Sanjha Morcha

Writers put spotlight on war veterans

Writers put spotlight on war veterans

Srishti Jaswal

Srishti.jaswal@htlive.com

Chandigarh : On the concluding day of the three-day Military Literature fest at the Lake Club, Sector 1, a discussion on ‘India’s Most Fearless 2’, a book written by senior journalists and authors Rahul Singh and Shiv Aroor, was taken up.

Singh along with psychologist Renee Singh talked about the psychological aspects behind the brave act of military officers. The session was moderated by the resident editor of the Indian Express, Chandigarh, Manraj Grewal Sharma.

Discussing about wounded soldiers at the battlefield, Singh said after fighting against death, these men realise their true potential. The talk was shaped around his research experiences for writing the book.

Rationalising why these wounded soldiers return to the battlefield, Singh said, “These men attain a different level of consciousness. They experience a high that makes them realise the real power of human spirit.” “Therefore, they want to go back and die doing what they really loved,” he said.

Singh shared the first-hand accounts of the Indian military officers who were involved in the anti-terror encounters in the wake of the 2016 surgical strikes and many more. His book is a sequel to Aroor’s India’s Most Fearless and has fourteen stories of such men who display bravery in the line of duty.


Better coordination needed among defence forces:

Better coordination needed among defence forces: ExpertsSTRENGTHENING NATION Suggest that chief of defence staff be made a permanent member of all committees concerning national security along with inter-ministerial discussions on related matters

Amanjeet Singh Salyal

amanjeet.singh@htlive.com

Chandigarh : Experts present on the last day of the Military Literature Festival in UT, on Sunday called for the need to form a separate defence cadre in the country for ‘better coordination’ among the defence forces.

Speaking during a panel discussion on ‘Creation of the post of the chief of defence staff (CDS)’, former Vice Air Marshal Manmohan Bahadur stressed on the need for the same and said that officers of the proposed cadre should be deputed only in organisations related to the national security.

He said the CDS should be made a permanent member of all committees related to strategic policy group, nuclear command authority and be made a part of all the inter-ministerial discussions that are related to matters of the national security. “At present, a bureaucrat heading the defence ministry formulates the operational plans for war-fighting and chiefs of staff execute it. With creation of the post of CDS, it could be rectified,” he said.

Former defence secretary Shekhar Dutt said the post of CDS be created to facilitate ‘jointmanship’ and render single-point military advice to the government on matters of national security.

‘TO ACT AS ADVISER TO centrAL GOVT’

Lieutenant General (retd) Aditya Singh who was moderating the talk, said the post of CDS is aimed at ensuring better coordination between the three services, Indian Army, Indian Navy and the Indian Air Force, adding that it would act as the single-point advisor to the government of India. “The officer concerned will be in a position to advise on matters related to all the three services, thus, making India’s armed forces integrated,” he said.

Advisor to British High Commission, New Delhi, Brigadier Gavin Thompson, said a central decision-making body such as the CDS is the need of the hour. “It has been followed in the United Kingdom for several years,” he said, while sharing about the working of the CDS in the British country.

Meanwhile, Lt Gen (retd) Sanjeev Langer gave a presentation and compared the system of the command of armed forces in USA, China, France and other countries with that of the CDS proposed in India.

He said that men who don uniforms in the armed forces should be deputed permanently in the ministry of defence, adding that the proposed CDS could play a great role in fostering inter-services jointness in terms of budgeting, equipment purchases, training, joint doctrines and planning of military operations, an imperative of the modern warfare.


Arms and the man Defence procurement needs more attention

Arms and the man

The compulsions of a developing economy that has to balance its priority of reaching out to all sections of society and making scarce resources available to them while maintaining strategic parity in a hostile and nuclear-armed neighbourhood came to the fore when a former Army chief disclosed last week that sub-standard ammunition and three-year-old satellite images were supplied to India during the Kargil war. During a conflict, the warring sides are already stretched figuring out how long they can sustain the war even as their national interests are at stake, making the soldiers fight against the odds. No wonder then that vendors exploit such a situation. India is still striving for self-reliance in defence production and as was pointed out, ‘while we have made ballistic missiles, we can’t make assault rifles’.

India’s situation is dissimilar to countries in the West that are major manufacturers of armaments and sell them to rival nations to keep their economy buoyant. During the Kargil war, the Bofors gun played a stellar role but the value of the howitzer was realised only then, as allegations of a scam had preceded it, threatening the reign of a serving PM.

The defence budget has seen a hike over the previous year, but the forces have other needs too besides weapons like pension and the outlay falls short. Acquisitions also get mired in allegations of kickbacks and the involvement of middlemen, the latest example being of Rafale. India’s aspirations get reflected in its agreeing to be part of UN peacekeeping missions, sending the IPKF to Sri Lanka, quelling rebellion in Maldives and the desire for a blue-water status for its Navy. Its neighbourhood is not just hostile but also uneven, there being a Doklam too for Balakot. Parity, therefore, has to be carefully calibrated. The Indian Army is known for its men leading from the front irrespective of rank, like Abdul Hameed in the face of Patton tanks and Subedar Joginder Singh during the Chinese aggression. But warfare is increasingly getting technology-based and the forces should get value for money.

 


Chinar Corps to observe 48th anniv of 1971 war

Jammu, December 15

To honour the Army’s victory in 1971 Indo-Pak war, Chinar Corps will observe the 48th anniversary at Badami Bagh cantonment in Srinagar tomorrow.

Remembering the nation’s heroes and martyrs, rich tributes will be paid to the gallant martyrs in a solemn ceremony at the war memorial in Badami Bagh, Srinagar, where Lt Gen KJS Dhillon, Chinar Corps Commander, will pay homage by laying a wreath on behalf of the entire soldiers’ fraternity. A large number of veterans and families of martyrs will also take part in the celebrations.

16th of December is celebrated every year as ‘Vijay Diwas’ to commemorate the Indian Army’s victory in the 1971 Indo-Pak war which terminated with the total capitulation of the Pakistani army in erstwhile East Pakistan, that led to the birth of Bangladesh.

The momentous day will be befittingly celebrated with same pride and vigour at different Army formations and units all across the Valley. — OC


Army organises ice hockey tournament in eastern Ladakh

Army organises ice hockey tournament in eastern Ladakh

Tribune News Service

Jammu, December 15

As part of its effort to promote local sports and encourage local sportsmen, the Patiala Brigade of the Fire & Fury Corps organised the Durbuk Ice Hockey Challenge at the Durbuk Ice Hockey Rink in eastern Ladakh.

Undertaken as a “Sadbhavana” initiative, 10 local ice hockey teams participated in the competition which was conducted on the league-cum-knockout basis.

The Durbuk Shyok Club Red (DSC Red) and Sachukul A teams played the final match, which saw a very keen contest between the two teams. The spectators were treated to a very high standard of technical skills and sportsmanship during the final match, which was eventually won by the DSC Red.

Players were felicitated by Commander Patiala Brigade who complimented all participants for their skills and dexterity displayed during the entire championship.


MILITARY LITERATURE FESTIVAL Experts want CDS empowered

Experts want CDS empowered

Gorkha Regiment personnel perform during Military Literature Festival in Chandigarh on Sunday. PHOTO: RAVI KUMAR

Chandigarh, December 15

Welcoming the government’s decision to finally appoint a Chief of Defence Staff (CDS), experts at the Military Literature Festival today stressed that the post should be suitably empowered and the charter of duties clearly defined to meet the required objections of civil-military integration for policy planning, operations and procurements.

Former General Officer Commanding-in-Chief Lt Gen Aditya Singh said challenges of the 21st century required not just jointness among the services but a deep level of integration between the armed forces and the civilian leadership. The CDS would act as a single-point advisor to the Centre on all matters related to the three services.

Stating that India could not afford to work in silos, former Defence Secretary Shekhar Dutt said while the post of CDS was absolutely necessary in the Indian context not just for logistics but also for operations, creating the post of CDS alone was not enough. It required transformation and remodeling of the higher defence establishment.

Dutt stressed the post of CDS has been created as it is necessary to have a professional body of the highest standing to facilitate ‘jointmanship’ and render single-point military advice to the government on matters of national security. He said that this post has been created by keeping in mind the present day needs and the first CDS would be appointed in few days from now.

Air Vice Marshal Manmohan Bahadur (retd) said the CDS should be able to merge the capabilities which the services required with the procedures that the MoD required and the country’s higher defence organisation should be reformed with greater military presence in the ministry. — TNS


Sidelights/single column

Sidelights/single columns

HT Correspondent

chandigarh@hindustantimes.com

If you can’t buy happiness, buy a bike: Lieutenant General Anil Puri

If you can’t buy happiness, buy a bike: Lt Gen Puri

Chandigarh : “If you can’t buy happiness, buy a bike,” said Lieutenant General Anil Puri who has become the first among his rank to complete the 1,200-km Paris-Brest-Paris (PBP) Circuit, France’s oldest cycling event. Talking about the event on the concluding day of the Military Literature Festival in UT, he said, “The event that is held every four years, is every randonneur’s dream ride. I call the ride ‘Niravan on wheels’ because I got to spend some ‘me time’ with just a bike, terrain and a calm mind.” Calling out the attendees, the army official said one should push his/her limits in terms of physical endurance.

The Israeli spirit

During the session ‘Defending against formidable odds: The Golan Heights, 1973’ on the concluding day of Military Literature Festival, 2019, experts lauded the spirit of nationalism of Israelis. They said the dedication and commitment of Israelis towards their country helped them counter the attacks by Arab countries. Even during war, they repaired and refurbished tanks rapidly to combat the superior armoury of the enemy. During the discussion, Israeli Major General Yosi Ben-Hannan shared his experience of war and said they had only 10 tanks but targeted more than 90 enemy tanks.

Talks on naval operations

The third edition of the Military Literature Fest at the Lake Club, Sector 1, saw a substantial navy presence with over four sessions hosted by the naval officers. On the concluding day of the festival, Commodore Srikant Kesnur was present during one of the sessions on Operation X: The Untold Story of India’s Covert Naval War in East Pakistan, 1971. Lieutenant Commander Aditya Thakur presented the talk on submariners on the first day of the fest, while on the second day, Captain Rajan Kapoor presented a talk on aviators at sea. On the third day, Kesnur spoke on naval operations at the 1971 war. Lieutenant Commander Rajiv Lochan with Lieutenant Shark Mahla spoke about special operations by the Indian Navy.


MILITARY LITERATURE FESTIVAL The hero of Burma campaign

The hero of Burma campaign

Lt Gen Baljit Singh (retd)

“I was, like other Generals before me, to be saved….by the resourcefulness and the stubborn valour of my troops.” — General William Slim about the Burma campaign, 1944

In the closing two years of WW II in the Burma campaign, Gen William Slim as Commander Fourteenth Army would emerge a votary of the dictum that “A bold general may be lucky, but no general is lucky unless he is bold”. General Slim was an intuitive master of the “operational art” and a deserving entrant in the hallowed pantheon of warlords by the virtue of exceptional military leadership skills.

Field Marshal Slim’s meteoric rise was shaped by his impoverished childhood. Starting as a teacher in a local slum school, he eventually became a much-decorated soldier. Because of his exceptional leadership skills, he carved a victory out of defeat during the Burma campaign

There are three broad elements to warfare, namely the application of combat power, marshalling and movement of logistics. But above all, capable military leadership with proven battlefield experience backed by scholarship in the art and science of warfare. And the application of these elements as a judicious mix at the appropriate time and place is the crux of what is called the “operational art”.

Unlike his peers, Slim’s meteoric rise was shaped by his impoverished childhood. He started his first job in 1910 as a teacher in a local slum school and later became a clerk in Stewarts & Lloyds. He learned an early lesson that assiduous hard work is the bedrock of success in life.

Within days of commencement of World War I, Slim qualified for War Time Commission in the Royal Warwickshire Regiment. As a rookie lieutenant during the Gallipoli offensive, he led his platoon courageously against the Turks. In the process, Slim was seriously wounded but got a the Military Cross (MC) for his gallantry. After eight months’ of hospitalisation in London, he was back on the battlefield with renewed vigour and was Mentioned-in-Dispatches twice for bravery in the battle of Baghdad. He was again wounded and evacuated to Bombay. Post recovery this time he was granted permanent commission in the Indian Army, his alma-mater hereafter.

A battlefield hardened and proven combatant, Major Slim now focussed his energies on acquiring military scholarship. He topped the merit list for entry to Staff College, Quetta and topped the class on graduation. He then served at Army Headquarters, Delhi, before moving to Staff College, Camberley (UK), as an instructor. Given his background for hardwork and merit, three years later he was the natural choice for the inaugural course at the Imperial Defence College (UK), in 1937.

Now promoted to Lieutenant Colonel and given command of 2/7 Gurkha Rifles, Slim was quite pleased with it because in Gallipoli he had been “fascinated by the fighting qualities of the little mountain men from Nepal.” Two decades later, Slim’s memoir, Unofficial History was, in part, a sensitive eulogy of his Gurkha comrades.

At the commencement of World War II, Slim had, by the dint of his courage and application of mind for six years on the art and science of warfare, acquired a reputation for professional excellence among his peers and superiors. This was further bolstered as he successfully led a brigade in Eritrea. This was followed by command of 10 Indian Infantry Division for the capture of Iraq and Iran. It got him the Distinguished Service Order, which is second only to the Victoria Cross (VC).

When Japan joined the Axis Alliance with their devastating aerial blitzkrieg over Pearl Harbour on December 4, 1941, almost the entire armed forces of India, Australia and New Zealand had been committed to war in Europe, Africa and the Middle East. As we now know, Pearl Harbour was a prelude of the Japanese two-pronged grand design viz, defeat of China once and for all (Operation Ichi-Go) and the March to Delhi (Operation U-Go).

The War Office in London at that time had little choice but to create from scratch a rag-tag Burma Corps (Burcor) comprising 1 Burma Division. It was hurriedly patched together from Territorial Battalions, two Indian Mountain Artillery Batteries, and eight antiquated Air Defence Guns. This unit was soon to be reinforced with 17 Indian Infantry Division which at that time was on the high seas heading for Egypt.

A World War I veteran Maj-Gen John Smyth, VC, MC, wanted the 17 Division to have its first battle along the Sittang River but both British PM Winston Churchill and Commander-in-Chief of American-British-Dutch-Australian Command Archibald Wavell, desperate for victory after a series of defeats elsewhere, over-ruled Smyth and ordered him to “Go forward”. That he did and despite several brilliantly fought encounters, he and his men could not stem the winning streak of the Japanese offensive.

On February 23, 1942, Smyth was faced with the dilemma to either accept destruction of his two brigades in contact with the enemy or blow the only bridge over River Sittang and thus impede the Japanese advance and delay the fall of Burma. He chose the latter.

In the event, 17 Division was reduced to one effective brigade and Smyth was “sacked”. A brilliant career ended in unwarranted disgrace on March 2, 1942.

As though prompted by prescience, the War Office had already moved Slim to Rangoon. At this juncture he took up Command of Burcor manfully but the challenge of stemming the Japanese offensive was beyond the means at his disposal. The best he could do was to prevent a rout and destruction and so he dexterously launched them on “the Indian Army’s fighting withdrawal of 1,800 kilometres, the longest in the history of warfare” crossing back to India on May 24, 1942. In General Stilwell’s words, “They had got a hell of a beating but they had not been disgraced…..Slim was proud to have commanded them and was determined that one day they would go back.”

The Japanese, too, were stretched beyond their capacity for the march to Delhi and instead pulled back along the Irrawaddy River line to regroup for another push. Meanwhile, Slim was promoted to command the newly created Fourteenth Army with the mandate to recapture Burma with his cosmopolitan army of 12 divisions; seven were Indian, two British and three from colonies in Africa besides ample air support from two components of the US Army and Allied Air Forces in Assam (a far cry from the Burcor). Meanwhile, the Japanese Burma Army had also grown from four to eight divisions.

By March 1944, the stage was fully set for an Armageddon such that “nowhere in WW II did the combatants fight with more mindless savagery”. Slim had decided that he would lure the Japanese to come forward on the ground of his choosing, cripple them severely against his well entrenched defences from Imphal to Kohima and thereafter go on the offensive to inflict total defeat. As anticipated, the Japanese took colossal casualties and were forced to retreat in total disorder in July, 1944. By one estimate from this opening phase of Slim’s offensive “…. of the 150,000 Japanese troops only 14,000 survived”!

Promoted General and Commander All Allied Land Forces South East Asia, Slim’s next phase was a masterpiece of the operational art opening with a daring and deep outflanking manoeuvre to capture Meiktila, leaving the bulk of Japanese Army in the Irrawaddy loop with close to zero logistic support. And that set the stage for 17 Division to make a dash for Rangoon and hoist the Union Jack from where they had been evicted by the Japanese two years earlier on February 24, 1942. A great military triumph by any yardstick.

And of that dramatic moment, a nineteen-year-old lance corporal wrote home “I see him (Sic.Slim) clear, with that robber-baron face under that Gurkha hat, and his carbine slung, looking a rather scruffy private with a General’s tabs, which, of course, is what he was.”

Penning his most charming memoir, the Unofficial History, Slim recounts that once as a cadet he sat pouring over the text of “Principals of War” when an old Sergeant-Major going past him checked his stride and said “Don’t bother your head about all them things, me lad. There’s only one principal of war and that is this. Hit the other fellow, as quick as you can, and as hard as you can, where it hurts him most, when he ain’t looking”.

That advice was to guide Slim throughout the Burma campaign in the shaping of a “defeat into victory” such that the military historian Lt Gen Sir John Kiszely would most deservedly call Slim “perhaps the Greatest Commander of the 20th Century”.


Martyrdom fortnight to be observed

Martyrdom fortnight to be observed

Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, December 15

Chief Minister Capt Amarinder Singh on Sunday announced that the state government would observe “Shaheedi Pandarwara” (martyrdom fortnight) from December 16 to 30 to commemorate the supreme sacrifice of the family Guru Gobind Singh.

The Chief Minister has appealed to people to observe the ‘Shaheedi Pandarwara’ as homage to Guru Gobind’s family and also to spread the message of their sacrifice across the world. It has been more than 300 years since the martyrdom of Guru Gobind’s mother Mata Gujri and his four sons — Sahibzadas Ajit Singh, Jujhar Singh, Zorawar Singh and Fateh Singh — but their sacrifice remains a beacon to inspire people across the globe, he added.

It has been decided to observe the somber and sacred occasion during the month of “Pauh”, which is dedicated to mourning the great souls of those who had passed away, said an official spokesperson.

According to the spokesperson, the government will organise various programmes such as seminars, discussions and exhibitions to disseminate the message of the unparalleled sacrifice of the Guru’s family, especially among the youth.

The Chief Minister described this as a humble effort, as part of his government’s endeavour, to create awareness among the younger generation about the lives of the Gurus and imbue them with the principles for which They lived and died.


Dedication, Commitment Of Israeli People Always Helped Them To Counter Attacks’

The dedication and committed of Israeli people for their country has always helped them to counter the attacks of Arab countries. Even in the war, they repaired and refurbished the tanks rapidly to fight against the superior armour of the enemy. The experts in ‘Defending Against Formidable Odds: The Golan Heights, 1973’ discussion on the concluding day of Military Literature Festival 2019 lauded the spirit of nationalism of Israelis. During the discussion speaker Major General Yosi Ben-Hannan also shared his experience of war with the help of motivating presentationWhile initiating the discussion, Moderator Lt General KJ Singh said that young Israelis are very keen to join the army to serve their nation and they don’t even hesitate to sacrifice their life on their motherland. He added that they are one of the best examples to follow if one wants to work for the safeguard of his or her country.Israeli Maj Gen Yoshi Ben-Hannan, while narrating his days in the war, said that he had only 10 tanks in the starting but as they started performing well by hitting enemy tanks, they were joined by the tanks from other battalions too. He added that with their 10 tanks, they had targeted more than 90 tanks of the enemy.Meanwhile, Lt General IS Singha also acclaimed that spirit of Israeli youth and informed that every year 60,000 boys and 60,000 girls qualify for the army service which is another inspiring aspect for the nations like India. He added that it is not the religion which is uniting them; it is their language which infuses the spirit of nationalism in them.While talking about the situation of war, Lt Gen IS Singha claimed that it requires 10 day advance notice for any army to get prepared for the war but Israel got only few hours notice due to the failure of intelligence agencies. He added that an Intelligence Officer should never be over confident as the result of the war depend lot upon his inputs.