal or moral — for faulting the 356 officers and soldiers who face the fury of criminal law for seeking succour from the apex court?

But let us address the root of this whole problem, which is the deployment of the army in disturbed areas under the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA). Counter-insurgency operations, worldwide, tend to become “dirty” and difficult because they are waged against one’s own citizens. The army happens to be a “blunt instrument”, trained and motivated to destroy the nation’s enemies through extreme violence and, therefore, normally must not be used against one’s own citizenry. However, when the elected government does deploy the army for “aid to the civil power”, the law requires each detachment to be accompanied by a magistrate who authorizes, in writing, when fire may be opened on civilians.

Most insurgencies, rooted in alienation and socio-economic factors, are aggravated by political venality and apathy. After the serial failure of the elected government, civil administration and police, the area is declared as “disturbed” and the military asked to restore order, invoking AFSPA. Even when the army restores relative peace and normalcy, the local police and administration repeatedly fail to resume their normal functioning. The prolonged imposition of AFSPA is, therefore, not a requirement of the army, but a fig leaf used by successive governments to hide egregious failures of governance knowing full well that deployment of the army without AFSPA would be illegal, and any orders issued would constitute “unlawful commands”.

Soldiers, being human, do make mistakes and violations of human rights have occurred from time to time. But the army as a highly disciplined body is acutely conscious that violation of human rights is a crime that sullies the organisation’s good name. Strict and comprehensive codes of conduct have been laid down by the army’s leadership and drastic punishments are meted out under the Army Act where infringements are proved. A fact not generally known is that the strength of the Central Armed Police Forces (CAPF) has been steadily boosted and is now almost on par with our 1.3 million-strong army, and they have been designated the home ministry’s “lead counter-insurgency force”. This provides the government with some obvious choices: One, withdraw AFSPA and the army and hand over CI operations to CAPFs. Two, withdraw AFSPA, deploy the army and ensure that each patrol, ambush and covert operation has an embedded magistrate to authorise opening/returning fire. Three, retain AFSPA and trust your army.

Above all, let us remember that soldiers are equal citizens with equal rights and not sacrificial lambs for those with a confused national perspective. The actions of our soldiers, when acting on behalf of the state, must be dealt with under the Army Act and not the CrPC. The state must also react with urgency to insulate its soldiers from over-zealous NGOs and excessive judicial activism.


Army gets psychology-based e-platform for training troops

Vijay Mohan 

Tribune News Service 

Chandigarh, August 22 
The Army is employing a new psychology-based e-platform developed by the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) to define training requirements and assess human behaviour at individual as well as organisational level.
Referred to as the Organisational Effectiveness and Competence Building Training Management System, a prototype has been recently installed at the Shimla-based Army Training Command, the apex formation that oversees all doctrinal and training aspects of the Army. Over the past years, ARTRAC and its subordinate training establishments have inducted a large number of computer-aided training and assessment tools and simulators.

The web-based real-time training management system, named Sabera, comprises a user and an administrator interface. The individual level can be used for assessing individuals in leadership style, their strength and the areas they may like to include in their personal development programme.
The organisational level is meant for maintaining a human resource inventory, designing customised training programmes and as a personalised automated training aid. The system can also be used for human resource management. Sabera has already undergone rigorous tests at Category-A training establishments.


Have ‘solid evidence’ against Jadhav, hopeful Pakistan will win case: Foreign Minister

Have 'solid evidence' against Jadhav, hopeful Pakistan will win case: Foreign Minister

Kulbhushan Jadhav. File photo

Islamabad, August 23 

Pakistan has “solid evidence” against Indian national Kulbhushan Jadhav and is hopeful of winning the case against him at the International Court of Justice (ICJ), Pakistan’s new Foreign Minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi said on Thursday.

Jadhav, 47, was sentenced to death by a Pakistani military court on spying charges in April 2017. India moved the ICJ in May the same year against the verdict. The world court halted Jadhav’s execution on India’s appeal pending the final verdict by it.

Both India and Pakistan have already submitted their detailed pleas and responses in the world court.

“We have solid evidence against Jadhav and are hopeful we will win the case in the ICJ,” Qureshi told the media in his home city of Multan in southern Punjab.

“We will try our best to present our stance in an effective manner before the ICJ,” he said.

Yesterday, the Geo TV citing sources had said that the world court will hear the case daily for a week in February next year.

Pakistan says its security forces arrested Jadhav from Balochistan province in March 2016 after he reportedly entered the country from Iran.

In its submission to the ICJ, Pakistan had stated that Jadhav is not an ordinary person as he had entered the country with the intent of spying and carrying out sabotage activities.

India denies all the charges and maintains that Jadhav was kidnapped from Iran where he had business interests after retiring from the Navy and that he has no links with the government. On Indo-Pak talks, Qureshi said Pakistan wants to resolve the core issue of Kashmir in a peaceful manner through dialogue with India.

He hoped that India would reciprocate Pakistan’s offer for talks. PTI


215 recruits join Army

Tribune News Service

Srinagar, August 20

The chairman of Chiefs of Staff Committee, Lt Gen Satish Dua, on Monday said thousands of Kashmiri youths want to join the Army.In all, 215 recruits from the state joined the Jammu and Kashmir Light Infantry (JAKLI) Regiment on Monday. The passing-out parade was reviewed by Lt Gen Satish Dua at the JAKLI Regimental Centre in Rangreth on the outskirts of Srinagar.Lt General Dua said not all were alienated in Kashmir and the youths were coming in large numbers for the Army recruitment rallies. He hoped that the misguided youth would get back to the mainstream soon.“It is true that some of our children have been misguided and are on a wrong path. We hope that they will get back to the mainstream soon,” Lt General Dua told reporters after the function. “But this is just once facet of the state youth. If everybody is alienated then why do we have large number of J&K youths attending the Army recruitment rallies? Thousands of J&K youths want to join the Army. So, we must understand that there are some misguided elements but then there are some youth who have patriotic sentiments too,” he added.Lt Gen Dua said this summer, there had been an overall improvement in the situation.“Be it the incidents, terrorist encounters, stone-throwing — things are under control as compared to the previous years,” he added.


PM Imran Khan of Pakistan Can the two Punjabs at least get together?

PM Imran Khan of Pakistan

Pakistan’s third successive democratic transition should ideally suggest that civilians and the military have achieved a consensus on national security and foreign policy. But a closer look reveals that the last two democratic arrangements met their Waterloo after crossing swords with the security agencies. Imran Khan’s easy relationship with the army suggests that the current government may not spend most of its tenure anxiously looking over its shoulder. India is likely to rank as the fourth priority for Imran Khan after domestic consolidation and clean up, Afghanistan and ties with China-US-Russia. India needs to accept its place lower down on Islamabad’s pecking order as a blessing.Imran Khan has expressed a desire for reopening dialogue with India. But with the Modi government at the fag end of its tenure, any opening will get caught in the groove of whether Kashmir or terrorism should be the prime topic of discussion. The loser in this endless wait will be Punjab that had its natural trade routes to the west blocked after the 1965 war. The Modi government has initiated a massive infrastructure revamp along the coasts but Punjab’s wait for outlets continues. Punjab Cabinet minister Navjot Sidhu’s presence as Pakistan PM Imran Khan’s sole invitee from India points to the potential of reviving talks about re-engaging the two Punjabs. Last time this arrangement was sought to be consecrated via the Badal-Shahbaz Sharif joint statement. There need not be any political opposition to taking the dust off the initiative since at that time the Congress was in power at the Centre and the BJP a coalition partner in Punjab. For both Punjabs, the usefulness of trade revival needs hardly to be stated. But much of the agenda can only be implemented with the help of the Central governments. Both Islamabad and New Delhi need to take a hard look at such low-risk solutions that may over time become a stepping stone for substantial dialogue between the two nations.


Played 1948 Olympic final with Dr Chuttani’s help: Balbir Senior

Hockey legend scored 2 goals as India bagged first gold after Independence

Played 1948 Olympic final with Dr Chuttani’s help: Balbir Senior

Legendary hockey player Balbir Singh Senior at the Chandigarh Press Club on Sunday. Tribune photo: NITIN MITTAL

Sanjeev Singh Barriana

Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, August 12

“If it wasn’t for Dr PN Chuttani, I would not have played the hockey final at the 1948 London Olympics, when India won its first gold after Independence,” said triple Olympic gold medallist Balbir Singh Senior on the sidelines of a ‘Meet the Press’ programme here on Sunday. Balbir Singh had gone on to score two goals as India thrashed Great Britain 4-0.Speaking about the late Dr Chuttani, a former president of the Tribune Trust and PGI ex-Director, the veteran said: “After attempts to sideline me and not let me play on my favourite position of centre forward during earlier matches in the Olympics, I was told that I will not be playing in the final.”“Dr Chuttani, a hockey enthusiast who was then on a scholarship in England, reacted strongly to the development and met Indian High Commissioner Krishna Menon. The latter agreed to intervene to ensure that I played in the all-important final,” he recalled.The hockey legend was also part of the Indian Olympic team that won the gold in Helsinki (1952) and Melbourne (1956). Balbir Singh said the greatest glory in his life was to see the Tricolour unfurled every time the team won.On his protracted struggle to get back his memorabilia, including 36 medals, from the Sports Authority of India (SAI), he said: “Nathde nathde thak gaye haan. Pata nahin mere medal kitthe gaye. Eh vi pata nahin kide kol ja ke rovan (I am exhausted. I have no idea where my medals are).” The items also include the blazer he wore during the 1956 Olympics.Balbir Singh had given the medals to the SAI for a proposed museum back in 1985. “I needed a few of them for submission to the London Olympic Committee, which was honouring 16 heroes of various disciplines. Leave aside returning my possessions, I have not even got a reply about their fate,” he said.His daughter, Sushbir Bhomia, who is fighting the case for the lost items, said: “No one is giving us clear answers, but we will keep making efforts to find them.”On the upcoming Asian Games, Balbir Singh said he was hopeful of a good performance by the Indian hockey team.Envoy’s intervention did the trickAfter attempts to sideline me and not let me play on my favourite position of centre forward during earlier matches in the Olympics, I was told that I would not be playing in the final. Dr Chuttani, a hockey enthusiast who was then on a scholarship in England, reacted strongly to the development and met Indian High Commissioner Krishna Menon. The latter agreed to intervene to ensure that I played in the all-important final.Struggle to get back memorabiliaNathde nathde thak gaye haan. Pata nahin mere medal kitthe gaye. Eh vi pata nahin kide kol ja ke rovan (I am exhausted. I have no idea where my medals are). — Balbir Singh Senior


Story of India’s golden uprising:Balbir’s journey from carnage of 1947 to greatness in 1948

GOLDEN MEMORY OF 1948

 

OLYMPIC GLORY Despite the ravages of Partition, the 1948 hockey team won independent India’s maiden title

From page 01 England, the undisputed hockey champions of the world by virtue of winning the first two Olympic gold medals at London 1908 and Antwerp 1920, developed cold feet when they learned that India had entered the 1928 Amsterdam Games.

AP■ Balbir Singh scored two of India’s four goals in the 1948 final. India forward Balbir Singh (2R) attempts to score a goal during the London Olympics final vs Great Britain at Wembley Stadium.The English had a close look at the silken-skilled Indians at the Folkestone Hockey Festival just prior to the Olympics and the spectre of humiliation at the hands of a colony prompted the inventors of modern hockey to withdraw and thereby preserve their pride.

India went on to win three pre-War Olympic hockey gold medals as the English kept away with pride a huge barrier. But there was no escape when the Olympics came calling in London 1948. They formed the British Hockey Board with four countries to collectively combat India. While their untested rival was pulling all its might, the developing scenario in India was quite opposite — depletion and division. India achieved freedom but it came at a cost — Partition and the exodus of Anglo-Indians, the backbone of its hockey legacy.

Most players came from motley clubs like Brothers (Lahore), Spartan (Rawalpindi), Independents (Delhi), Lusitanians (Mumbai), Youngsters (Lucknow), besides institutions and states. These clubs had players of every creed, region and religion. Partition shook everything up. Hockey players were no exception when a chunk of the population had to abandon property, flee homes and seek new settlements as lives were in disarray.

Undivided Punjab was then the king of Indian hockey. The province held the National Championship, Brothers club, Invitation Cup, Spartan club and Aga Khan Cup. Vast areas of the region had now become Pakistan.

There was a problem hand. The winner’s troph could not be retrieved for n year’s competitions! Only t Aga Khan organisers w lucky. The Maori Shie given to National champio was stuck with the Laho based Punjab Hockey As ciation, never returning India.

Lahore and Lyallp based players like Kesh Dutt and Grahanand Singh were stranded. Th were touring the coun with the Indian Hock Federation (IHF) XI a then Sri Lanka midway

1947 when Partition p cipitated.

Their cities in flames, their families advised them not to return. Stars like AIS Dara, who represented India at the 1936 Berlin Games, Abdul Aziz, Jamshed and others cried out of the next event, the East Africa tour, to avoid being part of an Indian team. People were still migrating, blood was being spilled and princely states were playing truant when it came to joining India (Kashmir, Junagarh and Hyderabad in particular).

The refugee influx and settlement were raging issues when hockey was sought to be kept alive by IHF head Naval Tata. All the good work the IHF had done to prepare for the Olympics until then — the Nationals, trials, new tournaments like Pentangular, national team tour of the country and abroad — came to a naught because of the dissipation of talent. They had to start everything anew and the process earnestly began with the Nationals in early 1948.

Parts of Punjab that remained with India (East Punjab) managed to put together a new team to defend the title in Mumbai, the team being a pale shadow of its past. And it told. East Punjab was eliminated in Round 2 itself. Only five players from the holders featured in the competition. Bhopal took Punjab’s place in the Nationals. They beat Bombay for top honours (1-0). Despite roping in stranded stars like Keshav Dutt, domicile changers Amir Kumar (Punjab) and RS Gentle (Delhi), Bombay failed in the final. Bhopal’s left winger Latif-ur-Rahman, centre-forward Abdul Shakoor, defender Akhtar Hussain were outstanding and couldn’t be overlooked for a strong Indian team.

When the team for London was finalised it looked like any other team of the past — players from every walk, hue, creed and religion were present. Despite communal undercurrents and disharmony that was sweeping the subcontinent, the Indian team was not impacted. It comprised Christians, Hindus, Muslims, Anglo-Indians and Sikhs. Such a merit-oriented team was destined to make history. And London was the setting.

The problem IHF faced was the lack of funds. The requirement was a princely sum of ~3 lakh. Princes, kings, Nawabs, Diwans, Pramukh and the ruling class contributed substantially in the past to Indian hockey campaigns that ended in glory at three Olympics (1928, 1932, 1936). Having lost their clout and influence in the newly independent nation, funds from them were not forthcoming. IHF, meanwhile, decided to send the team by air to circumvent the problem of losing ‘all the gains made in the first ever three-week Mumbai camp in the 20-day travel by ship’.

Costs escalated. Gates, grants and fee from provincial hockey associations, private donations, the Cooperage Ball and other endeavours helped the cause. Every hardship the IHF had, every pain the players endured paid dividends. The combined might of four countries broke Pakistan (in the semis) but fell before India.

Amid full stands at the Wembley Stadium, 70 years ago on this day, it became clear — Indian hockey was class apart, they were true masters of the game they nurtured and modernised.

Three days later, the team celebrated the first anniversary of India’s independence with unbounded joy lined by Olympic gold.

Balbir’s journey from carnage of 1947 to greatness in 1948

That day when our flag was hoisted in front of thousands of Britons at the Wembley Stadium, I realised what independence meant. BALBIR SINGH, winner of three Olympic gold

BBC described Indian hockey’s 1948 London gold as one of the most politically significant episodes in the history of the Olympics. A British colony till a year ago, India defeated Britain on their home turf and saw the Tricolour of the newly-independent nation being hoisted in a country which ruled them for two centuries.

Leaving behind painful memories of Partition that saw massive migration, dividing the subcontinent into two nations (India and Pakistan) on religious lines and sparking large-scale violence which killed millions, the Indian hockey team gave a young nation something to feel proud of on August 12, 1948.

“Though it happened 70 years ago, memories of the London Games are as fresh as it happened yesterday,” recalls the 94-year-old Balbir Singh senior with moist eyes. “As a child I used to ask my father (Dalip Singh Dosanjh), who was a freedom fighter, what independence means and what we would get out of it. He’d reply that independence would give us our own identity, flag and pride forever. That day when our flag was hoisted in front of thousands of Britons at the Wembley, I realised what independence meant. It was the proudest moment for me and for all Indians back home. When the national anthem was played and the flag was going up, I felt that I was flying. I am short of words to describe that glorious moment,” added Balbir, who went on to complete a golden Olympic hat-trick (1948, 1952 and 1956).

PARTITION WOES

The story of independent India’s maiden Olympic gold started from the tragedy of Partition. India lost Lahore, a major hub of hockey, and many great players to Pakistan.

“Siblings Shahzada Sharukh and Shahzada Khurram, who were integral to the Punjab team, decided to stay back in Lahore, giving shelter to many teammates, including Keshav Dutt, and made sure they were escorted safely out of Lahore,” said Balbir.

Both brothers went on to represent Pakistan in London.

“The wound of Partition was so engraved in people’s hearts on both sides that when both teams came across each other during the 1948 opening ceremony, there was hardly any interaction between the players despite many of us playing for the state team just a year ago. There was no warmth.

“This was the impact Partition left and it took time to get out of that. Though with time, things settled down and we toured Pakistan in early 1950s for a Test series,” said Balbir.

“If the 1948 triumph was the greatest day of our lives, the 1947 carnage was the blot on our society. Being a Punjab Police inspector, I was in action then, trying to save people and stop violence. I was posted in Sadar ‘thana’ of Ludhiana and we got calls regarding fires, killings, abductions and loot almost every hour. People were at each other’s throat. There was a mass exodus of population fleeing to Lahore or coming from the other side. Because of the massacre, I stayed away from hockey for months.”

SELECTION CONUNDRUM

Mumbai won the 1948 Nationals and had seven players in the London squad. Initially in the 39-member list of probables for London, no player from Punjab was considered.

“It was only after the intervention of Dickie Carr, who was part of the 1932 Olympic gold medal-winning team, that I got a call after one week of the camp, eventually making it to the 20-member squad,” said Balbir.

THE FINAL

“When we took the field in the final, the jam-packed stadium was rooting for their team, but as the match went on, impressed with our game, the crowd started cheering us. That was the golden era of Indian hockey and I hope the day will come when we will again rule the world,” said Balbir, who scored the first two goals. Defender Trilochan Singh Bawa and Pat Jansen were the other scorers.

 


Exhibition on Army weapons thrills kids

Divya Sharma

Tribune News Service

Amritsar, August 11

The families of Army men and schoolchildren got a chance to know the Army in a better way through an exhibition organised by Panther Division at Panther Stadium in the Amritsar Cantonment.Children of jawans were enthusiastic to see the displayed arms. A large number of people attended the event organised ahead of the Independence Day celebrations.Schoolchildren were seen enthusiastically hopping around tanks, learning about the functioning of various guns besides getting their pictures clicked. However, families of Army men were seen accompanied by their real life heroes gathering information about the usage of these equipment.Sujata Waghmare, wife of an Army personnel accompanied by her two sons, said, “The kids should know what their father does.”The event began with a performance by Army band. Traditional bhangra added to the colour of the event. NCC cadets, war veterans and civil dignitaries were also present.Company Wuartermaster Sergeant CQMH, Rajesh Kumar, said, “It is good initiative. The family members can learn a lot from here.”Subedar Kundan Singh said, “I am posted in some other unit. Even I get don’t get to see such weapons on a daily basis. For my family, it is a new thing as they know we serve the Army but with this they can actually see the weapons and understand it’s working.”Shivani, a visitor, said, “I have come here for the first time. I love tanks.” Lalitesh Prasad, a student of Army Public School, said, “I am enjoying here with my school friends. It is so exciting to see these and understand them.”Brigadier Sushil Sharma was the chief guest of the event.