1. Its a matter of shame that the respectable elected representative of the People and for the People have ,behaved in a very derogatory , way , which was not expected from the MLA’s. The most uncivilized pattern of behavior in the Punjab Assembly on 22 Jun 2017 was more like trade union employees.
2. The MLA’s forgot to maintain their dignity and image of their status putting the voters who have voted them in an embarrassing situation. They were seen fighting with Police to force their way into the assembly by pushing Punjab Police personal and asking them to show the authority and tore off the letter which was handed over to them in front of Police Mulajims. A very shameful act which is uncalled for from any MLA.
3. Earlier the MLA were mostly and almost uneducated but the present stream are graduates at least. Does the fault lies with our our education system or it is matter of lack of training and wisdom of the newly elected first time elected MLA ‘s to the Assembly as they are not aware about the conduct to be followed.
4. There is need to train these raw MLA’s for 3 weeks training to teach them how to conduct themselves in Assembly and how to maintain the decorum and sanity and dignity of the Vidyan Sabha.
Can we say the speaker has lost the control our the Assembly MLA’s . Had he taken the initiative to train all MLA’s irrespective of party affiliation he would had been respected as a GURU by All but there seems to be unkown failure on this aspect. Speaker failed to train them especially the new MLA. In this haggama none of the old MLA’s behaved in this manner but only the new ones to earn cheap popularity among massesin an a undignified behavior.
This confirms
(a) They have no point to discuss except slogans.
(b) They have only negative politics in mind to find weaknesses.
(c) They are not aware about the proceedings process in the house or how best the question hour can be utilized.
(d) May be the frustration as they lost the power against their expectations and now want to make up.
There was no issue on which such hagama should have taken place. Earlier the suspended MLA’s from APP, Sukhpal Khaira and Bains wanted forceful entry in the vidhan sabha and they got engaged in altercation with the State Police Staff , whom they are suppose to command and give instruction for Law and order. The two MLA from APP degraded themselves and lost their respectability and dignity of being people representatives.
Ruckus In Punjab Assembly On Day Seven Of Budget Session/AAP Women MLAs Insulted In Punjab Assembly
No Doubts AAP lives to its anarchic reputation; outrages sanctity of Vidhan Sabha. They are all leaders by themselves and fail to listen to their nominated leader. It seems it was provocation by Sukhpal Khaira and Bains if they are not allowed inside , the other members of their party must make hue and cry in the assembly which went out of control .
AAP MLA Parmal Singh’s Turban Taken Off In Punjab Assembly
The lady APP MLA giving communal colour to the self removed turban and spreading his hairs.
It was a day of ‘competitive hooliganism’ resorted to by the Aam Aadmi Party and the Shiromani Akali Dal for grabbing the opposition space in the Vidhan Sabha and the headlines in the media in the process outraging the sanctity of the august house.
On Thursday the Aam Aadmi Party members lived up to their characteristic (ill)reputation of being THE ANARCHISTS. Their crying persecution notwithstanding, it is they who started it. One of their members tried to break the security cordon, after pushing aside the female staff in a undignified way thus so shamelessly, apparently in a bid to assault the Speaker. Others also tried to join in. Speaker had no option but to order them to be marshalled out. Instead of following the Speaker’s orders, they tried to browbeat the marshals, including the female staff. Once taken out, they started crying wolf and persecution. One of the marshals arm was fractured. Number of MLA’s misbehaved with the female staff by pushing them but they resisted even they were wrongly touched at places during pushing.
Captain Claims AAP MLA Outraged Modesty Of A Lady Constable/Manpreet Say Akalis And AAP Hand In Hand
The scene was so embarrassing for the speaker to watch when MLA’s were misbehaving with Female staff of the assembly that Speaker had to Call the marshals to show the out door to the rudy MLA’s .
Shiromani Akali Dal, that’s desperately trying to grab the opposition space jumped in to the “defence” of AAP. The gullible AAP members walked into their trap, without realising that the Akalis were actually grabbing their space and the headlines in the media. No doubts the advantage was cashed by Sukhbir Singh Badal and Majithia who had ignited the fuel to earn upper edge to show better behavior than APP .
There was no turban falling down but as precautionary the concern MLA took off the turban and opened his hairs to show that he was manhandled. What a pity.
And to top it all the ‘seasoned statesman’, Sardar Parkash Singh Badal seized the moment to shed ‘sympathetic’ tears for the AAP legislators who were crying persecution and intimidation. Otherwise he has not been attending the Vidhan Sabha.
Former CM Prakash Singh Badal Visits AAP MLAs In Hospital / SAD Condemn Speaker For Using Force/sympathetic’ tears for the AAP legislators
As they say, POT CALLING THE KETTLE BLACK.
Tossed turbans in Punjab Assembly bring AAP, SAD MLAs together for common cause(Removed on his own and spread his hairs)
The MLA’s Themselves are not trained for Vidhyan Sabha procedure and they alleged that they were forced from the house by untrained staff. Does this mean that they should had been taken on chairs while singing “He is a Jolly Good fellow” . MLA;’s have to behave nad come on the Assembly floor and discuss the issues worth diverting attention of the govt not for criticism only.
My personal views and logics
Col CJS Khera
Gen Secy
Sanjha Morcha
ASSEMBLY IN SESSION
Stretchers out in Punjab House
“AAP MLAs and the Akalis are conspiring to disrupt proceedings of the House. Action should be taken against all legislators who have been breaking Assembly rules and throwing papers at the Speaker, besides creating a ruckus over non-issuesCapt Amarinder Singh, Chief Minister
If elected representatives are treated like this, imagine how the ruling party will behave with the commoners. Turbans of MLAs came off… it’s an insult to the Sikh communitySukhbir Singh Badal, Akali Dal president
Any effort to disrupt the House proceedings for petty political interests would not be tolerated. Anarchist activities (by Opposition MLAs) are against the sanctity of the august HouseRana KP Singh, Vidhan Sabha Speaker
Marshals attacked AAP leaders on the Speaker’s directions. They removed turbans of five MLAs and misbehaved with women legislators. I thank the SAD and SGPC for showing support and concernHS Phoolka, Leader of opposition
Badal has forgotten how his party legislators had, in June 1986, dragged the then Speaker Surjit Singh Minhas from his chair. In the melee, Minhas’ turban had come off. Badal never apologised for that. Now, he is shedding crocodile tears… the entire drama was enacted by the SAD and AAPSunil Jakhar, PPCC president
I have never seen such a brazen display of brutality unleashed against elected representatives, and that too in the temple of democracyBir Devinder Singh, former Deputy Speaker
Turban is the pride of a Sikh. It is unfortunate that turbans are tossed at a place from where the elected members enact laws and take vital decisions for the state. The incident is condemnable. I demand stern action against the marshals involved in the actGiani Gurbachan Singh, Akal Takht jathedar
OTHER HAPPENINGS
Nagra vs MajithiaA heated exchange took place between former Revenue Minister and Majitha MLA Bikram Singh Majithia and Congress legislator Kuljit Singh Nagra. Majithia wondered what level of studies Nagra had pursued for 12 years at Panjab University. The latter retorted, “I have five degrees and you don’t even have a diploma. In fact, you have nothing except your brother-in-law Sukhbir Badal. Í am proud to be a self-made man”. Not impressed by his claims, Majithia repeatedly asked the Congress leader to spell “proud”. TNSProbe into land scamThe CM ordered an inquiry into the alleged multi-crore rural land scam in Fatehgarh Sahib by the Gram Panchayat, Jheurheri. He was intervening on a call attention notice raised by Mohali MLA Balbir Singh Sidhu regarding the purchase of land at almost double the prevailing market rate. Sidhu informed the House that officials did not seek sanction from the competent authority before purchasing the land. Crores withdrawn were spent only on paper instead of being utilized for actual development works. Thus, a VB should be ordered, he demanded. TNSSports kit distribution to be investigatedChief Minister Capt Amarinder Singh has promised a thorough probe into alleged irregularities in the distribution of sports kits among the youth clubs under the then SAD-BJP rule. The assurance came from the Chief Minister in the Vidhan Sabha on Thursday in response to a question asked by Congress MLA Rajinder Beri during question hour. TNSTight security in placeAdditional security was deployed at the Vidhan Sabha. Specialised police teams, such as SWAT, were present inside the House. A posse of cops was deployed at the entrance for MLAs. The watch and ward staff, right after they had thrown out the AAP MLAs, were seen flocking Chief Minister Capt Amarinder Singh, touching his feet for blessings. TNS
Marshals injured too
- Amanjot Singh, a marshal, suffered an arm fracture in the scuffle at the Vidhan Sabha, while Harjit Kaur,a constable from themarshal staff, lodged a complaint with theSpeaker against an AAP MLA, accusing him ofhitting her and tearing her shirt. A spokesperson for the Vidhan Sabha said AAP MLAs broke the arm of Amanjot when he was trying to stop legislators from advancing towards the chair of the Speaker.
