Sanjha Morcha

Interim ban on construction in 100-metre area around airport HC asks GMADA to carry on with demolishing illegal structures

Interim ban on construction in 100-metre area around airport

ribune News Service

Chandigarh, September 26

Less than two months after the Indian Air Force expressed safety and other concerns regarding the Chandigarh international airport, the Punjab and Haryana High Court today ordered interim ban on further construction in a 100-metre area from the boundary wall of the landing field.

A Division Bench of the High Court also made it clear the to Greater Mohali Area Development Authority to carry on with the activity of demolishing illegal structures falling in the area under its jurisdiction. Taking note of GMADA’s assurance that it would issue orders in this regard by Monday, the Bench directed the state of Punjab to provide adequate police force.

The Bench of Chief Justice Krishna Murari and Justice Arun Palli also made the Zirakpur Municipal Corporation a party to the ongoing public interest litigation on making the airport fully operational. It was also directed to initiate action against illegal constructions in accordance with law. The Bench also called for a detailed report on the issue.

Appearing before the Bench, Assistant Solicitor General of India Chetan Mittal said the issue of illegal constructions was being raised since long. He added that the worst affected was Phabat village in Zirakpur, where multi-storeyed buildings were coming up overnight.

Elaborating, Mittal said the height of the airport boundary wall was 11 ft and any structure higher than that was dangerous. Quoting an example, he said a joint survey was carried out after a high-level meeting of all stakeholders was convened by the amicus curiae or the friend of the court, senior advocate ML Sarin. However, the Zirakpur EO did not participate in the process.

Besides, the construction of a building was brought to the Mohali Additional Deputy Commissioner’s notice again and again, initially when it started, again when the first floor was constructed and then when the second floor came up. Taking a serious view of the matter, the Bench verbally asked the EO to seek voluntary retirement.

The Chandigarh Administration, in the meantime, undertook to acquire and pay for 0.6 acre essential for providing the CAT-III facility to enable landing during poor visibility. The Bench, during the course of the hearing, was informed that major deadlines for pending works had been fixed following the meeting convened by senior advocate Sarin. The Bench was told that the work on resurfacing and extension of the airport would be completed by March 31 next year.

The work on completing lighting and installation of the CAT-II facility, too, would be over by that date. Tata Power SED, the company involved in the installation of the CAT-II system, has also been made a party for furnishing the requisite undertaking regarding the completion of work.

Multi-storeyed buildings at Phabat

  • Appearing before the Bench, Assistant Solicitor General of India Chetan Mittal said the issue of illegal and unauthorised constructions was being raised since long. He said Phabat village in Zirakpur was the worst affected, where multi-storeyed buildings were coming up overnight. He said the height of the airport boundary wall was 11 ft and any structure higher than that was dangerous

Clear-cut corruption in Rafale deal, PM must clear stand

Clear-cut corruption in Rafale deal, PM must clear stand: Rahul

Congress president Rahul Gandhi addressing a press conference on Rafale deal at AICC headquarters in New Delhi on Saturday. Tribune photo: Manas Ranjan Bhui

Tribune News Service
New Delhi, September 22

Congress president Rahul Gandhi Saturday said there was “clear-cut” corruption in the Rafale deal and asked Prime Minister Narendra Modi to clear his position on the issue.

Gandhi’s blistering attack on Modi during a press conference came a day after former French president Francois Hollande was quoted as saying that the Indian government proposed Anil Ambani’s Reliance Defence as Dassault Aviation’s Indian partner in the Rs 58,000 crore Rafale jet fighter deal.

The prime minister must clear his stand on the Rafale deal after Hollande’s remarks, he said.

“Why is the prime minister silent? It is a matter related to defence forces, it is a matter related to corruption,” he said.

He also claimed that various defence ministers of the NDA government have been lying to protect Modi.

Gandhi demanded a joint parliamentary committee probe and Hollande can also be called.

“We are absolutely convinced that the prime minister is corrupt… He must clarify,” Gandhi said.

“It is very important for the prime minister now to either accept Mr. Hollande’s statement or state that Mr. Hollande is lying and tell what the truth is,” he said.

‘Surgical strikes’

Taking to Twitter earlier in the day, Gamdhi called Reliance Defence’s involvement in the deal “surgical strike” on the country’s defence forces.

“The PM and Anil Ambani jointly carried out a One Hundred & Thirty Thousand Crore SURGICAL STRIKE on the Indian Defence forces. Modi Ji you dishonoured the blood of our martyred soldiers. Shame on you. You betrayed India’s soul,” Gandhi tweeted.

The report in ‘Mediapart’, a French language publication, quoted Hollande as saying recently: “It was the Indian government that proposed this service group, and Dassault which negotiated with Ambani. We had no choice; we took the interlocutor who was given to us”.

Modi had announced the procurement of a batch of 36 Rafale jets after holding talks with then French president Hollande on April 10, 2015, in Paris. The opposition party has been accusing the government of choosing Reliance Defence over state-run Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd to benefit the private firm even though it didn’t have any experience in the aerospace sector.

Hollande’s remarks contradict the central government’s stand that Dassault chose Reliance Defence as an Indian partner to fulfil its offset obligations and that the establishment had nothing to do with it. With PTI


Feather in cap

Feather in cap

(From left) Lt-Commander Pratibha Jamwal, Lieutenant S Vijaya Devi, Lieutenant Payal Gupta and Lt-Commander Swati P, the crew of INS Tarini, India’s first all-women circumnavigation expedition of the globe, pose on the concluding day of the ISB Leadership Summit 2018 in Mohali on Saturday. A Tribune photograph

At home in sea, these voyagers sail to see the world

CHANDIGARH: Sailing is the best way to see the world. Coming from Lt Commander Pratibha Jamwal, Lt Commander Swati P, Lt Vijaya Devi and Lt Payal Gupta — the four sailors who were part of the world’s first all-woman naval crew of INS Tarini to circumnavigate the globe — these words carry immense weight.

KESHAV SINGH/HT■ (From left) Lt Commander Swati P, Lt Payal Gupta, Lt Vijaya Devi and Lt Commander Pratibha Jamwal in Mohali.In Chandigarh for the leadership summit of the Indian School of Business, the four say the 250-day long cruise that concluded in May this year, was a lesson in life.

Lt Commander Pratibha Jaswal from Kullu, 29, who trained as an engineer from Solan, says they learnt to never give up. “When six of you are confined in a 56-feet yacht, the size of a big room, with only ocean for company, you make the most of everything,” she says

The women from as far as Manipur in the East, Vishakhapatnam in the south and Himachal in the north all volunteered for the project because they wanted to explore the world and test their limits. The sea, they say, knows no gender.

“I remember running down from my watch tower on the sixth floor when I heard they were seeking volunteers,” says Swati, 28, who has been sailing since 9, thanks to a mother who was a sailing instructor. It was ditto for the others. Once selected, they underwent training for over two years.

They have returned with a renewed passion for life. We appreciate the smallest things, says Lt Payal Gupta, 27, an engineer from Dehradun. Lt Vijaya Devi, 28-yearold postgraduate in English from Manipur, who used to suffer from aquaphobia until she joined the navy, says the expedition was also a lesson in geography. Her eyes gleam as she tells you about Falkland, a tiny island in South America.

“While sailing, we have to rely entirely on the winds,” says Swati as she dwells on the almost wind-free Indian Ocean vis-a-vis the stormy Cape Horn, located between Antarctica and South Africa.

The girls battled very strong winds, extreme cold and seven-foot-high waves in a yacht that operated only with the power of the wind. Their bunks were cone shaped because the yacht always tilts to one side. They kept themselves in high spirits by rustling up delicious meals.

“Be it idli, noodles, pizza… you name it, we made it,” they say in chorus.

“It’s the cheapest way to see the world if you don’t have to buy the boat,” grin the four sailors, who have been bitten by the travel bug.

Like Ulysses, they plan to keep travelling. And while you are still marvelling at their feat, they tell you the Indian Navy is planning another first — a solo circumnavigation around the world by a woman.


Punjab govt declares holiday on Sept 10

Punjab govt declares holiday on Sept 10

Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, September 8

On the directive of Chief Minister Captain Amarinder Singh, the Punjab government has declared a gazetted public holiday on the occasion of ‘First Parkash Purab of Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji’ (installation of Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji in Sri Harmandir Sahib in 1604) on September 10, Monday.

Disclosing this here, a spokesperson of the Chief Minister’s Office said that all the offices of Punjab government, boards, corporations and educational institutions would remain closed on the occasion. This holiday was earlier included in the state’s list of restricted holidays.


Rafale deal grandmother of corruption, Nirmala Sitharaman being made the scapegoat: Congress

Rafale deal grandmother of corruption, Nirmala Sitharaman being made the scapegoat: Congress

Congress asked how the price of Rafale aircraft shot up by 300 per cent during Modi`s tenure from Rs 526 crore to Rs 1,670 crore.

Kota: Calling Rafale deal the grandmother of all corruption, Congress spokesperson Shakti Singh Gohil has said the culture of crony capitalism has become part of the Narendra Modi government’s DNA.

Speaking to media persons during his one-day visit to Kota on Sunday, Gohil said Congress workers would tour the country and expose the corrupt Rafale deal.

How did the price of Rafale aircraft shoot up by 300 per cent during Modi’s tenure from Rs 526 crore to Rs 1,670 crore, Gohil asked. He alleged the entire deal reeks of gross mismanagement.

It is said Modi does not accept less than crores. He is the master in safe corruption,” Gohil said and pointed out that for the first time three defence ministers have been in office in four years.

“Arun Jaitley and Manohar Parrikar escaped the corruption charge in Rafale deal. Nirmala (Sitharaman), being politically naive, is now being made the scapegoat,” Gohil alleged.

BJP carried out a campaign against the Congress, alleging corruption in the Bofors deal, however, no evidence was found against Rajiv Gandhi, he said.

A group of committees should discuss and negotiate when such deals are being made, leaving no chance for corruption, he explained.

 

If the Modi government is sure of the Rafale deal, why does it not constitute a joint parliamentary committee (JPC) as demanded by Congress national president Rahul Gandhi, Gohil asked.


Maj Gogoi case: ‘Moral turpitude, corruption to be dealt with sternly’

Maj Gogoi case: 'Moral turpitude, corruption to be dealt with sternly'

Army chief Gen Bipin Rawat. File photo

New Delhi, September 4

Any case of moral turpitude and corruption would be dealt with sternly, Army chief Gen Bipin Rawat said on Tuesday, referring to Major Leetul Gogoi, who was found guilty of “fraternising” with a local woman at a Srinagar hotel.

Gen Rawat said action would be taken against Maj Gogoi in keeping with his guilt.

“I had clearly said that any case of moral turpitude and corruption will be dealt with in a very stern manner. The Court of Inquiry has recommended that we should go in for courtmartial proceedings.

“If it is related to moral turpitude, then we will take action accordingly. If it is something else, the punishment will be (according) to the crime he has committed,” Gen Rawat told reporters in New Delhi in response to a question on Maj Gogoi.

Last month, an Army Court of Inquiry indicted Maj Gogoi for “fraternising” with a local woman at a Srinagar hotel and being away from his place of duty.

Maj Gogoi was detained by police in May following an altercation when he was allegedly trying to enter a Srinagar hotel with the 18-year-old woman.

Last year, the officer was at the centre of a human shield row after his decision to tie a civilian to the bonnet of his vehicle in Kashmir, purportedly as a shield against stone-pelters during polling in the Srinagar Lok Sabha by-election.

He was honoured by Gen Rawat with the Army chief’s Commendation Card for his sustained efforts in counter-insurgency operations. PTI

 


Joint Indo-US Army exercise concludes at Chaubattia

The fortnight-long 14th Indo-US joint Army exercise in ‘Yudh Abhyas’ series, at Chaubattia in Uttarakhand’s Almora district saw one infantry battalion—350 soldiers—each carrying out field training drills under a joint brigade headquarters, an Indian Army spokesperson said.

The exercise that concluded on Saturday saw participation of US Army’s 1st Battalion of the 23rd Infantry regiment. It was the fourth such exercise at Chaubattia, the spokesperson added.

The Yudh Abhyas series started in 2004 under US Army Pacific Partnership Programme.

“Over the years, the two countries have decided to progressively increase the scope and content of the combined exercise,” said an Indian Army officer.

The commanders and staff officers of both sides worked in close coordination to receive and collate intelligence to issue suitable operational orders. The combined field training components executed these orders in simulated realistic situation, the spokesperson said.

The exercise curriculum, the spokesperson said, was planned progressively where the participants were initially made to get familiar with each other’s organizational structure, weapons, equipment and tactical drills.

The training culminated in a 48-hour consolidation and validation exercise in which troops carried out a daring rescue and destroy mission in the general area of Pilkholi near Chaubattia.

The final exercise was reviewed by senior officers from both sides, the spokesman added. — IANS


Eastern command posting puts Lt Gen Mukund Naravane in reckoning for top army job

NEW DELHI: A game of musical chairs is being played with the top brass of the Army with an officer who was relegated to a training command being shifted to the operationally sensitive East to give him a shot at the top post of Army chief next year.

Lt Gen Mukund Naravane, who was posted as the head of the Army’s Training Command in December last year, would be the senior most officer of the Indian Army when General Bipin Rawat retires next year. While in the past the seniority principle ..

Read more at:
//economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/65864869.cms?utm_source=contentofinterest&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=cppst

Artists claim bias against WW-I Indian soldiers

London, September 23

A group of Indian artists, in the UK to mark the centenary of World War I, has claimed they have uncovered documents that reveal bias against the Indian sub-continent soldiers fighting alongside the British Army in the 20th century war.

The Delhi-based artists from the Raqs Media Collective told the ‘Observer’ that papers from the British Library revealed the British forces systematically neglected to treat psychological problems among Indian soldiers and adopted unequal measures in the care of soldiers traumatised by their experiences from the battleground.

“The condition of shell shock was first diagnosed in 1915 by the English doctor Charles Meyers. But documents we found show Meyers quickly dropped the term because it was feared ordinary soldiers would find it easy to understand and so would ask to be seen by medics,” said Shuddhabrata Sengupta of Raqs.“Insted, Meyers suggested a more opaque diagnosis of NYD, or Not Yet Diagnosed — Nervous, which ordinary soldiers would find harder to use,” he said. Sengupta’s team is working on a new art project at Colchester in Essex, commissioned to commemorate the end of World War I — being marked in the UK since 2014 and set to end in November this year.

The term “trench back”, which features in their new installation ‘Not Yet At Ease’, was often adopted to describe symptoms that were actually psychological. “The idea of ‘trench back’ was derived from the condition of ‘railway back’, which was used for people who were thought to have been upset, or jolted, by the speed of rail travel,” said Sengupta. “It was a way of talking about wounds or damage to the spine, instead of mental health. ‘Trench back’ was supposedly caused by being knocked by falling debris in the trenches.”

Records show 1.3 million soldiers from undivided India served in WW-I as part of the British Indian Army. — PTI


The price of ‘national security’ by Shyam Saran

The phrase is misused by predatory States to wield power without responsibility

The price of ‘national security’

Hush-Hush: The 2013 Task Force on National Security report was never made public.

Shyam Saran
Former foreign secretary

The term ‘national security’ is a convenient catch-all for governments which wish to justify policies which abridge the rights of citizens. It is often used to deflect the need for transparency and hide incompetence and misgovernance. The shortcomings in one’s own defence preparedness and intelligence capabilities are camouflaged in the noise of blaming adversaries for their aggressive behaviour. Even when the spotlight is turned on one’s own failures in safeguarding national security, reports are kept from public scrutiny because, ironically, they may ‘compromise’ national security. Historians are denied access to archives even when these are decades old because, again, national security may be undermined. In sum, this means that citizens cannot be trusted with knowledge that might actually permit them to assess the performance of those who govern in their name. ‘National security’ is a magic phrase which allows predatory States to wield power without responsibility. In an age of international terrorism where citizens are rightfully fearful and anxious it has assumed even greater potency.

This phenomenon has become pervasive across the world, affecting democracies and non-democracies alike, though there may be differences of degree. But its impact is most corrosive in democracies as it erodes individual fundamental  rights which lie at the heart of democracy. The worst abuse of citizen’s rights appears to require no justification beyond citing national security.  Even courts are loath to question government actions when this phrase is bandied about darkly. India has not been immune to this international trend and successive governments have found this a convenient way of encroaching on the constitutional rights of citizens and evading responsibility for actually endangering national security through acts of commission and omission. Even on issues that do not directly relate to national security, such as data on river flows, public access is denied because such data is deemed to be ‘sensitive’. It should come as no surprise that we never seem to learn from our mistakes. Transparency is fundamental to democratic governance because only with transparency is accountability possible. And contrary to what governments may believe, it is the lack of transparency and accountability which represents one of the most significant threats to security. Behind this penchant for opaqueness lies the constant neglect of what is really required to safeguard the nation’s interest. Opportunities for corruption exist because facts can be hidden on grounds that national security may be compromised. This has been evident in several defence deals over the years. Governments make bona fide mistakes in managing security, but responsible governments submit themselves to scrutiny from respected and credible non-governmental entities to ensure that mistakes are exposed and acknowledged and remedial action taken. But even when governments have subjected themselves to such scrutiny they baulk at making  reports public. Even Parliament does not get a chance to exercise its role as a public sentinel.

The Task Force on National Security, whose very comprehensive report on both domestic and external security was submitted in May 2013, was never put in the public domain. If the UPA government was wary of doing this, so has been the successor government. It is argued that publicising the report may alert our adversaries to our security gaps and that the government is taking action to implement its various recommendations. This is a specious argument. Without transparency there is less incentive to move with a sense of urgency to implement corrective measures and this is quite apparent in our continuing failure to deal with cross-border terrorism or to eliminate left-wing terrorism. It is really the weakness in governance and political corruption which have undermined our security. We should condemn Pakistan for engaging in cross-border terrorism,  but why is there little or no focus on drug smuggling and contraband trade which facilitate such breaches of our border defences? Security forces are deployed to defeat left-wing extremism, yet its economic and social dimensions are ignored. Without acknowledging this, it is difficult to see how the Naxal challenge can be met, whether in its rural or urban manifestation. Detaining social activists who raise such uncomfortable questions about the State’s misgovernance and its pursuit of discriminatory policies against the most underprivileged citizens of our country is not going to promote national security.

Political sensitivity and desire not to be held responsible for failure are often the reasons for lack of transparency. But it is this political tendency which is most responsible for creating an insecure and vulnerable state. In-house inquiries do not deliver results because those guilty of mismanagement and even dereliction of duty are unlikely to make an honest assessment of their own failings or suggest reforms which may come at the cost of their personal or organisational interests. This is the reason why the constant examination and review of India’s security institutions and processes cannot be left to the discretion of political leadership or be subject to the veto of security agencies who have no interest in exposing their own failings and weaknesses. Finally, this points to the crying need for an Indian national security doctrine which alone can provide  a long term assurance of security in an era of rapid change. Ad hoc responses coloured by political compulsions will not do anymore.