Sanjha Morcha

18 years on, Kargil war continues to confound

Veterans say there is little historical analysis of 1999 conflict, its impact

CHANDIGARH: Lt Gen SH Kulkarni (retd) spoke for many when he asked whether the establishment has learnt any lessons from the Kargil War of 1999. Why did Kargil happen? Have we acted upon the lessons it served us or are we setting the stage for another Kargil?

ANIL DAYAL/HT■ Col Balwan Singh, a Maha Vir Chakra winner, addressing the session on Kargil War during the Military Literature Festival at the Lake Club in Chandigarh on Friday.He rued that there was little historical analysis of the war and its social impact. “Would it have been in our interest to widen the war? The navy could have inflicted great hardships had it been allowed to attack Pakistan. I retired three years ago, and there was no answer to any of these issues,” fumed the general.

These questions also resonated with the audience at the session on Kargil War 1999 during the Military Literature Festival 2017, here on Friday. So did the blow-by-blow account that Col Balwan Singh, Maha Vir Chakra winner, provided of the battle for Tiger Hill.

A young lieutenant with 18 Grenadiers at that time, he was leading the ghatak platoon that was tasked with capturing Tiger Hill on July 3. Though just three months into service, he led his team to the hilltop, taking a very steep, unexplored route, took the enemy by surprise and stormed their bunkers, killing four Pakistanis despite being wounded. “That was a very decisive battle, after which the enemy started fleeing,” recounted Singh.

Interestingly, Subedar Yogendra Singh Yadav, Param Vir Chakra, who was part of Col Balwan’s platoon, was also present.

A QUESTION OF INTELLIGENCE

While Col Balwan brought the war to life, other panelists debated the inter-force coordination and the quality of intelligence inputs that played a big role in Kargil. Author of a book on Operation Vijay, Lt Gen Mohinder Puri (retd), who was commanding 8 Mountain Division, which was moved from the Valley to Kargil, described how they managed to surprise the intruders and secure a victory.

Surprise was a big element in the operations. Air Marshal Vinod Patney, who moderated the session, described how they too were taken aback when they were asked to rehash their plans at the last minute. “It was on May 25 that I got a call from the chief that we were on deployment the next day. Then he dropped a bombshell. He said don’t cross the Line of Control, not a single bomb should fall across it. This was totally different from the plans we had prepared.”

The operation was a surprise for the aircraft as well. “None of our aircraft was designed for combat operations in such mountainous terrain. In fact, no combat aircraft has been designed to operate there,” he said, adding that the IAF was in perfect sync with the army and not a single army soldier or installation was affected by the air shelling.

When asked about the tri-services doctrine, the Air Marshal declared, “Integrated command is a bad word.”

Commenting on the “surprise” element, Brig Davinder Singh (retd) said there were indications of intrusion and increased firing in the Kargil sector, but these were not interpreted rightly. “All our intelligence gathering resources are with the RAW, not with the army. What can we do if they choose to keep half the information to themselves.”

Be it intelligence or lack of it, the time taken by the Indian establishment to react, or the last minute change in operations, 18 years on, Kargil continues to confound.


Ministry of Defence doubles honorarium for gallantry awardees

Ministry of Defence doubles honorarium for gallantry awardees
An Ashoka Chakra awardee will be paid Rs 12,000 a month, up from Rs 6,000. Ashoka Chakra is the highest peace-time gallantry award. PTI file

Ajay Banerjee

Tribune News Service

New Delhi, December 6

In an important decision, the Ministry of Defence (MoD) has doubled the honorarium for gallantry awardees. The monies will be admissible from August 1.A notification of the MoD signed on December 4 says the highest war-time gallantry awardee of the Paramvir Chakra, will get Rs 20,000 per month, up from Rs 10,000 being paid as of now.An Ashoka Chakra awardee will be paid Rs 12,000 a month, up from Rs 6,000. Ashoka Chakra is the highest peace-time gallantry award.

(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)

New honorarium for Maha Vir Chakra and Kirti Chakra will be Rs 10,000 and Rs 9,000, respectively. This has also been doubled. A Vir Chakra awardee will be getting Rs 7,000, a Shaurya Chakra awardee Rs 6,000 while a Sena medal, Nao Sena medal and Vayu Sena medal awardee will get Rs 2,000 per month.The award will be dispensed to the widow of the awardee in case the awardee is dead. In case the awardee was a bachelor, the award will be paid to the father and mother.The previous enhancement was made in 2012.On the other hand, the MoD is reconsidering the cap it imposed on the fees paid for children of martyrs. The MoD had imposed a cap of Rs 10,000 per month and this would have impacted 3,200 children studying in various stages of their education, including in professional colleges. 


Can’t rule out Rohingya terror links: BSF report

NEW DELHI: The Border Security Force (BSF) has not caught any Rohingya with arms or terror links but it cannot be ruled out, KK Sharma, chief of the paramilitary force, said on Wednesday, adding that there were about 36,000 Rohingyas in the country.

AP FILETill Oct. 31, 2017, fake notes worth ₹50 lakh, all of ₹2,000 denomination, were seized by BSF.“The threat that they have links with terror organisations is a very serious one. It has been given by our sister agencies and I don’t doubt them,” Sharma said on Wednesday. He said his troops apprehended 87 Rohingya Muslims along the India-Bangladesh border in 2017 and 76 “had been sent back to Bangladesh”.

The annual report released by the BSF on Wednesday said agents lure Rohingyas with good job opportunities in India and motivate them that they will work with their own community in states such as J&K, Tamil Nadu and West Bengal.

“Apart from being a natural choice due to its Muslim majority, the Rohingyas say they pick J&K on economic considerations and most of them follow a similar pattern. Once a Rohingya reaches Jammu, he stays there for a few months and then invites other relatives, informing them of job opportunities and better pay,” it said.

In its annually collected data, released two days before its 52nd raising day, the BSF highlighted key issues and initiatives taken along the eastern border.

Issues such as Maoism, narcotics smuggling, fake Indian currency networks, illegal sale of arms and ammunition, cattle smuggling and illegal immigration of Rohingya Muslims rank high on the agenda of the force. The operational initiatives taken by BSF in 2017 have been on the eastern border with some of them waiting approval from the ministry of home affairs.

The BSF data between December 2016 and October 2017 — a period post demonetisation — suggested that fake Indian currency networks took a major hit after Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s announcement last year in November, but they continue to operate and have even replicated the new ₹2,000 note to the best of their “abilities”

This year till October 31, fake notes worth ₹50 lakh, all of ₹2,000 denomination, were seized by the BSF. In 2013, the force seized fake notes worth ₹95 lakh, followed by ₹1.9 crore in 2014, ₹2.8 crore in 2015 and ₹1.5 crore last year.

The BSF also claimed to have penetrated areas previously considered safe havens for Left-wing extremists, apprehending 120 Maoists in Odisha and Chhattisgarh along with weapons.

In addition, the paramilitary force managed to recover over 10,000kg narcotics and seized 1.20 lakh cattle.

Sharma said the government in Bangladesh, being “friendly”, had helped the force maintain law and order but more had to be done for its upkeep.


World’s largest amphibious aircraft makes maiden flight in China

World’s largest amphibious aircraft makes maiden flight in China
Chinas domestically developed AG600, the worlds largest amphibious aircraft. — Reuters.

Beijing, December 24

China’s domestically developed AG600, the world’s largest amphibious aircraft, performed its maiden flight on Sunday from an airport on the shores of the South China Sea, the latest step in a military modernisation programme.(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)China has stepped up research on advanced military equipment as it adopts a more muscular approach to territorial disputes in places such as the disputed South China Sea, rattling nerves in the Asia-Pacific region and the United States.State television showed live images of the AG600 lifting off from Zhuhai airport in the southern province of Guangdong, which sits on the South China Sea coast.It returned about an hour later and taxied to its stand accompanied by martial music and greeted by crowds waving Chinese flags.Xinhua news agency said the aircraft was the “protector spirit of the sea, islands and reefs”.It had previously been scheduled to make its first flight earlier this year but it is unclear why it was delayed after ground tests took place in April.State-owned Aviation Industry Corp of China (AVIC) has spent almost eight years developing the aircraft, which is roughly the size of a Boeing Co 737 and is designed to carry out marine rescues and battle forest fires.However, state media has also noted its potential use in the South China Sea, where China, Vietnam, Malaysia, the Philippines, Taiwan and Brunei all have overlapping claims.The AG600’s chief designer, Huang Lingcai, was quoted in the official China Daily earlier this month as saying it can make round trips without refuelling from the southern island province of Hainan to James Shoal, claimed by China but which is located close to Sarawak in Malaysian Borneo.Powered by four turboprop engines, the AG600 can carry 50 people during maritime search-and-rescue missions, and can scoop up 12 metric tons of water within 20 seconds for fire fighting trips, according to state media.The aircraft has received 17 orders so far from Chinese government departments and Chinese companies. It has a maximum flight range of 4,500 km (2,800 miles) and a maximum take-off weight of 53.5 tonnes.It can use conventional airports and also land and take-off from the sea.China is in the midst of a massive military modernisation programme, ranging from testing anti-satellite missiles to building stealth fighters and the country’s first indigenous aircraft carrier, to add to an existing one bought from Ukraine. — Reuters.


18 Army Goodwill Schools’ teachers felicitated

Jammu: Lt Gen D Anbu, GOC-in-C, Northern Command, awarded 18 teachers of various Army Goodwill Schools of the state at an award ceremony held in Udhampur on Tuesday. These teachers were selected after a stringent process based on their teaching ability and use of modern teaching aids. The awards were sponsored by the Satya Bharti Foundation and included cash prize, trophy and a certificate. Muhammad Ashraf Magrey of Army Goodwill School, Ziran, won the first prize in the senior secondary-level category thanked the Army for providing a platform for the teachers to showcase their teaching abilities and making a positive contribution in improving the education scenario of the state. tns


Work to integrate BrahMos on 40 Sukhoi fighter aircraft starts

New Delhi, December 17

Work has begun to integrate the BrahMos supersonic cruise missile on 40 Sukhoi combat aircraft, which is expected to fulfil critical needs of the Indian Air Force in the wake of evolving security dynamics in the region.The air-launched variant of the BrahMos, the world’s fastest supersonic cruise missile, was successfully test-fired from a Sukhoi-30 combat jet on November 22, marking a major milestone to enhance the precision-strike capability of the Air Force.(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)The work to integrate the BrahMos missile on 40 Sukhoi combat aircraft has begun. A timeline for the project is being set, official sources said without elaborating.  It is learnt that the project is expected to be completed by 2020. The fleet of 40 Sukhoi jet will undergo structural modifications at the state-run aerospace major Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd (HAL) for integration of the missile on them. The 2.5-tonne missile flies almost three times the speed of sound at Mach 2.8 and has a range of 290 km. The range of the missile, an Indo-Russia joint venture, can be extended up to 400 km as certain technical restrictions were lifted after India became a full member of the Missile Technology Control Regime (MTCR) last year.“It is a very important project considering IAF’s evolving requirement to boost air power when the possibility of a two-front war cannot be ruled out,” said an official.After the test firing of the air-launched version, the IAF had said the missile coupled with the superlative performance of the Su-30 aircraft will give the force a strategic reach and will allow it to dominate the ocean and the battlefields. The integration of the missile on Sukhoi aircraft is a very complex process involving mechanical, electrical and software modifications of the Su-30 jet. BrahMos is a joint venture between DRDO of India and NPO Mashinostroyenia of Russia. — PTIHeaviest weapon on Sukhoi-30

  • BrahMos will be the heaviest weapon to be fitted on India’s Su-30 fighter aircraft
  • The fleet will undergo structural modifications at state-run Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd
  • With this, IAF capability to strike from large stand-off ranges on any target on sea or land will rise manifold
  • BrahMos is named after two rivers: Brahmaputra and Moskva (flowing in western Russia)

290 km the missile’s range — extendable up to 400 km as certain technical restrictions were lifted after India became a full member of the Missile Technology Control Regime in 20162.5 tonne the missile’s weight, which flies almost three times the speed of sound at Mach 2.82020 year by which the missile- Sukhoi integration project is expected to be completed


Sikh battalion Subedar’s advice saved Valley in ’47

Sikh battalion Subedar’s advice saved Valley in ’47
Punjab Chief Minister Capt Amarinder Singh speaks at Military Literature Festival in Chandigarh on Friday. TRIBUNE PHOTO: RAVI KUMAR

IAF attack at Longewala was massive

  • The IAF attack on Pakistan army tank column at Longewala during the 1971 war was important as it destroyed a large number of tanks, recollected Air Marshal Vinod Patney (retd). In the audience sat Brig Kuldip Singh Chandpuri (retd), who as a Major led a company of the 23 Punjab Battalion, to prevent tanks from coming. The IAF had taken over at first light and destroyed 28 tanks. “There were a large number of tanks and we had only four hunter aircraft that launched an attack in streams. Twenty-eight tanks were hit,” said Air Marshal Patney, speaking at a session “Use of air power in 1971 war”. This was done using atechnique last used in the World War-II (1939-45), he said

Ajay Banerjee

Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, December 8

The Kashmir valley was saved in 1947 due to military action stemming from a strong advice given by a Subedar of the 1st Sikh battalion of the Indian Army to his officer.On realising that it was impossible to defend just the Srinagar airfield from the Pakistan army-backed armed raiders, the Subedar suggested to his boss Lt Col Dewan Ranjit Rai: “Sahib let’s go find the enemy rather than wait for them to arrive.”Punjab Chief Minister Capt Amarinder Singh, a noted historian, narrated this anecdote at a session on the first Indo-Pak war (1947-48) on the opening day of the Military Literature Festival here this morning.Col Rai heeded the advice and moved his troops towards Baramulla, some 34 miles north-west of Srinagar. That, Capt Amarinder said, changed the course of the fight. In all, 462 marauders were killed. In the meantime, the troops of the 1st Patiala moved up to Zoji La and held onto the pass for the six months, stopping the ingress of the raiders from the eastern flank. The two — 1st Sikh and 1st Patiala (now rechristened 15 Punjab) — secured a total of 27 gallantry awards among themselves, including 1 PVC, the highest war-time gallantry award.Capt Amarinder said on October 25, when VP Menon, the then secretary of states, led a delegation to Srinagar, “there was panic”.Dr Harish Khare, Editor-in-Chief of The Tribune Group of Newspapers, said: “Who did what to whom remains a matter of subjective interpretation even after 70 years. We have an Indian version, a Pakistan version and rather mischievous British version.”“Many questions remain unanswered. What was the role of British leadership? Could things be different had an Indian General been given command of the Army (a British was the commander then). Could there have been a better timing for accepting a ceasefire? Many of the present narratives flow from the mistakes we made, not made, or presumed to be made,” said Dr Khare.Lt Gen AK Mukherjee (retd) narrated how a company of 13 Field Regiment wore the uniform of 1st Sikh and when artillery guns arrived they reverted to being gunners (their original role). They fought a very decisive battle to save Uri.Brig IS Gakhal (retd), who is from the Sikh Regiment, narrated interesting anecdotes on role of the 1st Sikh. Brig MS Gill (retd) listed the surprise caused by tanks at Zoji La that led to the advance towards Drass and Kargil. Maj Gen Shivdev Singh (retd) suggested that the battles of Jammu, Kashmir and Ladakh could not be seen in isolation when studying the war.


Military and its glory in focus at fest by the lake

Besides interactions with war veterans and winners of gallantry awards, the festival will have a book exhibition, handicrafts stalls, armament display and live painting corner

From page 01 CHANDIGARH:City Beautiful is geared up to experience an amalgamation of war stories, experience, and defence literature under a single roof with the twoday Military Literature Festival starting at the Lake Club, on Friday.

ANIL DAYAL/HT PHOTOSIn the final countdown to India’s first Military Literature Festival, the motorcycle display team of the Indian Army left scores of Chandigarh residents awestruck with their performance at Uttar Marg, near Sukhna Lake on Thursday.The event is a joint initiative of the Punjab government and the Chandigarh administration, and is being supported by the western command of the Indian Army.

The festival aims to create awareness among people, especially the children, about military history and accomplishments of our forces. The event is open to all and has free entries. The registration for it can be done at www.militaryliteraturefestival.com.

Besides interactions with veterans, the festival will have a book exhibition, handicrafts stalls, armament display, live painting corner, magic shows for children, selfie with war heros, among others.

The festival will also host a performance by Punjabi sufi singer Satinder Sartaaj at the Capitol Complex, whereas Gorkha soldiers will stage the famous khukri dance at the lake club.

Adequate parking facilities have been made and shuttle service will be provided for the last-mile connectivity.

WAR VETERANS TO INTERACT WITH SCHOOLCHILDREN

To provide schoolchildren an opportunity to interact with war veterans, the festival is organising a ‘Children’s Samwad’. These veterans include heros from the Sino-India war of 1962, the Indo-Pak war of 1965, the Bangladesh liberation war of 1971 and the Kargil war.

Honorary Captain Bana Singh (retd), a Param Vir Chakra (PVC) winner— India’s highest wartime military honour— will share his experience with the children.

Besides him, Brigadier Kuldip Singh Chandpuri (retd), a Maha Vir Chakra winner, best known for his heroics in the Battle of Longewala when he was successful in holding the Pakistani forces for a full night with just 120 soldiers, during the Bangladesh liberation war of 1971, is also participating in the festival.

Naib Subedar Sanjay Kumar, who was awarded the Param Vir Chakra for capturing Area Flat Top, despite being grievously injured, during the Kargil War, and Subedar Yogendra Singh Yadav, the youngest person to be awarded the Param Vir Chakra, will also interact with the children. Other decorated officers like Col Balwan Singh and Brigadier Sukhjit Singh, Maha Vir Chakra winners, will also interact with the schoolchildren.

‘WILL BE A LEARNING EXPERIENCE FOR YOUTH’

Talking about the significance of the festival, Major General BS Grewal (retd), director of Maharaja Ranjit Singh Armed Forces Preparatory Institute, Mohali, said, “Cadets at our institute are looking forward to the festival with great enthusiasm. The experience will be very beneficial for them because they will get an opportunity to meet and interact with many veterans.”

Shubhdeep Singh Aulakh, a student at the institute, said, “These events should be organised more often so that aspirants like us get to know how we can best serve the country. Interacting with the veterans and knowing their experience will be a lifetime opportunity.”


A FITTING TRIBUTE TO BRAVADO::::Nostalgia marks braveheart’s statue­unveiling at his school

DS Sandhu and Jaikanta Sandhu, parents of late Rajeev Sandhu, second lieutenant of the Assam regiment, whose statue was unveiled at his alma mater, St John’s High School, in Sector 26, Chandigarh, on Wednesday.

Second Lt Rajeev Sandhu was killed in peace operation in Sri Lanka

From page 01 CHANDIGARH : For parents who could not even see the body of their only son, Wednesday was a day that will always remain etched in the memories of DS Sandhu and Jaikanta Sandhu, parents of late Rajeev Sandhu, second lieutenant of the Assam regiment, whose statue was unveiled at his alma mater, St John’s High School in Sector 26.

HT PHOTO(From left) Lt Col PK Jaitley, Rajiv Chandgothia, Col Michael James, Sanjeev K Sharma, Varun Khurana, Akhil Mehta and Rajesh Bansal, who were Sandhu’s batchmates at St John’s High School.It was an emotional moment for his batch mates, members of the regiment and young students.

Second Lieutenant Rajeev Sandhu had served in the Indian Army for only four months when he lost his life fighting against the LTTE during a peacekeeping operation in Sri Lanka in 1988.

At 21, he became the youngest officer to receive Maha Vir Chakra (MVC), the second highest gallantry award of the country after Param Vir Chakra. He was commissioned in the army on March 5, 1988, and gave supreme sacrifice on July 19, 1988. Seen as an effort to highlight his achievements and motivate students to join the forces and serve their country, principal Kavita C Das shared how the officer embodied the motto of the school— For God and Country.

The highlight of the day, however, was when the martyrs’ batch mates who turned up in large numbers broke into tears as Justice GS Sandhawalia took the podium and recollected the memories of his friend and class fellow Rajeev Sandhu.

FUN-LOVING AND COMPETITIVE Unanimously referred to as a loyal friend, a disciplinarian with a competitive spirit, Sandhu’s class fellows were effusive in their praise for their friend. “He was always sure that he wanted to join the army,” said Lt Colonel PK Jaitley, his batch mate, complimenting his never say die spirit.

His class fellow Akhil Mehta, a consultant, said he owes his roller skating skills to Sandhu who was a national champion in the sport.

While another alumni Col Michael James (retd), Sanjeev Sharma and Rajeev Bansal added how Sandhu’s fun-loving avatar came out every now and then, be it while going for gehri to Sector 9 near Carmel Convent School back in the 80s or while planning trips to Kasauli and Pinjore airfield.

Many credit his parents for imbibing this spirit in him from a young age, the soldier’s father, a former para-trainer, and his mother, who was the first woman SP in the Punjab cadre during her time.

However, the humble parents believe they are best known as the ‘proud parents of the bravest soldier.’

The beauty of the event was how it brought together people who even though had never met the army officer, but had heard of his valour all their lives.

Brig Jashi Bawa (retd) from the same battalion in the Assam regiment shared how Rajeev Sandhu is remembered to date and became a source of inspiration for everyone there.

The function was concluded on a serene note by the students of the school who presented the national anthem in sign language throwing light on the concept of equality for all.

Besides the Para Olympic soldiers and boys of the school, the audience comprised bureaucrats and other dignitaries from the city, including Congress leader Manish Tiwari and judges of the Punjab and Haryana high court, members of the Assam Regiment. Subedar Major KB Chettri of 7 Assam Regiment, Col Mridul Verma, CO of Assam Regiment, BrigChaudhry on behalf of the veterans, were also present.


Pak violates ceasefire yet again, targets Army posts in Poonch

Pak violates ceasefire yet again, targets Army posts in Poonch
Indian troops guarding the LoC retaliated effectively. Tribune file

Jammu, December 24

Pakistani troops on Sunday resorted to unprovoked firing along the Line of Control in Poonch district of Jammu and Kashmir, a day after a similar incident took the lives of four Army personnel in nearby Rajouri district.

(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)

The Pakistani troops started firing from heavy and light weapons from across the border, targeting forward posts and villages in Shahpur sector around 12.55 pm, a police official said.

Read: Major, 3 jawans killed in Rajouri LoC attack

He said the Indian troops guarding the LoC retaliated effectively and that the firing between the two sides was going on when the last reports came.

However, there is no immediate report of any casualty in the skirmishes, the official said.

The latest ceasefire violation comes a day after the Pakistani troops killed an Army Major and three jawans and injured another in Keri sector of nearby Rajouri district.

Jammu and Kashmir witnessed a total of 881 ceasefire violations this year, highest in the past seven years, along the LoC and the International Border (IB), resulting in the death of 34 persons.

According to officials, Pakistan has violated ceasefire along the LoC in Jammu and Kashmir 771 times till December 10, and 110 times along the IB till November-end this year.

Thirty persons — 14 Army personnel, 12 civilians and four BSF personnel — were killed in such incidents.

The truce between India and Pakistan along the International Border, Line of Control and the Actual Ground Position Line in Jammu and Kashmir came into force in November, 2003.

India shares a 3,323-km-long border with Pakistan, of which 221 km of the IB and 740 km of the LoC fall in Jammu and Kashmir.

In 2016, there were 449 incidents of ceasefire violations wherein 13 civilians and 13 government forces personnel were killed and 83 civilians and 99 security personnel were injured.

In 2014, there were 583 incidents of ceasefire violation in which 14 civilians and three security personnel were killed and 101 civilians and 28 security personnel were injured.

In 2015, the number of ceasefire violations was 405; 347 in 2013, 114 in 2012, 62 in 2011 and 70 in 2010. PTI